ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



Weis won't let the terrorists win

Posted: Friday, August 24, 2007 7:08 PM

I know that college football is more than just a game, maybe more than life itself. It’s the reason colleges were built – to serve as homes for football teams. So I’m not going to be the one running around saying that there are other things in life more important than football, because there aren’t any, including breathing and eating and going to the bathroom after six beers.

 

So I guess I can’t get on Charlie Weis’ case for pulling a Dick Cheney on reporters who asked him who his starting quarterback is going to be when Notre Dame opens against Georgia Tech. Yep, Weis said, he has picked a starter from among Evan Sharpley, Demetrius Jones and Jimmy Clausen. And nope, he ain’t telling us who it is.

 

He can’t tell us because if he does, the terrorists will win. Besides, that information is protected by executive privilege.

 

This is true coaching genius that he could have learned only at the knee of Bill Belichick, the Patriots coach who is the original public relations black hole – information goes in and never comes out. He’s got three potential quarterbacks, none of whom have started a college game, and he doesn’t want the Yellow Jackets to know which of the quarterbacks they know nothing about is going to start the first game.

 

It’s the old element of surprise. It’s such a surprise, in fact, that even the quarterbacks don’t know which one is going to start. When reporters tried a couple of follow-up questions, Weis reportedly got irritable. How dare they ask such things. Remember the terrorists!

 

The mystery deepened on Friday, the only day on which freshmen are allowed to try their hand at speaking actual words to reporters in response to actual questions. Clausen, the true freshman who came to Notre Dame with more hype that David Beckham had going to the Galaxy, had surgery in the spring to remove bone spurs from his throwing elbow.

 

Weis had neglected to mention that – you can only imagine what would have happened if Georgia Tech had had that information three or four months ago. So he let everyone speculate about whether Clausen would win the starting job, even though he’s apparently still building up his arm strength.

 

Exactly how strong he is isn’t clear; reporters aren’t allowed to watch practices either except for the one on Friday. It was the day when Weis lifts all the veils. Freshmen talk. Practice is open. Go ahead and fill your notebooks, guys. Just don’t expect him to make a habit of it.

 

I figure that this year it’s the quarterbacks. Next year, he’ll keep the offensive line a secret and maybe the linebackers. No sense giving that first opponent too much information. Give him enough time, and he’ll keep the schedule a secret – why should the opponents even know who they’re going to play? They could get a competitive advantage.

 

All I can say is he’d better beat Georgia Tech. It wouldn’t hurt to beat Michigan and USC, too. And while he’s at it, he might want to win a bowl game. It’s the only thing that would make this nonsense tolerable.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Its not nonsense, its coaching.  Weis is the coach and he doesnt want to name a starter.  Im real sorry the writers dont have a story on the starting quarterback, but its also not their team.  Nowhere does it state any news agency should have first hand knowledge of the starting QB at ND.  I think its nonsense to assume that a coach is going to answer each and every question asked of him.
After reading your story I feel sorry for you . It is evident you never played or coached at any level. Your comments paifully support your glaring lack of sports knowledge.
You're an idiot. I am a huge Notre Dame and not knowing the starting quarterback is extremely painful. I still think Weis is better off keeping it to himself. We will be lucky to have a passing offense at all this year. We need all the help we can muster.

One more thing. Weis doesn't want to talk about rebuilding but if he starts Sharpley, that is exactly the mode he is in. He woudl have given up on the season before it ever began.
There's nothing uglier than watching a grown man put on his pink dress and patent leather Mary Janes so he can play Little Miss Grumpy.

What's it to you if a coach wants to keep his roster close to his vest? Charlie has been associated with successful coaching systems for two decades. If he believes as a coach that coaches Gailey and Tenuta would benefit from knowing the QB, that's his call, and frankly he knows more about it than you do.

By the way...      

'It wouldn’t hurt to beat Michigan and USC, too.'

