ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

NBCSports.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



Beckham is a soccer snoozer

Posted: Thursday, August 09, 2007 8:53 PM

It used to be that you had to do something to merit a lead story on the sports page. You know, win a game, contribute to a win, be involved in a big play, make a big error, strike out with the bases loaded in the bottom of the ninth. But then along came Michelle Wie, who had only to show up at a golf tournament to get the star treatment for doing nothing. And now we have her male equivalent, David Beckham.

 

He played the final 21 minutes Thursday night. That’s it. His team, the L.A. Galaxy, lost, 1-0. He kicked the ball a couple times, had a free kick. As near as I can tell from the story, that was pretty much it.

 

And it was a major headline.

 

Soccer fans are going to beat me up for this, and they’re welcome to do so, if that will help their insecurities. To them, I’m a yahoo who doesn’t understand the beautiful game, a loutish old flatus who won’t give soccer a chance.

 

Balderdash. I’ve been giving soccer more chances than Darryl Strawberry and Steve Howe had together for more than 30 years now. I went to a World Cup and found it highly entertaining, and I watched a lot of the last one, including all of the final. Good stuff.

 

But you’re never going to convince America that soccer has arrived simply because Posh Spice’s husband was able to run about the pitch for 21 minutes.

 

This is how the Associated Press chronicled his entry into the gane:

 

“The sellout crowd of 46,686 cheered when Beckham stripped off his warm-up jacket and T-shirt, displaying his bare chest in a steady rain as he prepared to enter. The three-time World Cup veteran, his hair closely cropped and stubble on his face, then put on his No. 23 jersey and replaced Quavas Kirk in the 72nd minute.”

 

What in the name of corner kicks is that all about? He can’t wear his jersey under his warm-up jacket? I should care whether he’s shaved or not? Is this a sport or a rock concert?

 

But wait, there’s an explanation: “Beckham’s appearance was the latest milestone in his move to the United States, a signing that has created unprecedented publicity for a league that hopes to elevate itself above niche status in a crowded sports landscape.”

 

Somebody throw some sawdust under that writer. He or she is starting to lose it.

 

I’m happy for American soccer. It’s a worthy sport and deserves its place in that crowded sports landscape. But sooner or later, Beckham, like Wie, is going to have to actually do something useful.

 

And the problem remains that he isn’t a guy who puts the ball in the net a lot. He’s a guy who sets up goals. I know that’s important, and I know how wonderfully he can bend the ball. But Americans who aren’t fans are going to turn to soccer games to see what all the hubbub is about, and they’re going to see fans cheering for a stubbly guy putting on his shirt, and shrieking with delight when he takes a corner kick. If the ball doesn’t go into the goal, those curious fans aren’t going to appreciate that kind of thing. They’ll just scratch their heads and

wonder what the heck all the fuss is about.

 

Beckham played! He took off his shirt! He kicked the ball! (Imagine anyone doing that in a soccer game.) Women swooned!

 

The Galaxy lost.

 

Call me when he does something. Meanwhile, I’ll go back to watching Michelle Wie missing cuts.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Umm...you went to the world cup? That is giving soccer a chance? Give me a break. I guess you like the scoring in basketball more? Your biased and a poor reporter.
this article is a joke. The guy obviously does not like NOR understand soccer at all. You don't have to score 3 goals to "do something". It's Beckham's presence in the game, it's what he does that sets up goals. Give him a full game, and I guarantee you that he will play a part in at least one of the galaxy's goals that WILL be scored...Until then, just go back to being fat and watching baseball!
I've been wondering when someone is going to notice that there's all this press about a guy who is doing NOTHING.  

I'm so tired of hearing about him that I wish he would just go away.

