ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



Get it done, Goodell

Posted: Wednesday, June 13, 2007 11:45 PM

Where in the name of humanity is Roger Goodell?

 

You've probably read or heard about the war of words going on between former player and coach Mike Ditka and the NFL Players Association.

 

It's getting ugly, with former Bears player Dave Duerson, who is a member of the league's benefits board, accusing his former coach of not caring about players when he was leading the Bears and saying his group does plenty for disabled former players. Gene Upshaw, the head of the NLFPA, has been calling some of his own former constituents liars. Ditka is going on every media outlet that will have him demanding that someone do something for players who have been maimed by the game.

 

The poster player of the moment is Brian DeMarco, a former Jaguars offensive lineman who can't stand up without assistance, has been reduced to periods of having to house his family in a self-storage unit, is in his mid-30s, and gets virtually no help from the league or the union.

 

It's ugly and mean-spirited, especially on the union side. Upshaw has his health, his mental faculties and an enormous salary, and he's saying that guys who can't walk or work should be happy with the scraps the system throws them.

 

If you haven't cried for a while, read this story about what's become of John Mackey, the former All-Pro tight end for the Colts. He's in his mid-60s and has dementia. He's hardly the only one. His wife knows of at least 20 former NFL players in the same condition.

 

The NFL won't pay these players disability because they say it can't be proved that their dementia is the result of playing football.

 

In DeMarco's case, Upshaw brags about helping the player out with about $9,500 in help for rent – over a period of years. DeMarco, who once earned about a million dollars a year, says he's been wiped out by medical expenses.

 

Let's go back to the first sentence of this piece: Where is Goodell? He's the NFL commissioner, the man who can make things happen, the man who can slap the owners around and call a conference with the union and demand that something be done.

 

We are talking multi-billion dollar industry here. And we are talking about men who have given everything to the game. And they can't even get health insurance?

 

I know benefits cost money, but this borders on the criminal. The least the league can do is make sure that former players have medical coverage.

 

DeMarco's body was destroyed in the line of duty. The NFL used him. It has an obligation to help him and ever player who's been reduced to poverty by injuries.

 

This is no time to be arguing about what role football had to play or debating whether middle-aged guys with dementia got it through football. You get hit in the head repeatedly, you get punch drunk.

 

It's Goodell's job to take command. It's the union's job to stop ignoring the people who built the game. It's the current players' duty to take care of the people who made their salaries possible.

 

And it's way past the time to call a former coach and founding member of the NFLPA names simply for demanding what everyone should have by right – justice.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

just another case of big business and big labor in bed with one another, and who suffers?...the small guy! goodell and upshaw although they are in charge now are just symptoms of a long standing problem of greed and power in a few hands.
It's amazing and somewhat surprising because the illlusion is that the NFL has changed over the years to be become more player-friendly with better salaries, bonuses, etc. However, these issues could be part of a Pete Gent novel. I would urge anyone who doubts some of the validity of these claims to go back and read North Dallas Forty andor a less highly acclaimed but in many ways a better book The Franchise. That's also by Pete Gent. He tells a subplot about the Union absconding w/ the Players pension funds! It's riveting stuff. I don't recall the specifics but it speaks to what the league was like in the 60's and 70's and how evidently it may actually be worse now. There's some real divide/conquer stuff going on over there. This also speaks to a larger issue of private health care. Ultimately, the provider is in the for-profit business and as such is compelled to try to deny claims. The system reeks!! Not just for the NFLPA but for all of us. That's the bigger issue. I know, Joe Montana has some grievance with the NFL as well and didn't appear at some ceremony because of that.
Of all the times Congress has held (or has been threatening to hold) hearings on sports related matters, THIS seems like the kind of issue to possibly do so with. Much more important than the status of steroids in baseball...
Great article.You hit it on the head,Just so you know Mike Ditka,Jerry Kramer and and a host of hall of famers have started gridirongreats.org to step up and help players on need.
Mike,

When referring to John Mackey or any other Baltimore Colt it is imperative to say that player played for the Baltimore Colts; not the Colts.  There is a big difference.  As a New Yorker you know that Jackie Robinson played for the Brooklyn Dodgers, not the Dodgers.    
Lady justice is blindfolded and so is the union and NFL hierachy. Actually, more like the three monkeys...See no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil just ignore it.
You're right.  If not for the DeMarcos, Duersons, etc., the players today would not be making the money they are today.

Can't the players of today picture themselves in the positions these former players are in (needing health care/insurance)someday?

Oh, I know, it can't possibly happen to me.  I'll invest my money, I won't get sick or injured, I'll have all these resources when I'm through playing!!!  Well, wake up.  It can happen & has happened to these unfortunate people.  Remember, they are, after all, human beings not ex-jocks.
It's time for the union & the league, both of whom have reaped the benefit of these former players' efforts,both on and off the field!!  

DO THE RIGHT THING NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!
Like any other business, employees get used up and spit out. I think Goodell must demand benefits be paid.
Bond Brady:  Get over yourself.  The Colts are the Colts no matter where they play.  I'm assuming you're from Baltimore and are still stinging over that Super Bowl victory in their new and better city.

Anyway, here's my question-why has Gene Upshaw not been removed from his post?  He's proven completely inefficient at his job, and focuses on the wrong topics.  The union forced the Raiders to cancel the rest of their camp because some millionaires whined about having to do some weightlifting, but former athletes ravaged by the game when salaries were nothing like today can't get any help?
I agree, millionaires should be made to weightlift on principle - all of 'em, not just sports stars. Gene Upshaw should be made to run around Los Angeles with an aardvark on his back in a baby pouch and a clutch of stinging nettles down his trousers. I'll still be there watching them though, and I'll get my tickets at the usual place, ticketliquidator. Long live live sports!!!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=225509