Weis beat third-ranked Michigan 17-10 on September 10, 2005. You're not even good at your own job, let alone Charlie's.
How many college footballs teams have you coached? After you have coached a few years then maybe you can commenton how someone else coaches. It must really bother you not to know.
What an innovator that Weis is.  No one else has ever thought to try to confuse the opposition by keeping information about his team secret.  Of course, it doesn't make any sense to do this, all three of the QB's have exactly the same skill set and besides teams never practice against what they think the opposition is going to do.  Never ever.
You write as if you're entitled to this information.  Coach Weis is simply doing what he feels he must to help ND win agasint Georgia Tech.  Was is that such a terrible thing?If you were writing a story on a topic and you found out that another reporter from a competing paper/website/journal/etc. was writing a story on the same topic, would you give him your sources so he could finish his story before you and beat you to publication???  I didn't think so.
You are correct in noting Charlie's weird relationship with the media is a result of his years with Belichick. He has been taking some unfair hits since the bowl game. The truth of the matter is this is only his second recruiting class, due to his late arrival his first year as the Patriots were in the playoffs and he had little time to recruit himself. Next year and the following will bear the fruit of his recruiting and ability to bring the speed and athletes to ND which was sorely lacking in quantity before his arrival.
Are you serious?  Do you know anything about college football?  GT has three different QB's they would have to prepare for.  I understand we have seen none of them play, but there are scouting reports available on all three.  One is a pure pocket passer with a laser rocket arm, one is an athletic play maker, and one lies somewhere in between.  

When a team prepares against another team they have to prepare for anything that the offense might throw at them, by keeping a secret of which type of QB (who by the way, kind of sets the tempo for the entire offensive package) you limit the amount of time they can prepare for any type of offense.

It's the same reason Coaches will run an onside kick in the second quarter against an opponent.  It looks like it doesn't make sense, but the Coach for next weeks team has to take time away from his offense/devensive unit time to prepare for a "what if" kind of play.

Why does everyone bash Charlie?  He has basically used Coaching inteligence (with medi/against other teams) to get his team into the BCS in his first two years.  It doesn't matter that they were over matched.  He did and said what he had to in order to get his team in a bowl game  that was above their level of competition.

Anyone with that type of Coaching know how is better judged by someone who actually knows what they are talking about.
Are you an idiot? Because Demetrius Jones is in the mix, not announcing the starter will force GT to prepare for both a classic drop back and a running quarterback. It may be a minimal advantage, but it's an advantage nonetheless. If you don't think GT would like to know the starter, you're crazy.

Also, ND did confirm that Clausen had an off season procedure on his throwing elbow. They haven't elaborated on it until yesterday. Why should they have? So Clausen can be more red meat for the media?

Just because you WANT information, doesn't mean you should get it. Especially you, since you had the poor taste to compare ND's secrecy to our war on terror--all in the name of a bad joke.
Make this stuff tolerable, FOR WHO? I've been a ND fan for over 43 years and I'm fine with it. Like Charlie said, we get to have the element of surprise for one game, why can we not use it. Also, so everybody else needs to beat USC and Michigan right or is it just us, because ND wouldn't announce the QB until the opening play. Relax Mike, you'll find out soon enough and you'll get to dog ND just like everybody else who probably thinks Bob Davies and Tyrone Willingham we're great coaches who got screwed by ND.
Get over it man. Why should he tell. It gives him and advantage however slight it may be. Preping for a mobile QB is different than preping drop back passer. Why would any smart coach give up even the slightest advantage to please the media and fans?

Last I checked he was the one getting paid millions of dollars to coach one of the most storied programs in college football history. I think he knows a little more about the subject than you.

What are people like you going to do in a few years when Notre Dame is a top 10 team year in and year out and you have nothing to bash them about?
Wow, not much going on in the sports world, eh? Judging by the fact that you wrote "reportedly" charlie got irritable, we can assume you didn't even watch the interview. So, you are giving an opinion based on 2nd hand information about an interview. Well done! I'm sure there is another Mike Vick story to be written once we are done writing speculative pieces and getting irritated about whether or not Charlie is telling the media who his QB is going to be. It could be he is wanting to minimize pressure on an inexperienced QB before the game starts. Also, you can pick up any scouting report and see the difference between Jones and Sharpley. Hopefully, GT at LEAST did that.