Thanks for finally pointing out the obvious.
seems like a fair piece, and i'm a soccer fan.  beckham *did* ask for the attention when he signed the contract worth more than the rest of the MLS combined.  and as for critics pointing out "he's only played 21 minutes - give him a break" that's the writer's point exactly: he's only played 21 minutes, give us a break until he does play 90 minutes.  will he ever?
Beckham, who is recuperating from an injury and has a history of playing hurt to help his team, probably should not have played but did so anyway, when his team looked in trouble and was even a man down. I actually think you did not even watch the game since you missed most of the important things that happened in that loss. One other thing, no one in the world knows who you are compared to Beckham. The only reason many people are reading your column today is because you are writing about him. You should send him flowers.
Not that it matters in the overall scheme of things, but Beckham is a product of very successful PR.  Soccer is a wonderful sport that I know little about.  However, I have been given the understanding from more than one source that Beckham is a mediocre soccer player made into the superstar he is by his wife's star making machinery in operation when the Spice Girls were in swing.
It is all marketing. My sport of choice is soccer, love the game, and defended it coming to the Rosebowl so far back, can't remember when now.

But this shameless extravagance on a player who is not all that great makes me sick! But that is typical western/American value-less and capitalistic obsession.

I'm with you Mike.
You seem don't know very much about soccer. In Europe David Beckham is a very famous soccer player. Actually He is way beyond a soccer player, he is also a celebrity. Soccer is the world most popular sport; Even though he is now playing in the US, his fans from around the world still want to hear his news (ANY news about him).

I think the US especially MLS is very lucky for having David Beckham playing in this "tiny" league because he definitely will bring it to a different level.
You are correct.  Soccer will always be a "niche sport" in this country and this effort at glamorizing it is just a sad day for the MLS.
Open Mike is right! I mean, do you think Beckham came to the U.S to play soccer?? Just keep watching him from time to time, and you'll see what i'm talking about.
"Somebody throw some sawdust under that writer"...

If I had to draw anaolgies to Michelle Wie, I would probably cite Mike Celzic's "journalism", which, to be polite, I might call "a disgrace".  When an athlete performs at a sub-par level, the failure is apparent to even casual spectators.  I wish the same went for writing
This is an embarassing article. David Beckham is front page news because of the amount of money LA spent to bring him to the States and join the Galaxy, not to mention his decorated career. It's going to be a long time before any American team gets complete world notice, it's not going to happen immediately on his first game. And how is it a problem that he's more of a setter than a scorer? Everyone has their own specific assignment in soccer which makes it truly a team sport, the whole of which is greater than the sum of its parts. He'll do fine, just lighten up and enjoy the show.
Beckham = overrated. He's over his prime, and even at his prime he wasn't as good as some of the other soccer greats (Ronaldinho, C.Ronaldo, etc.) I concur that the MLS should have tried to bring someone else, not Beckham.
Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Thierre Henry, Didier Drogba, Wayne Rooney and many others are much more exciting to watch than Beckham.

The fact is, soccer fans are sophisticated and aren't going to fall for star power. Everyone else might, for a short time, but they'll be bored if they don't understand the game. MLS has tried to imitate Pro Wrestling or Nascar and throw some character flare in to spice it up. What they don't get is that those sports need to be spiced up because the skill levels are relatively low compared to comparable sports. Soccer is one of the most skilled sports in the world...no spicing up necessary.
Any press is good press.  The beautiful game can handle scrutiny and criticism.  It is bigger than one talented player on a bad team (that is fortunate relegation does not exist).  Keep writing about soccer!  The fact Mr. Celizic took the time to be critical shows progress in the development of the professional game here in the States.
The author is not belittling or ripping on Beckham.  He is not saying that he is a fraud cause he only played 21 minutes.  He is saying that him playing 21 minutes doesn't deserve front page headlines... which it doesn't.  Can anyone disagree with that?  That it isn't an exciting sport story?  
Wie and Beckham in the same sentence? I mean talk about a reckless and uneducated comparison! This comparison is on on par with me dropping your name in the same sentence as Charles Dickens, fine that was harsh, my emotions got the better of me.
He's playing in America because that is all he could get.
Bringing David Beckham to Major League Soccer is like the Canadian Football League signing Peyton Manning or the Chinese professional basketball league wooing away LeBron James. No matter how you slice it, Beckham playing his first game, whether as a starter or substitute, is worthy of lead story status.  

And the value of that lead story status for American soccer is, in my opinion, the ability to give occasional and willing fans, such as the author, an easily accessible oppurtunity to learn the ins and outs of the game and get past the only-goals-are-exciting mindset.  

