ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



CWS, but no football playoff?

Posted: Friday, June 22, 2007 12:37 AM

We can't have a playoff in college football because it would make the season too long and compromise academics. That's what college presidents tell us every time they vote to perpetuate the absurd BCS system of not choosing a legitimate NCAA football champion.

So where are these guys now to complain about the length of the college baseball season? Oh, I forgot. school let out a month ago, and the presidents are probably in Switzerland or Vienna, recharging their batteries after a busy year of moral rectitude.

Meanwhile, college baseball goes on, with players who have already graduated and technically aren't even in school anymore still at least three days from ending the longest season in college sports.

USC played its first game this year at the end of January and its last game at the end of May.

Here's the schedule for Rice, which was finally eliminated Thursday in the College World Series semifinals. Note that the Owls' first game was on Feb. 3, more than two weeks before the major leagues began spring training and nearly five months ago.

North Carolina, which beat Rice to get to the finals, started play on Feb. 16.  Oregon State, the other team in the finals, started play on Jan. 25 – in Hawaii, which isn't a bad road trip. After four games in three days in Hawaii, the team came home, then few to Georgia for three days ending on Feb. 11. Five days later, the Beavers were in Arizona for another three-day weekend. The following Friday, it was a three-day trip to Southern California. Then it was out to Texas for four days.

This sort of schedule continues to the end of May, with teams playing about 14 games a month for a total of 70 or more on the season, including playoffs. You have to figure pre-season practice starts well before the first game, so we're talking about a six month season that continues well after school's out.

And the college presidents think that the football season's too long?

In football, you've got 12 or 13 games in just over three months, with at least half of those games at home, meaning that teams travel only five or six Fridays a year, come back to campus on Saturday night, and have a day off before classes resume on Monday. Then there's five to seven weeks off before one bowl game.

And the presidents tell us that's too much.

But the baseball schedule is just right. Every weekend is Friday-Sunday games with a few Mondays and Tuesdays thrown in, and maybe a Thursday here and there. And when they're not playing, there's practice.

The beginning of the season is ridiculous for the cold-climate teams, with long plane flights every Friday to get to the warm-weather opponent, a long trip back Sunday night, and then classes on Monday.

I'm not going to say it's too much season, because I'm not playing it. But I am saying that if you can play baseball for five months and continue almost until July, then you can darned well have a football playoff.

And if you don't want to have a football playoff, at least have the decency to say it's about the money and don't preach to us about the importance of academics and the welfare of the student-athletes. If you're worried about the kids, why play them during their vacation, the only time they're allowed to get a job and make a little money? Why play them so long the kids who are drafted into the pros arrive late for the beginning of the paying careers?

 

It's about the money. Just like football.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

THANK YOU!  I have noticed this discrepancy for a long time now.  Glad you pointed it out.  I wish they'd think of the fans for a change, and guess what?  They'd get more money with a playoff in football.  If it's about the money, I wish they'd think about *that* money.  
Excellent points.   The BCS is all about the money, everybody knows it.  The university presidents are a bunch of hypocrites.
When the CWS gets major sponsors like Nokia, FedEx and AT&T, college president will take a lot more interest in their wellbeing and academic concerns.
Hey, go ahead and slam college football and the BCS for not having a playoff determine a real champion.  But leave college baseball alone.  It's great as it is.  Don't let college baseball be ruined by some fat cat looking for more money or some school near the Canadian border that wants to wait until it's 75 degrees in their town to start baseball season.
You obviously never played both sports, or even sports at all...I regularly played double-headers even as a little leaguer, no problem.  After evan a high school football game, you can hardly walk for days, which is why pros take such pleasure when the coach tells them "come in on Wednesday".  Ever seen the tape of Jerome Bettis inching backwards down the stairs because he was so beat up?  They are not comparable.  

Sports writing must be one of the only professions where you can have absolutely no experience and yet give your opinion as if you were an expert.  You will moan about no college playoff, then in the next sentence criticize the same schools' graduation rates. A former college athlete and high school national merit scholar, I was forced to change majors because I was gone every weekend and missed labs.  You try studying on a dark bus and in a hotel room - not quite the study carroll you used in college, huh?

Your next piece of "news" will probably berate the teams for not caring about the health of their players after their career, when we have used them up for your playoff pleasure.  Sad...you all want to be Woodward and Bernstein...
Well, let's remember that baseball can be played on consecutive days, if necessary.  Football requires a week or so of recovery, etc.
Why wouldn’t this work?

This playoff system would require only six additional games:

2nd weekend of December (quarterfinals) highest seeded teams play at home
1 vs 8
2 vs 7
3 vs 6
4 vs 5

3rd weekend of December (semifinals) highest seeded teams play at home
1 vs 4
2 vs 3

New Years Day Bowls and Championship Game:
These teams would have played in a Bowl Game or BCS regardless of a playoff, so it’s not an extra game.

The losers (4) of the quarterfinals, the losers (2) of the semi-finals, and the 9th & 10th seeded teams just missing the playoffs are paired on New Year’s Day in the four major bowls, providing quality Major Bowl match-ups, and providing each team with the opportunity to win its final game.  The remaining two teams play in the BCS Championship Game the following week.      

The revenue (significant!!) generated by these six games could be shared by the participating conferences.  These conferences would still be entitled to their Bowl and BCS shares.

I am tired of hearing about college football playoffs and the BCS. The reason that we do not need a playoff or even a championship game is simple. It keeps interest in college football all year long. I love the debate over who is best. the last thing we need is a playoff. It will be like the NFL, where no one even talks about who is #1. It's the Colts. Lets keep the debate alive, and the sports bar trash talk going.
BCS football is to SEC football what green is to money. Aruguably more than any other conference the SEC would not receive nearly the green for a post season playoff system that they do for BCS play/pay. This explains why Florida's Bernie Machen was silenced into submission after the SEC presidents meeting. "Shut up Bernie! You want to be able to pay for all your toys? Then shut up!"

This proves that NCAA football is addicted to money like the U.S. is to oil. At this point all those songs about money start running through my head and they don't stop echoing but instead build with each reverberation to a crescendoing orgasmic cry of "BCS! BCS! BCS!"

Even though the majority of fans give lip service to wanting a true playoff system it's not going to happen until they stop feeding the beast. The beast is the gorged TV/BCS money pit. As long as the fans continue to watch and bet on the now five BCS games, which by the way was a brilliant move to add in the underdog game and what better way to silence that big minority than to give them a spot on the national stage, the playoff system is doomed to the greed of money.

This is the only way the playoff system stands a chance is that the fans put their money where their mouth is and a business plan is made to prove it would make more money for the big conferences and TV than the current vagary. Well, that and enough money to silence the few who would lose out on money in any shift from the status quo, i.e. the SEC presidents.

How's that go again? "Money, its a gas.
Grab that cash with both hands and make a stash.
New car, caviar, four star daydream,
Think Ill buy me a football team."


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=232973