How DARE Charlie run the team the way HE wants to and not the way you reporters would like him to so you can fill your bandwidth with quality reporting such as this piece!
To keep your opponent guessing as to who will line up at QB is a smart move.  Different styles for all 3 means GT has to prepare for them all, thereby not spending as much time extensively preparing for one.  Weis is giving Tenuta a lot more to prepare for, so the secrecy makes sense.  While I would love to know who the starting QB is going to be, I think this move by Weis is wise!
Mr. Celizic,
First of all, a coach is not allowed to talk about a players medical condition.  You really should know that before you criticize coach Weis.  Your article illustrates your ignorance and arrogance.  Many of you in the media feel you are above everyone else and somehow deserve answers because you are "the press."  Charlie Weis has no obligation to answer the question on the starting QB position.  He is responsible for his team and it's success or failure.  I know coach Weis is a man of integrity, and he sets a great example for his players.  Why don't you do some research into the teams grade point averages and graduation rates.  After all, isn't that what college football is supposed to be about?  Take some notes from Charlie Weis, Mr. Celizic, you might learn something!
You heard this here, Weis will start Demetrius Jones against GT and take a page out of Lou Holtz's playbook -- run the option and veer.  

Imagine that!  

Post GT, he will revert back to a classic throwing QB mixed in w Demetrius Jones running Lou's playbook.
This guy obviously knows little about coaching. I am a big college fan. While I am not a huge ND fan, I admire coach Weise. Mainly because I followed his NFL coaching career. One question to the yo-yo who wrote this article, "Why, why would any coach want to give any edge to his opponent? Why???
It seems that a little provocation can get the desired Irish up in this little MSNBC segment.  You can see that CW has so far managed to inspire the faithful (of whom I am one), who don't care about a little secrecy and gamesmanship in college football (however much we may deplore it in our face shooting secret VP).   Let me quibble a bit on your facts, however.   Anyone paying attention (including GT coaches) knew Clausen had elbow surgery back in May, so it was not news as of Clausen's press conference.  

And you get a whole lot more insight from a Weis press conference than, e.g. former coach Williamham.   I tend to give the Belechek/Tuna/Weis school of coaching and press management the benefit of the doubt given the success they've had.  If he thinks keeping press pressure off his inexperienced (all 3)starting QB before his first game and on himself, that's fine with me.  

I don't think you have any there there, whatever happens in this particular year or game.
Mr. Celizic,

Thanks for getting all the ND fans fired up for Saturday's opener.  Maybe we can discuss your article after the game.  Charlie's so darn smart I wouldn't doubt he's got a fourth QB he hasn't said anything about.  I predict ND 31 GT 27 with the field goal being made by none other than..............Jimmy C.
If I were a novice of the game of college football I might conclude from your article that the name of the Notre Dame quarterback who will start against Georgia Tech really is a matter of national security.          
Way to go Mike.  Compare terrorism to QB selection in college football.  Who cares what the choice is?  Why does it matter so much in your own insignificant world?  It's sports, not life, death, war or anything close to that level.  So the media can't criticize the decision until after the first game of the season.  Get over yourself.  I don't like/dis-like Charlie Weis or ND in fact.  I even live in South Bend and could care less.  He's not obligated to tell anyone (the same would go for Pete Carroll, Joe Pa or any other big name coach).  The media's ability to provide over-blown, over-examined coverage of absurd things is limitless.  Go back to your roots and find something of more substance to try and discuss.  Either that or get a glass of warm milk and take a snooze.  You're a bit too stressed.
You're an idiot.  You are a hater.  This is the last time I will read an article that you write.  Did I mention that you're an idiot?  
Judging from the comments above... no one seems to like you very much.  Your reporting style seems to rub people the wrong way....  While I will never cheer for the Irish, I must agree with their fans on this one.  Weis has little reason to reveal his QB choice to you or anyone else until they line up under center against GT.    You sir, are a sad little man who could never play sports... so you became a writer so athletes that you idolized had to speak to you.  Now it burns you up that a tubby coach who has SuperBowl rings to his resume has little interest in you or the rest of the media types who hound them with needless questions.  
I wonder if all the folks who read the garbage you publish about ND realize that you're a graduate of Notre Dame.  They probably think that you're just a jerk from another institution who likes to bash the Irish rather than a grad who thinks he could do a better job of coaching than Charlie.
The only thing that would make this nonsense tolerable is if you promise to never write another "sports" article
This article was neither insightful nor amusing. This looks more like an entry in your diary than a column. "Dear Diary, I'm sad." This my first --and probably last-- experience with one of your pieces. The rest of your writing better be amazing. It’s the only thing that would make this nonsense tolerable.  
It probably wouldn't hurt to write an article that my 6 year old nephew couldn't write. If you submitted this poor excuse for a news publication to a 5th grade grammar school teacher, you'd probably get sent to a guidance counselor and your locker searched for explosives.

