ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



Beckham is a soccer snoozer

Posted: Thursday, August 09, 2007 8:53 PM

It used to be that you had to do something to merit a lead story on the sports page. You know, win a game, contribute to a win, be involved in a big play, make a big error, strike out with the bases loaded in the bottom of the ninth. But then along came Michelle Wie, who had only to show up at a golf tournament to get the star treatment for doing nothing. And now we have her male equivalent, David Beckham.

 

He played the final 21 minutes Thursday night. That’s it. His team, the L.A. Galaxy, lost, 1-0. He kicked the ball a couple times, had a free kick. As near as I can tell from the story, that was pretty much it.

 

And it was a major headline.

 

Soccer fans are going to beat me up for this, and they’re welcome to do so, if that will help their insecurities. To them, I’m a yahoo who doesn’t understand the beautiful game, a loutish old flatus who won’t give soccer a chance.

 

Balderdash. I’ve been giving soccer more chances than Darryl Strawberry and Steve Howe had together for more than 30 years now. I went to a World Cup and found it highly entertaining, and I watched a lot of the last one, including all of the final. Good stuff.

 

But you’re never going to convince America that soccer has arrived simply because Posh Spice’s husband was able to run about the pitch for 21 minutes.

 

This is how the Associated Press chronicled his entry into the gane:

 

“The sellout crowd of 46,686 cheered when Beckham stripped off his warm-up jacket and T-shirt, displaying his bare chest in a steady rain as he prepared to enter. The three-time World Cup veteran, his hair closely cropped and stubble on his face, then put on his No. 23 jersey and replaced Quavas Kirk in the 72nd minute.”

 

What in the name of corner kicks is that all about? He can’t wear his jersey under his warm-up jacket? I should care whether he’s shaved or not? Is this a sport or a rock concert?

 

But wait, there’s an explanation: “Beckham’s appearance was the latest milestone in his move to the United States, a signing that has created unprecedented publicity for a league that hopes to elevate itself above niche status in a crowded sports landscape.”

 

Somebody throw some sawdust under that writer. He or she is starting to lose it.

 

I’m happy for American soccer. It’s a worthy sport and deserves its place in that crowded sports landscape. But sooner or later, Beckham, like Wie, is going to have to actually do something useful.

 

And the problem remains that he isn’t a guy who puts the ball in the net a lot. He’s a guy who sets up goals. I know that’s important, and I know how wonderfully he can bend the ball. But Americans who aren’t fans are going to turn to soccer games to see what all the hubbub is about, and they’re going to see fans cheering for a stubbly guy putting on his shirt, and shrieking with delight when he takes a corner kick. If the ball doesn’t go into the goal, those curious fans aren’t going to appreciate that kind of thing. They’ll just scratch their heads and

wonder what the heck all the fuss is about.

 

Beckham played! He took off his shirt! He kicked the ball! (Imagine anyone doing that in a soccer game.) Women swooned!

 

The Galaxy lost.

 

Call me when he does something. Meanwhile, I’ll go back to watching Michelle Wie missing cuts.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Please gime me a break. The guy played 21 minutes and you already ripping him and it's obvious from your comments that ur bias against soccer(football) but give the guy a chance and once he's healthy and playing 90 minutes then we will judge him accordingly. But for you to do so based on 21 minutes and him taking off his shirt is plain pathetic. Go ahead, watch Michelle Wie miss cuts. That sounds alot more fun, please!
Beckham has been at the top of his profession for the last 10 years, so to compare him to Michelle Wie is a little off. If soccer bores you so much then do us all a favor and stop writing about it.
"But Americans who aren’t fans are going to turn to soccer games to see what all the hubbub is about, and they’re going to see fans cheering for a stubbly guy putting on his shirt, and shrieking with delight when he takes a corner kick."

That's more than enough action to entertain most American TV viewers/sportsfans.

Beckham seems like a really decent bloke, so I wouldn't criticise him peronally. But he's never been -- and never will be -- a truly world class footballer.

Also, there are many players already playing in the MLS who are better footballers than Beckham.

But, in the shadow of Barry Bonds' pharmo-record, can we ever truly believe that American sports fans care anything for talent and sporting ability?

How many linebackers do anything even vaguely interesting in an NFL game? And what's the difference between Donovan McNabb throwing one more horrible pass and any footballer passing a ball rather than scoring a goal?

Nobody can say that the NFL games leave anyone giddy with excitement (between constant stoppages and Viagra ads.)