My hope is that as Major League Soccer grows and the U.S. National Teams fare well in World Cups, more people will be come to pick up on the subtleties that comprise the beautiful game.  I thought Beckham's performance was admirable.  Nursing an injury, with his team down a goal and a man, he entered the game and proceeded to give his team a chance.  

So even if you didn't see it Mike, trust me, Beckham did more than just show up.  
"It used to be that you had to do something to merit a lead story on the sports page"

Thats pathetic that you say that, the guy has done plenty (on and off the field) to deserve front page news attention.  If you think that the debut of one of the worlds biggest sports stars isn't worth making the headlines, you should not be writing about sports.
I totally agree with you. I have been a soccer fan since I was a kid and my dad used to take me and my brother to the soccer games in my country of origin. Beckham has been blown out of proportion by the media and by the clubs he's been with because he sells a lot of jerseys. He is no ronaldinho nor messi. If the US soccer league wants to promote and establish itself as a reputable league within the US public it has to bring players that will recognized by their performance inside the field. I suggest people to follow fellow Colombian, Juan Pablo Angel, he is been scoring like no other and he is a wonderful player.
I think if the MLS is serious about elevating its play and profile in the world of football (not soccer) it wouldn't be at the feet of Beckham. The money spent on Beckham could have recruited 10 great players that could have been spread amongst at least 3 teams! This would create real synergy and competition but at the same time  elevate the level of play. Who is really benefiting from Beckham apart from Beckahm?  
There are at least three legitimate reasons he has so much hype. Firstly, although not the best all-around soccer player in the world, he is a good player and perhaps the best striker of free kicks, corners, and early crosses in the world.  

Secondly, he is perhaps the most recognizeable sports figure in the world (not necessarily in the U.S. though).

Thirdly, because he has decided to ply his trade in what the rest of the world considers to be a soccer back-water, a lot of people ar interested in seeing if he can raise the status of MLS.

And lastly, Mike did you actually watch the game?  If not perhaps you save your criticism.

Just like everything else, Beckham is going to be alternately ridiculed and praised far too much.  The truth is somewhere in the middle.  He simply didn't play enough to warrant all of the attention he got for last night's game.  However, his class on the pitch is obvious. The three or four times he touched the ball he managed to make things happen. Project that out over the course of a game or a season, and he will end up delivering. The writer clearly is on the "ridicule" end of the spectrum and is a bitter old grump. Step aside old man.
If you don't understand the game why are you writting about it?
"What in the name of corner kicks is that all about? He can’t wear his jersey under his warm-up jacket? I should care whether he’s shaved or not? Is this a sport or a rock concert?"
Agreed...... but i dont think Lexi Lalas signed him for Modeling and I am sure he won't get away with again.

