ABOUT OPEN MIKE

Mike Celizic

MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic provides his unique slant as he takes an offbeat look into the world of sports beyond the box scores.



Sometimes silence is golden

Posted: Friday, September 28, 2007 5:38 PM

What’s the dumbest thing you’ve ever heard an analyst say? I want to know.

 

Fill this space up with the dumb lines that are passed off as cogent insight.

 

I don’t care about who said it – I prefer not to know. The object isn’t to insult people who are working hard – or even those who are hardly working – for a living by attempting to sound intelligent without offending anyone for three and four hours at a stretch, which is impossible to start with.

 

One that drives me nuts is when an analyst talks about the importance of “gaining positive yardage.’ You know, as opposed to gaining negative yardage.

 

Woody Austin, the golfer, blew up a while ago complaining about an announcer who was gushing about Tiger Woods’ competitive nature. (Announcers are required to do this, as if we don’t know that Tiger likes tto win.) Then the announcer says something along the lines of, “Nobody wants to win more than Tiger Woods.”

 

Austin blew up, and rightfully so. Just because Tiger usually wins, doesn’t mean that his desire is stronger. He may be more talented, but every other guy on Tour wants to win, too. Some may want to win every more than Tiger; they just don’t have the skills to do it.

I heard another on Friday afternoon.

 

I’m watching the Presidents Cup and Vijay Singh and Stuart Appelby are climbing all over Tiger Woods and Jim Furyk. It’s just one of those days when Singh holes out for birdie from a greenside bunker on the first hole and he and Appelby just keep making impossible shots all day.

 

Anyway, Woods and Furyk are down two almost immediately and are desperately trying to make something happen when one of the analysts says this:

 

“They don’t want to go three down this early in the match.”

 

Huh? What does he mean, “this early in the match?” Is there perhaps a time later in the match when they will want to go three down? And, when you get down to it, if you’re going to three down, you actually do want to go down early so you have more time to catch up. When you really don’t want to go three down is late in the match, like when you have four holes to play.

 

Those are just a few examples. Go down to the comments box and post yours.

 

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Anthony DiComo, reporter for MLB.com, in an article today about the Mets and Omar Minaya's position on the future status of Willie Randolph, obviuosly decided to take the wimp clause (reference the movie Brewster's Millions), rather than go after Minaya for his position on how "HE" did this season.  Not a single TOUGH POINTED question was thrown Minaya's way or even snuck in through the back door, subsequently the whole article should have been pulled and sent swirling around the bowl.  
  Not a single comment made to Minaya about HIS responsibility for the team implosion ... i.e. the pitching staff that HE handed Randolph to use, his lack of action during last off season right up to the trade deadline this season, to do anything at all to improve the team's pitching staff.  
  I didn't have to dig up Nostradamus to highlight (or perhaps lowlight) the similarities with last year's Mets NLCS pitching fiasco, nor did I need his services to predict the outcome of this year's season to be any different.  After short lived leads and gift giving by the pitching staff the next half inning, again Randolph played the hand he was dealt, depending on his bats to stop the bleeding ... and to his credit, did a pretty decent job of it.
  Why is it always the manager's fault when the wheels fall off?  And it at all possible that we could find a sports journalist with a "pair" (regardless of gender) to address the tough stuff with the poeple that pay the bills ... the ownership.
  Thanks Tony ....that's about 3 minutes of my life I'll never get back!  

Mike .... you're the best.
"The referee is the most important guy in the ring, other than the fighters" - George Foreman

Anything from Brent Mussberger, Steve Philips, Shannon Sharpe and Chris Collingsworth
mike: gotta miss Rizzuto!  my current (un)favorite is "young quarterback" - or pitcher, linebacker, point guard, etc.  Saturday,  term was applied to true freshman quarterback.  What else could he be but "young", even if he looks like Greg Odem?
Just about every booth announcer I've ever heard has used the phrase, "He's as good as anyone else in the league at his position."

Doesn't that state that the player is average, no better and no worse than anyone?  If he's no better or no worse, why do I care and why are you telling me about it?  

Why not tell me what he does better than any other player at his position?
how about "that good quickness."
Ok, the all-time dumbest remark was unbelievable, but I am not making this up honest! Before the 1986 AFC championship game between the New England Patriots and the Miami Dolphins an analyst said "For New England to win today they will have to outscore the Dolphins"-anyone out there over 40 who can back me up on this?
LPGA commentators are the greatest for filling the void. My favorite, "Her greatest strength is she has no weaknesses." Huh?
An old classic from Tim McCarver, referring to Phillies catcher Darren Daulton; "He's had 5 knee operations in his career...2 of them on the same knee!"
I don't know what the dumbest thing ever said by a sportscaster is.  But I'm guessing Tim McCarver said it.
Tim McCarver's comment during the 2004 ALCS - when Matsui walked - he said "that walk was worse than a home run"
Joe Morgan during a recent baseball playoff game," I don't care how good a pitchers "stuff" is . If he continues to load the bases against a great hitting team he is going to be in trouble ". Wonderful insight into the game!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://openmike.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=386468