Indeed, the major reason for the NFL's TV success (and that's the measure of success for sports in the US, not the actual number of people playing those sports, which is led by TA! DA! soccer.) is that most of an NFL team's positions can be comfortably filled by fat people, thus indulging the fantasies of the NFL's equally fat spectators that one day they, too could (or could have been) a pro "athlete."

And don't get me started with baseball.  At least in soccer everyone keeps moving. In baseball the only things moving most of the time are the players saliva glands.

Give the guy time to recouperate and stop berrating and belittling his impact. He did not ask for the attention. He is just getting it. Save your glib remarks until he gets well. If by then he does not play well, you are off the leash to bark and bite. For now, just muzzle mouth and choke your barks.
Mike Celizic = Andy Rooney
Nothing wrong with this piece. I am a soccer fan, and would like to see the domestic game improve. Everyone should watch the US/Mexico tourney, Superliga 2007, underway right now, that has shown the potential of what  could and should become MLS play. That said Becks is the wrong superstar to bring to the USA. Instead, a ridculus amount of money should have brought Christian Ronaldo to L.A. that would put the MLS in national sports news, but not just for his good looks, but for stupifing moves that after seeing a few times, might just give a viewer reason to pause and watch next time the saw the L.A. kits on screen.
Um, I read the article, and it is NOT an 'attack' on Mr. Beckham.  The author admits to watching AND liking soccer...so what if David Beckham didn't 'ask' for the attention.....he's not out there telling the press to stop writing about him for every bowel movement he has either.  

The author of the piece was attacking the PRESS <AP> for their inane coverage of Mr. Beckham, not his undeniable skills as a player.

Geez....read the text next time and stop letting emotions determine your responses.
"Nicely Done!" Any sport where fans clap and yell 'Nicely done' and 'excellent cross' is just a step over from PoLo without the pony.
I thought Becks elevated the level of play on the Galaxy side for the short time he was on the field.  This shows great promise for the team and soccer in America.  I hope our young players going to europe will come home after no more than 2 years and raise the level of play.  But writers really do need to stop trashing the game, but at least that is publicity........
Let's see...no sexual abuse allegations, obviously no steroids, no dog fighting, no murders, no drugs, no DUIs...no way this guy qualifies as an American sports hero. And, he can string together several complete sentences.

Mike, you and your ilk please just keep fawning over the juiced-up illiterate louts that pass for sportsmen in the US sports marketing machine. We'll find our own heroes now and I'm sure Beckham will be among them.
It's cool if you don't like soccer, but why do you have to try to ruin it for people who enjoy it.  Even if Beckham turns out to be a bust, he's generated some interest in the MLS, which it needed. Funny that you don't find it "newsworthy," but wrote a column on it.  Of course, I'm just insecure because I disagree with you, right?
American Football - plenty of stops in play to get that can of cheez wiz or Bud Lite.  

American Baseball - you can get that Bud Lite or cheez wiz at any time because if you do miss something, the endless replays will cover it, giving illusion that there is "action" in the sport.

Soccer - No stops in play for the Nachos.  TV hates it for the lack of commercial time.
Becks is still not 100%.  It is not his fault he is getting all this media coverage.  He did some good things last night, and expect him to do more in the coming weeks.  In any case, MLS has only been around 12 yrs.  I think the league is leaps and bounds ahead of schedule compared to other leagues
The world stopped when Michael Jordon returned to the game after his baseball fling.  In fact, I believe his first at-bat in the minors was more chronicled than Beckham's entry into U.S. soccer.  

Beckham has a hurt ankle and only played the last 20 minutes.  What were you expecting?  Three bicycle kick goals and a game victory?  He's a big story.  He's an incredible athlete.  Let the man (and the sport) have a bit of publicity in this country.  It will quickly fade back into obscurity again and you can go on writing about football holdouts and baseball strikes.  
Mr. Celizic, it's you who I think is insecure by having to blunt the effect of any anticipated criticism of this column by exclaiming that you know you're going to get "beat up" for it.  