Side note:  I agree with everyone else, don't write about something you cannot stand to watch - and please do some of us a favor - don't wait by the phone for your call.
I agree with your assessment of Beckham's impact on the game. Even during his prime, he was, at best, a tier 2/3 soccer player...and was courted more for his looks, glamour than actually soccer-playing talent. Americans are so gullible and riduculously susceptible to being swayed by Beckham removing his warm-up jacket (during rain!), changing the color of his hair...attending glamorous hollywood parties etc. I firmly believe that soccer will not take hold in the US until it gets beyond the likes of Becks and Landon Donovan and the soccer mom crowd that look at soccer as a status symbol....A place to see and be seen...in that new SUV. Look to the likes of Adu and other inner city soccer players to do for US soccer what Michael Jordans, Alan Iverson, LaDanian Tomlinson and a host of other less priveleged youths did for the NBA, NFL, and MLB...Until then, we will be an-also run in international soccer tournaments and the graveyard for old has-been soccer players like Becks...
Anna Kournikova is one of the most celebrated tennis players in history. More people know her than know Graf and Seles, the best women players ever. But, Anna has never won a major - wait a minute - Anna has never won ANY tournament EVER. Unfortunately, sports are about the sport and sports are about the personalities that play the sport. Being a pompous soccer-hater is not cool. Beckham is still injured. He led his former team to a title in Spain (you know where that is, right?) He pulled off one of the greatest come-from-behind victories in the 1999 Champion League final. He will do incredible things; he's just injured. CHILL!
Points taken but soccer still is at the bottom of the barrell in U.S. sports, and most likely always will be. Americans want to see big scores and spectacular plays, not a bunch of sissy nannies kicking a ball at mid-court. Soccer is fine, it should just stay out of the US
As predicted, all the hypersensitive soccer wonks freaked out over this piece. The gist of which is, Beckham has done nothing since coming to America and he gets headlines. The columnist thinks that is wrong. Just like he thinks it is wrong that Michelle Wie gets headlines without any accomlishment.
There is no need to defend soccer or David Beckham's past. This column is a condemnation of the American Sportwriting establishment and their infatuation with stardom, e.g., ESPN's recent horrific "Who's Now" segment, rather than accomlishment.
Hey c'mon. He is still very much injured! You can't expect him to score 3 goals in the space of 21 minutes. We need to give him some more time to recover. He is still a human being and you can not expect him to be on top of his game every weekend.
You are right on! Beckham is a great soccer player, but, he's also past his prime. He had his great moments, and is basically out to pasture here in the US....where the media is fawning over his (and his stupid wife's) every move. YAWN. It's as boring as TO...he sucks but you'd think he was the best receiver in the NFL with all the attention he gets. He didn't do much last year, and won't every do much again.
Celizic you are a baseball fan and you are making your comments based off another writer's report of how the game went?  What Beckham did was the equivalent to Tom Glavine coming off of the DL to pitch the 7th inning.  That's it.  It seems that your issues are with the writer and not with Beckham.  Go back to watching juiced up Bonds and kissing the bum of an ineffective commissioner who's more worried about not stepping on the toes of his players instead of banning the lot of them for doing something as bad as Rose, Shoeless Joe, and that dumb jerk ref in the NBA.  Because yes, juicing is the equivalent to point shaving and betting on your own games.  Long live the Footy!
These might be the funniest and most pathetic group of "fanboy" comments I have read on this site. Give it up soccer fans; your elitism doesn't play here in the States.  Most of us grew up playing soccer at some point of our lives and then anyone that showed any athletic skill/talent shuffled to one of the "exciting" sports.  That is the way it is and until someone figures out how to make the sport more exciting then watching grass grow-- the way it will be going forward.  Beckham will be nothing more then a blip here in the States.  Get over yourselves already and go watch some real football.
I don't think the writer of this article is truly criticizing Beckham as much as he is pointing out how ridiculous the media has been.  Most people who know soccer (football)know what to expect from Beckham but the non soccer fans that tune in to see what the hype is about will be disappointed because they don't know anything about soccer.  They will expect Beckham to be like Michael Jordan and be the leading scorer.
Another overpaid athlete who does nothing but draw attention to himself.  He will not be the savior to soccer in America.  Soccer will never be anymore popular than it is right now.  I bet when it comes time to play for his home country, he will be injury free.  The only reason so many people play soccer is so they do not have to watch it.
Cristiano Ronaldo playing in the MLS?!? Hahaha...what a joke. Maybe in 15 years, but right now there's no reason why (arguably) the best player in the world, entering the prime of his career, would even entertain the idea. Beckham was once a world-class player, but his career is on the decline. That said, he is by far the best player MLS has right now.
But yet here you are writing about both Beckham and Wie.
"Also, there are many players already playing in the MLS who are better footballers than Beckham. "

Just not on the LA Galaxy (and that includes Landycakes). There's a reason the Richmond Kickers knocked them out of the Cup--they're a better team.
This whole Beckham sensation has been sold for months, and then he arrives and....21 minutes??  That's it??  You soccer apologists need to wake up.  It's not my fault he was lauded so highly, and he's not going to do jack.  That's ESPN's & his publicist's fault.  Don't make the reality T.V. shows, and talk about him every 5 seconds, if you don't want people to criticize him for not playing.  It take's a big ego for him to think he can single handedly revive soccer in America.  

Let's hope that ego doesn't bruise as easily as his ankle.  BENCH IT LIKE BECKHAM!!
I played soccer as a youth and agree that it is pretty damn boring to watch.  Though, it's really fun to participate in.