Any moron can write a one page "article" based off of cynicism and sarcasm to get a reaction from readers. The only reason for you to write with such disregard for research, common sense, and football knowledge is that you are only interested in getting attention from Notre Dame Football fans. I understand that Mark May gets away with it all of the time, but at least he tries to base it off of some sort of facts, statistics, or even his football knowledge (as minute as that may be). You, however, have completely shuttered away using such sources in publishing your "article" and have embarrassed both yourself and the company that employs you.

Please do everyone a justice and do a little research the next time you decide to write an article. Take in some of the information that these people have written. They have actually done some research.

Example:

Charlie Weis attended Rich Rodriquez's Football camp this offseason....

Here's what I would take away from that bit of information, if I were Chan Gailey:

If Coach Weis is planning on starting Demetrius Jones, I would prepare for the West Virginia Spread Offense. Bring my corners and safeties in and concentrate on keeping 8 men in the box.

If Charlie Weis decides that he is going to start Evan Sharpley, I prepare for the same sort of offensive scheme as I faced the prior year, because I understand that he is familiar with those plays and has played in that system for 2 years under brady Quinn.

If it is Jimmie Claussen, then I know that I am preparing for short shuttle passes and lots of North and South runs, because he is admittedly not 100% and as a true freshman, he will not be expected to make the big plays. I am also confident that Coach Weis isn't going to risk having a skinny pocket passer freshman running a spread offense or option any time soon.

That is an example of writing about sports. This differs greatly from bitching and throwing a fit because the head football coach won't give you your scoop.

The next time you are inclined to write an "article," please base it off of facts, statistics, and football strategy. The next time you feel angry, frustrated, or dejected, please write it down if that makes you feel better, but throw it away when you are finished.
I see no reason why Charlie should announce his starting QB and thereby give Tech a leg up on preparation.
The intolerable nonsense is your column.  Your drive-by media types believe you have an inalienable right to every morsel of information without any regard for the potential ramifications of how you use that inforamation.  You media folks see yourself as special.  Many of you ARE special --- specially deranged.  Quarterback is the focal point of a team's offense.  Forcing an opponent to prepare for three substantially different styles in an opening game is the most logical and usefull of tactics.  Your childish tongue-in-cheek whining about keeping future offensive lines and even schedules secret reflects the inane level of your entire treatise of ignorance.
Mike - you are truly clueless and continue to lose credibility with each article you right.  I actually used to be a fan of yours when you wrote for the Bergen Record.  But between your lack of understanding of sports and your left wing political overtones, you have really become almost undreadable.
Mr. Celzic,

This latest comment of yours about the 'secrecy' over the ND quaterbacks is just one of several of your articles, recently, that in my opinion is a little anemic. You have been around football and sports lone enough to understand the politics of major programs and especially Notre Dame. There are several reasons Weis might not reveal who will be the starter, including competitive advantage or the fact that there truly has been little separation between the 3 candidates. None of us actually no Coach Weis' reasons and we don't need to know. The important thing is there will be a game played soon and there will be a quarterback leading ND into action.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=332588