The bottom line is, you DON'T understand the game.  And I'm not even a die-hard soccer/football fan.  Beckham came into a game where he had shown deep frustration for his team not having performed well up to that point.  He energized everyone in the stadium, and he actually did have some nice touches.  He made an incredible pass from midfield to Landon Donovan, who was right outside the goalbox.  It just so happens that Donovan was thwarted by the DC goalkeeper.  I can go on, but the bottom line is, don't rip someone or something you're unfamiliar with.  Give Beckham and soccer a chance.
I went to my first MLS game this year.  After sitting through a 0-0 snoozer where there was one legitimate scoring chance, I realized I was right all along.  This sport is terrible.  Maybe I just don't understand all the details about what goes into a good game; then again, if it can't keep me and the other 18,000 people there awake (who were really only there to watch the fireworks),I don't want to.
Becks is an exceptional role model - he is drug-free, polite, fit and athletic.  If he encourages the youth of America to trade the chips, soda and video games for a game of soccer in the backyard, is that so bad?  Besides, I have no problem paying to watch a handsome, ripped Beckham him remove his shirt in the rain.  I certainly would not pay to watch you do that, Mike.  Yikes!
Don't blame soccer fans for this coverage, blame ESPN's decision to hype him to no end, to the point of fixing a camera on the bench and showing him either sitting or warming up on the sideline while the game is still going on!  And also blame the infotainment media who cares more about hyping Beckham, the icon, rather than Beckham, the player.

He only played 20 minutes on a still healing ankle, but you could see him directing traffic in the midfield, he had a nice free kick to the near post that met its target, and he made some nice through passes that hadn't been seen the entire game from his team until he got in there.

Give the guy a break.
I am a soccer fan; I grew up playing soccer in the late 70’s & 80’s. I follow the Premier League matches when I’m in the UK and when I can find them over here, they are exciting matches. I watched the majority of the world cup. Needless to say I am a soccer fan.

With that said I completely agree with Mike, Beckham is completely over hyped. Yes Beckham is a legend and deserves the title as well. His record in the Premier League is incredible. He truly is the “Michael Jordan” of soccer (i.e. great talent, well marketed and good personality). However Beckham is on the down slope of his career, he was kicked off the UK national team last year. Real Madrid was delaying his contact renewal. He is not the same player as he was earlier in his career. He is equivalent to Michael Jordan during his Wizard days.

It’s obvious there is interest in seeing him play, but people’s attention span is short. If he doesn’t help generate some exciting soccer Americans’ will tune out professional soccer … again.
Your commentary is a snoozer.  Why shouldn't it make headlines.  He is the biggest sports star in the world.  Bigger then Michael Jordan ever was.  And I am a Jordan fan.
Beckham is not only NOT the best player in the world, he's not even the best ENGLISH player!!

I would rate the top ten players in the world as:

1. Ronaldhino (Brazil, Barcelona)
2. Messi (Argentina, Barcelona)
3. Ronaldo, Chriatiano (Portugal, Manchester United)
4. Rooney (England, Manchester United)
5. Robinho (Brazil, Real Madrid)
6. Ballack (Gernamy, Chelsea)
7. Maldini (Italy, AC Milan)
8. Henry (France, Barcelona)
9. Drogba (Ghana, Chelsea)
10. Van Nistelrooy (Netherlands, Real Madrid)

In his era, Beckham played with better players (Roy Keane, Eric Cantona, Ryan Giggs at Manchester United, Zidane at Real Madrid, Owen and Rooney with England) and was only considered an average player on those teams. He disappointed on the national stage, never shone at the world cup, and was easily replaced by Manchester United.

He's only a brand. Nothing more.

If the US Soccer federation wants to promote the sport, bring some of the above players over!
So many people quickly forget that Beckham has been voted the best soccer player in the WORLD in 1999 (and runner-up twice).  This is the equivalent of A-Rod deciding to go play baseball 10 years from now for some second-rate league overseas.  He doesn't need our approval.  He's making an honest effort to bring talent to an otherwise talentless league, and hopefully other top stars from the big European clubs will follow.  Americans won't embrace soccer until they have the best of the game in front of them, and not just one great player.  
As I suspected, the subtle genius of a midfield playmaker like Beckham will be lost on the average American sports fan who only cares about big one-man plays like home runs and slam-dunks and trash-talking.
In his debut, Beckham quickly took control of his team from a central midfield position and looked dangerous each time one of his accurate and well-timed passes connected with one of his forwards. Throughout the media circus which was forced upon him Beckham, remains humble and grateful. A true sportsman. If you don't have the class to appreciate this, at least keep your negative comments to yourself and focus on Barry Bonds and other steroid monster athletes that will give you the type of sport you crave.
Soccer is for little girls.
I don't know why Americans are so adverse to this game.  It really is a lot of fun.  Beckham is an awesome asset.  Its almost as though Americans feel if they don't have an upperhand in a sport, they put it down.  Mind you, these are the same people who have world series baseball with only American teams.  Whatever.
So these current headlines from ESPN.com are more exciting why? Three headlines are legal issues and the rest are basically useless. I guess Beckham should do steroids or stab someone? Then he'd be worthy of headlines? I personally would rather read a headline about a player getting on the field than read about all their legal troubles off the field.  