In addition, I recall seeing Beckham take and make a few great shots.  I think he's pretty good.  But, is he worth millions of dollars?  Probably not.

Part of what Beckham will bring to the game is more women who will watch soccer.  His sheer looks will bring in more fans...so I have no problem with looking at his bare chest.  Even if he doesn't score any goals it doesn't matter to me as long as I can watch him on the field.  Soccer is truly an exciting sport and I thouroughly enjoy it, but from a woman's perspective, if I can see some eye candy, why not...he's worth the money.  Oh yes, I also think he's a decent player.
So to recap the arguments made here:

1. Soccer in American has not "arrived" just because Beckham has come to the MLS

While I agree, nobody said it was supposed to. Not the MLS or the fans at least. It is only really ESPN and writers like you that are putting far too much emphasis on the arrival of one guy.

2. Beckham hasn't done anything useful and therefore you are uninterested in the sport and in Beckham. Plus, the Galaxy lost.

This is by far the most ridiculous point of your article. You are bashing the guy for not scoring or making something happen for the 15+ minutes he was on the field. You don't even mention the fact that he came on just after the Galaxy lost a man to go 10 versus 11. You also don't mention that he completely took control of his team once he stepped onto the pitch and set up three plays that could easily have been goals if his teammates were even slightly more competent.

3. If Beckham doesn't score goals, the casual viewer won't be interested.

This is probably true. But that same viewer probably wouldn't be captivated by anything less than complete and total domination of the league by Beckham. People who enjoy sports and enjoy competition will eventually make a decision on whether or not they like the game. Many already have. If they do decide they like the game, good for them. If not, they won't watch. The important thing is that the MLS is doing enough to make its fans happy and more and more people are starting to enjoy the product that they put out.

It is clear that you are upset about all of the hoopla surrounding Beckham which hasn't materialized into anything exciting on the field. I agree, but rather than bashing Beckham or the MLS, maybe you should point the finger at your own colleagues who are the culprits behind the over-exposure.
soccer may be fun to play, but watching it is akin to watching paint dry.  they can bring over all the washed up europeans they want, it won't change a thing.  the idea that "becks" will somehow invigorate soccer in the US is about the same as troy aikman going to europe to make them fall in love with american football.  plus, all this hoopla over his so-called beautiful wife - i could walk out on the beach right now and see five better looking women.
I am a soccer fan from way back, but the gae here is ruined for me by the announcers. They don't talk about the game, but analize con stantly. they could learn something from the Britsh and Mexican reporters
I happen to love the MLS and have followed it since the incept. I think Beckham is a nice addition but he will never be the reason I go to a game. DC United is the reason I go.

"But you’re never going to convince America that soccer has arrived simply because Posh Spice’s husband was able to run about the pitch for 21 minutes."

Soccer has arrived because DC United has been averaging 20k in attendance without Sir David, superliga is a good tv draw, ESPN now pays to broadcast soccer, 7 soccer specific stadiums and an entire generation of kids have grown up supporting it. Nobody cares if you like it or not, or whether it'll be anything more than the #4 sport in the US. It's successful and a good product.
  Soccer fans tag you because they wonder why hockey, as the former #4 sport never caught half the derision and scorn from sportswriters like you that soccer does. Why is that? An easy 4 columns? Red meat to the America #1 crowd? Lazy journalism?
Stop beating up soccer. The sport is fine (most popular in the world I remind you); I'm sorry you don't get it. The problem is the MLS bringing the aging stars you not only are not at their prime but stunt the growth of US soccer. Guess who sits when we bring Beckham or Angel to the U.S.? The young budding star who will ride the bench 2 or 3 years without really learning anything.  Bring the young stars from Latin America or Europe here to make us better. For the amount of money you pay Beckham you could have gotten almost anyone under the age of 30.
Beckham is still a world-class footballer.  It just so happens he is competing with one of the weakest sides in the MLS and he's not 100% yet -- the jury is still out!

I hope football improves in the US, but in the interim if you want to see some real football the English Premier League season begins this Saturday ...
That was a brilliant OpEd piece.  With OpEd being the operative word.  It's an opinion.  Atleast the author is making an attempt at understanding soccer.  I just don't get it myself.
Beckham who?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=311921