ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



22 reasons for Quinn to end holdout

Posted: Friday, August 03, 2007 5:45 PM

I have for years taken pride in saying that Notre Dame doesn’t admit dummies. That’s self-serving coming from a Domer, but I’ve always believed it to be true.

 

But Brady Quinn is destroying that little truism.

 

The quarterback who led Notre Dame to zero bowl victories – he did set a bunch of passing records, though – and went from Heisman Trophy candidate to the 22nd player taken in the NFL draft, was going to show the world this year that he’s better than the personnel directors thought he was.

 

He’d be in Browns’ camp doing that right at this very moment, except for one minor problem: he won’t sign a contract.

 

Quinn’s reasoning makes less sense than a syllogism I found carved on a Notre Dame desk top lo, those many years ago:

 

Nothing is better than God.

Warm beer is better than nothing.

Therefore, warm beer is better than God

 

He thinks he should have been drafted in the top five picks, so he wants to be paid according to where he thinks he should have been drafted rather than by where he did get picked.

 

By that logic, if you think you should be the company CEO instead of a mail-room clerk, you should demand a CEO’s salary. If you don’t get it, you should boycott work.

 

It’s particularly dumb because Quinn was drafted by the Browns, a team that has clear starter at quarterback. It does, however, have two other candidates – Charlie Frye and Derek Anderson. Had Quinn signed for whatever is the going rate for 22nd picks, he’d be in camp staking his claim to the starting position. Instead, he’s staying at home, working his way down the depth chart and into a great job as a clipboard holder.

 

Cleveland fans were happy when their team traded with Dallas to get the 22nd pick and rescue Brady from the draft’s green room, where the cameras kept showing him trying to act as if he wasn’t disappointed to see his stock falling faster than Congress’ approval ratings.

 

Now they’re just ticked. Cleveland is rightly described as a blue-collar, lunch-bucket city, and people who work their backsides of at grueling jobs just to get enough money together to dress up like dogs and cheer the local football team have no patience with greedy, hold-out jerks.

 

Something called “The Sideline Show” discovered that during his holdout, Quinn was signing autographs – the show claims he was charging for them – at Cleveland-area mall. With more passion than grammar, the site says: “The Chosen one or the dumb one now let me get this right reports are saying that Brady Quinn has an autograph session in Cleveland Ohio at a mall. Quinn was charging the Cleveland Browns fans money to sign autograph jerseys.”

 

With considerably more eloquence, Terry Pluto, an excellent columnist for many years at The Akron Beacon-Journal, wrote an open letter to Quinn, telling him to quit being a knucklehead and start proving he’s as great as he thinks he is. An excerpt: “Do you realize that your holdout makes it seem like you have an overblown sense of entitlement? That you not only are hurting yourself by holding out, but also not helping the team that saved you from even a bigger free-fall in the NFL Draft?

 

“Brady, the Browns picked you at No. 22.”

 

Quinn apparently is also hurting the Kansas City Chiefs, who, writes Fanhouse’s Michael David Smith, can’t sign the 23rd pick in the draft, wide-out Dwayne Bowe, who is waiting to see what Quinn gets before deciding on his own contact.

 

Way to go, Brady. You’re embarrassing your school, sucker-punching your own career, ticking off all of Northeast Ohio and keeping K.C. from getting all its players on board.

 

All because Quinn can’t count to 22.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Beautiful!!!  What an arrogant idiot !!!!
Brady can't sign till Jamarcus signs, he sets the scale. Do some research next time.
I couldn't agree more with your "blue collar" assesment about the fans in Cleveland. That's exactly why guys like Joe Thomas will be loved forever by Browns fans.
i know they wont, but the browns should just walk away from the table and forget all about brady quinn...i would like to see the reaction on his face if that happened...i'm so sick of these rookies and their hold outs
Do not give me this joe lunchbucket crap. I do not care how hardworking people in Cleveland are, they will pay the jacked rates to go see a Browns game. Quinn may have been drafted 22nd, but he was the number 2 quarterback in the draft and I will always be proud of him. As far as the bowl games are concerned, I never heard Brady complain about how god awful his line was or how he had to carry the Irish on his shoulders. Frankly, Peyton manning would never have won a bowl game against lsu or ohio state under those conditions.
A poorly written article (but I do agree Quinn is wrong).
one word - OVERRATED.  Good luck Brady - I'm sure the fans will be very fogiving when you start losing games (if and when you get snaps in games that matter).
you're a hater buddy.  As a journalist, you shouldn't put personal biases in your articles.  
Quinn's a smart man, he knows exactly what he is doing
Thank goodness my Raiders picked Russell instead !!!!!!!!!!
This guy Bob, Dayton News Journal, called Quinn a punk for holding out.  I believe he should have looked up the definition prior to writing his article.  I prefer to call him brilliant for allowing his agent do the talking.  Maybe sportswriters would be smart to hire an agent to negotiate  their contracts for better paying jobs and salaries.  I'm not sure how they would stack up with Quinn's intelligence and performance.  He has paid the price to get where he is.  Would you and your readers not do the same if you were walking in his shoes?  You do not have to like or love Notre Dame but give the young man a chance to perform.  Who knows, he may be a keeper?  I for one hope he does well and earns his money. I've never been a Cleveland fan but I may now become one.  If any of you would like to send me your season or game tickets, I would be happy to attend the Browns games.
Many times, you\'ll get bogged down by the colossal sum of travel intelligence attainable.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=303947