   * Armstrong's Discovery Channel team to disband
   * NFL replay in HD: Referees to get sharper looks
   * Cubs' Ramirez won't go on DL, but wrist still hurts
   * Colts to look in-house for McFarland's replacement
   * Tour winner will provide DNA to prove he's clean
   * All the way back: Ankiel homers for Cards
   * Report: Spiezio voluntarily seeks drug treatment
   * Aaron says he might 'eventually' speak with Bonds
   * Clemens suspended 5 games for hitting Jays' Rios
   * Jury finds backup punter guilty in stabbing attack
Isn't it funny that somebody can make a living commenting about commentators? It's not that you're wrong but what are you being paid for, exactly?
You don't watch soccer for goals.  Yes goals are nice, and they detrmine the outcome.  But the sport, is broken down into plays within the game.  Like cheering for the 1st down in footbal, or a powerplay in hockey.

Beckham, is envolved in certain plays within a game, and he does them quite well.  I agree that the hype is way too much, but I am a soccer fan who never watched the MLS untill this week.  Instead I watched the Eurpean Teams.  Now, there are 2 high profile signings in the MLS (Juan Pablo Ángel - Red Bulls) and more to come.

So the circus created by your media peers is just something that we need to get through to help bring soccer to the American masses.
This article is more of a comment on the sad state of the media than it is about Beckham or soccer.
Not a bad piece at all. I've been playing and watching the game for decades and we all know that American soccer is a peculiar beast. In other words, something exciting [e.g. goals] has to happen for people to get excited. That's why FIFA changed the rules on offsides being even. That said, Beckham's debut here has been a great big yawn. It will be interesting to see how he does when his foot gets better. Let's just hope the stands are still full by then.
Beckham is just the first of the international superstars to be imported to America.  We Americans have a knack for buying everything that we want, and if Beckham starts playing like how he's paid, then MLS teams will want more international attention.  But for now, the media should cut him some slack and understand he's coming off an injury, and LA is very keen on protecting their investment for the next 5 years.  It would be a shame to have him injure his ankle again before he's able to play, just to satisfy an unwarranted media frenzy.
Well, the only thing accurate about your column is the description: offbeat. Perhaps it should say, "off-base." Your account of Beckham's performance is clearly from someone who doesn't understand the game. Maybe you should have mentioned how the Galaxy instantly seemed more organized and composed the second Beckham stepped on the field, or the brilliant pass to Donovan, or the amazingly perfect kick to Pavon who couldn't put in the header. Those are the things that enable teams to get goals and prevent the opponent from scoring, and are just as crucial as the goal itself. Why not help educate people about the game and enlighten peolple about what to look for in a player, like the seemingly (to you) small things Beckham did yesterday, rather than rant about trivial things like you have? Could it be because you don't have to make any effort that way?
Good article, and I do agree that the Michelle Wie analogy is completley wrong. I do think you underestimate the American soccer fan though. This country (as a whole) has enough of an understanding of the game to appreciate outstanding midfield play without trying to convert the performance to fantasy type statistics. No one is going to be disappointed about the lack of hat tricks.
"If the ball doesn’t go into the goal, those curious fans aren’t going to appreciate that kind of thing. They’ll just scratch their heads and wonder what the heck all the fuss is about."

