ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



Lucky enough to catch the ball? Keep it!

Posted: Tuesday, August 07, 2007 11:54 PM

Two historic baseballs left the playing field in a space of four days. Alex Rodriguez’ 500th at Yankee Stadium on Saturday and Barry Bonds’ record-breaking 756th on Tuesday. Both players would probably like to have the baseballs back. And they should have them – if they’re willing to pay hard cash.

We know more about A-Rod’s ball. That was caught by Walter Kowalczyk, of Trenton, N.J., who is thinking about law school and who doesn’t have a lot of money. The Yankees offered him a bunch of signed memorabilia in return for the ball, but Kowalczyk’s no fool. He’s hanging on to it and weighing his options. Sure, signed jerseys from Derek Jeter and Roger Clemens and who knows who else are swell souvenirs, but the ball could be worth $100,000, which goes a long way toward paying law-school tuition. And while the Yankees were offering signed stuff that costs the team very little, neither the team nor A-Rod were offering actual cash.

It was a similar deal for Phil Ozersky, the lucky man who caught Mark McGwire’s 70th and final home run of the 1998 season and sold it for $3 million. Neither McGwire nor the team offered that kind of money, so he put it up for auction. Ozersky was vilified in the local media and by other fans in St. Louis who thought he was being greedy and should have given the ball back to McGwire.

Silly, weren’t they?

When was the last time a superstar volunteered to take less money to stay with the home team and maybe help keep ticket prices down? All we hear from them is how they have to take care of their families. Well, fans have families, too. Who’s taking care of them?

Ever hear of Sal Durante? He was the lucky 19-year-old kid who caught Roger Maris’ record-breaking 61st home run in Yankee Stadium in 1961. Durante offered the ball to Maris.

“No, kid,” Maris told him. “Keep the ball and make yourself some money.”

Durante got $5,000 from Sam Gordon, a California restaurateur, plus a honeymoon trip to California. In 1961, that was a year’s income. But Maris’ advice is classic. Can you imagine a player saying that today?

Can you, for that matter, imagine A-Rod calling up Kowalczyk and offering a hundred grand? A-Rod could find that in the seat cushions of his couch, but instead he’s hoping Kowalczyk will just hand the ball over.

Whoever won the free-for-all for Bonds’ ball came out bloody. I kind of doubt he’ll want to hand the ball to Barry. Nor should he. If you win the lottery, you don’t hand the ticket back to the clerk who sold it to you. It’s the same with baseballs. You catch them, you keep them.

And then you sell them, because, like the jocks always say, you have to think about your family.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I hope the Murphy gets every cent from whereever he can. After all Bonds had admitted to roids and a few others. If McGuire's ball was worth 3 million back then this ball should fetch $5,000,000.00 if it gets a dime.
Who's going to beat it.Maybe A-Rod but very doubtful.Good luck Mr Murphy and enjoy your vacation.
Congratulations Matt Murphy!!!  It was well worth your scuffle.  Treat yourself like the athletes do & HOLD OUT as long as possible to get the most bang for your buck!!  Sam Gray
I agree keep it, UNLESS the ball is hit by Barry Bonds.  Then you throw it back!!!!!!!!!!
I'd trade it to Bonds for a ball signed by all Yankee players.
Great column.  I totally agree with your point on players take all the money they can to take care of their families, but fans have families too.  I hope this guy from New York makes a small fortune on his good luck.  
Mike,

Bonds is a disgrace to MLB and the human race and shouldn't be considered for Cooperstown because he cheated and you know it.  As for the ball sell it and enjoy the benefits that come from this fiasco and Bonds
Good luck with the money that you will make.Also if you ever want to just give the ball away I'll take the ball. Go Mets
Ebay my friend, Ebay.
I don't even care that Bonds cheated.  There's tons of other players cheating, too.  What bothers me is that he is such a classless individual.  Truly a waste of oxygen.
First off you know neither of those 2 egomaniacs are going to offer anything to fans who caught the balls. They are both so into themselves that they figure the fans owe it to them. Bonds has already said he does'nt want it
I think it's great that a Mets fan caught the ball in SF.  If either A-Rod (of whom I'm a big fan) or Bonds (who I despise) want the ball so much, they should fork over the $$$.  Otherwise, sell it to highest bidder.
With every ball that Bonds hits, this one gets less and less and less valuable.  He should sell it as soon as possible.
It is my greatest wish that this young man enjoy his treasure.  It is my greatest sadness that IRS feels the need to tax him on this event prior to his sale (which should be used to determine value).
Sell, sell, sell, after all it is just a baseball. And I'm no fan of A-Rod either, but when he breaks the record (which is pretty much gonna happen) Bonds ball will be worthless, because there will be Homerun King.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=308588