That's because most Americans are idiots.
Did you watch the 21 minutes he was in the game? L.A. had three excellent scoring chances that were blown by shoddy, rushed finishing (the main problem of the MLS). I'm just wondering who on the Galaxy is going to put the ball in the net. Could be a frustrating tenure in L.A. for Beckham.
This article is written by yet another ignorant hater. Soccer is on its way to a steady rise in popularity in the US. MLS is barely 12 years young. It will be more popular than NBA in about another 10-15 years. Beckham, although not a great player, bring s amuch needed boost to the league. The quality of MLS is improving and it is normal for those who despise the game to be afraid.
Why will soccer make it here? One simple reason: demographics: America is changing and Latinos will become more and more influential in the country.
Regardless of the tone of the article, you know soccer is making inroads in the US when American sports writers finally use the word pitch instead of field.
I missed the game. I was busy watching paint dry.
Beckham is a great player, I am a huge Manchester United fan, I did not want to see him leave and go to Real Madrid. Now in LA (the new jerseys look just like Real). He will amaze us when he does play a full 90 with his skill at set pieces. The Superliga has been a very entertaining tournament. I would like to see other clubs from other countries compete with the Mexican league teams and the MLS. Hopefully Beckham will be healthy so everyone can see what Spain and England will be missing.
Mike, if you knew anything about soccer, anything at all, you would know that what the Galaxy got David Beckham for, he did exactly that in those 21 minutes. He is one of the best set up guys on the planet. His free kick into the goal square would have been in the back of the net in England or Europe. But in the US, the skill (and the understanding) is lacking to the point that it was hardly noticed. That's why he was so peeved after the kick - he knows that if he was at Real Madrid or at Man U, that's a goal. If you don't know about the game, or don't like it, then don't write about it and move on.
Mike, in mentioning that you are "probably going to get beat up by true soccer fans for what you are saying" you are clearly confessing that you do not have the knowledge or understanding of the game of soccer.  I mean no disrespect, but you are ignorant in writting about about something you have no idea about and as a journalist I think it's rather irresponsible of you to do so.  If you understood the game at all, you would have noticed several things, for one the energy that was apparant at RFK from the sole presence of Beckham.  Had no intentions of playing due to his injured ankle, despite of this he was taken up by the moment and made an appearance, for which the crowd went nuts about.  All things considered, I feel he played very well for the few minutes that he was on the pitch.  He made a few beautiful passes which gave us a glimpse of what is to come.  Soccer is at a turning point in this country, become is one of many more international superstars that will be put out to pasture in the states and will draw our sport to the masses.  This in combination with a strong American pool of talent, I strongly feel that people such as yourself are the ones that are truely insecure of what is to come in the next few years and are using your position to convince people otherwise.
Please do  not compare other sports to soccer .We all now by fact that soccer is by "far" the most popular and watch sport in the world .With no disrespect but can we compare the World series (baseball) with the World cup (soccer).The sport is growing ,no doubt,nobody will pay (invest)all those millions into a player like Beckham without expecting good results.Give soccer a chance or at least try.
You're right. Beckham is long finished as a europian football player. The last time I saw him with Real Madrid, he really seemed like a 45 year old veteran. I can't believe, how they are paying him hundreds of millions of dollars just to have him here. I've really come to the conclusion that Beckham is another example that "looks and fame" matter more than the actual talent a sport man has to have nowadays. I think hollywood is taking over the American Soccer League which is not a good thing for the sport.
You should watch Michelle Wii because you know nothing about soccer. As far as soccer goes, scoring goals are important as players who create them...like in football defense is as important as offense or in baseball pitching is as hitting, got it?
From a non soccer point of view, bringing Becks is a great move, since most people on this side of the pond know very little about players on that side. Personally I would have loved for Henry to come over. But then again, not a lot of people would really care. Becks has the notariety, so he attracts people. Yet, still he has to produce to make the rest of the States which does not know anything about soccer like the beautiful game.
Is Mike ragging on the super soccer star or the press who needed a story and thought to shove a big ole piece of nothing about soccer down out throats?  Soccer fans seem a little touchy.

GO MIKE!!!
But you are missing the point. Soccer is a team game and it Beckham's contribution that is so important, when he is finally fit. We don't deride Reggie White or Lawrence Taylor because they did'nt score TD's. They contributed to the teams victories by being a part of the team. Oh and on the subject of his goals, I guess the one he scored from the halfway line was just one we can all forget about.
Celizic is a never was.  All of his articles have a negative tone to them and really he says nothing.  I've tried to remove his articles from my personal msnbc page but they keep coming back.  Mike you certainly look old enough why don't you do us all a favor and retire.  

you have nothing worth reading to say anymore (not that I can confirm you ever did).

I am a soccer fan. A big one in fact. One that used to get irritated by articles like this. I don't think Beckham or the hype that surrounds him are what will bring Soccer to the forefront of sports. I don't any particular person will. Girls will come to games and watch on tv because he is cute, boys and men will tune in and show up to see if he can live up to the hype.

Soccer in the US has to keep doing what it has been doing. Improve the overall talent. Make the games exciting for the purist and the casual fan. Bring American soccer to the point where it can win championships outside of North and Central America.

I don't think the objective should be to make Soccer one of the three top American sports, it should be to make American Soccer one of the best soccer teams in the world. Its improving, but truthfully as much as a patriot as I am I will would still rather watch Mexican or South American Soccer than American.
To compare beckham to Michelle Wie is ridiculous.  Michelle Wie is a rookie who has yet to prove herself.  Her buzz is because of her age and look so far.  Beckham is also known for his look, but he hasn't come this far because of just his look.  He was a legend at Man.U. and anyone who actually watch his game will know that while he's not the BEST player, he's a real player who play his heart out and actually make a difference on the field!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=311921