Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Paul — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 15:49:58 GMT

Riding a motorcycle without a helmet is legal in the state of PA for licensed riders.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Cindy, PA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 15:52:01 GMT

Well said. Thank you! Stupidity and immaturity has no color.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

John, Fairfax, VA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:00:36 GMT

Here in Fairfax Va we have been taking the loss of Sean Taylor hard. RIP you will be missed.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Larry Finley, Colorado Springs, CO — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:03:14 GMT

Mr. Celizic: According to Wikipedia, "Munson was frequently homesick, and took flying lessons so that he could fly home to his family in Canton on off-days". In addition Wikipedia adds "On August 2, 1979, he was practicing takeoffs and landings in his new Cessna Citation I/SP jet at the Akron-Canton Regional Airport. On the third touch-and-go, Munson failed to lower the flaps for landing and allowed the aircraft to sink too low before increasing engine power, causing the jet to clip a tree and fall short of the runway. The plane then hit a tree stump and burst into flames, killing Munson (who was trapped inside) and injuring two other companions."

Referencing the first quote, this wouldn't come accross as "thug behaviour" or sophmoric or even stupid. Referencing the second quote, Munson made a mistake, something that pilots do from time to time, but thankfully very infrequently.

Your brief portrait of Munson wrongfully includes him with the bozos that embrace the type of idiotic behaviour prevelant today in professional and amateur sports.

With due respect sir, you are wrong. Flying a jet in order that he could see his family is hardly the mindset of the others listed in your article.

This isn't apples and oranges, it isn't even remotely related.

Larry Finley
Colorado Springs, CO

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Stacy, Los Angeles, CA. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:09:31 GMT

The best commentary I've seen thus far. Thank you Mike.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Stacy, Los Angeles, CA. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:09:53 GMT

The best commentary I've seen thus far. Thank you Mike.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Hatti, Austin TX — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:11:14 GMT

Thank you. Finally, a rational thought.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

A. Brown, Shreveport, LA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:11:36 GMT

The second paragraph states that this "clearly seemed like a reasonable act by the as-yet-unidentified gunman." I can't help but assume that this is a typo that should be fixed immediately.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

uwe fruendt san felipe mex. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:17:02 GMT

there is much more to this story, then just a burglari! first , burglers doo not carry guns (98)% then all the telefone lines were cut plus the came straight to the bedroom and shot him. dous this sound like a plain burglary??

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Lee (Milwaukee) — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:19:45 GMT

and you're still haven't said something intelligent.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Annabelle, New York, NY — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:20:21 GMT

Comparing Ben Roethlisberger's helmetless motorcycle riding (the result of youth and stupidity, not any desire to appear "tough") with a young man who kept a machete in his bedroom for protection (if he's such an upstanding guy at this point in his life, you have to ask from what was he protecting himself?), was consistently fined by the NFL for on-field issues, brandished a gun at some people who allegedly stole his ATVs, is absolutely off the charts ridiculous. Taylor's home was broken into 8 days prior to the shooting, and a knife left on the bed. Whoever did it was trying to send Taylor a very clear message, and apparently that message was delivered in person on Monday. There is way more to Taylor's story than we know right now, whereas Ben Roethlisberger's accident was a one-time thing and about as cut and dried as you can get.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Tyrone, Kansas City — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:23:30 GMT

First off let me say I don't find responding to news articles a very healthy hobby. Doing so anonymously even less so. Nonetheless, thank you for at least attempting to be more objective than Mr. Shapiro. His commentary may very well be the ugliest and most bigoted excuse for journalism I have ever read. I only wish I had a valid e-mail address for his editors to fully express how truly disgusting I find both his timing and his insensitivity to Mr. Taylor's friends, family, AND RACE. Simply put thank you for at least trying to point out (especially to Mr. Shaprio and his editors) that no one race has the market cornered on immaturity and violence.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

rman nyc — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:24:22 GMT

It is very sad and all indication are he had turned the corner on his life and was a doting father.

My guess is he got into something with someone from his past (dissed) and street machismo/payback killed him. It looks and sounds like an assassination to me.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Jim Dwyer — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:30:27 GMT

It never ceases to amaze that rich folks get shot dead in their homes when a simple cure is available. It's called dogs, big dogs, who will bite anyone that breaks into your house, gun or no gun. You have to wonder if the rich are too cheap to care for dogs. Let them tell their story to St. Peter or the Devil. Dogs rule.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ed in Westchester NY — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:32:50 GMT

"Young males are trouble"

We'll get off of your lawn now Mike.

Don't be knee-jerk is the title of your blog. Yet, with that statement, you turn it upside down.

By all early accounts, he was in his house, asleep. I fail to see how that makes him "trouble".

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Tam, Columbus, OH — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:35:10 GMT

Thanks for you commentary, Mike. I was basically trying to sort out the same sadness in this tragedy as you were.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Penny Wayson, Halethorpe, Maryaldn — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:36:07 GMT

He will be terribly missed on the field. A great players for the Skins. No one deserves to die in this way he leaves behind a small child that will never get to grow up and have a Dad. I truly hope they get this person who does not respect the lives of others. We are very sadden in the Washington DC area.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

James Martone, Malibu, CA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:36:53 GMT

While Sean Taylor's death is tragic, the type of risky behavior in which he participated is light years worse than the other athletes mentioned in your article.

It is certainly fair to categorize riding a motorcycle without a helmet as risky behavior. But the only person Ben Roethlisberger put at risk was himself. It is certainly possible that he chose not to wear is helmet out of laziness, or maybe it was uncomfortable - but not necessarily to "show what a tough guy he was." And even if that was his motive, it is several orders of magnitude less risky than "being a thug."

Thurman Munson was flying in his plane WITH HIS INSTRUCTOR. I'm sure you've flown in an airplane with a pilot. Was that pilot just trying to show how tough he was? Why shouldn't Thurman Munson be able to learn that skill?

Josh Hancock is a little closer. While I doubt that he intended to harm anyone, driving while intoxicated certainly puts others at risk.

But when one waves guns around he either intends to kill someone or to give the appearance that he intends to kill someone. Lumping that into the same category as riding a motorcycle without a helmet and calling it risky behavior is like labeling both a walk down the street and a trip to Mars as travel.

This is not a case of different cultures either, such as wearing cornrows or a purple suit or having gold plated rims installed on your hummer. Sean Taylor was smart enough to know that this type of behavior is wrong. I'm sure the person who killed him knows that as well, yet both decided to live that type of lifestyle. There are many people who are not black who also choose that type of lifestyle. And there are many young black men who grew up in conditions much worse than Sean Taylor who don't engage in that type of behavior. While I know very little about Sean Taylor's father other than that he is a police chief, I suspect he was a bad father. I suspect the same is true of Andy Reid. And if his sons don't change, they may some day suffer the same fate as Taylor.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ward Hillyer Bastrop Texas — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:36:59 GMT

I'm sorry, but blaming young male athletes, which is what you are doing, is absurd (I am not one, or at least not a young male). Should we force all young males to take estrogen? Are all motorcyclists, shooters, and pilots daredevils and barnstormers? Of course not! I would agree that today's young super athlete is coddled beyond his own good and therefore developes a warped view of his world and society in general. I would further stipulate that the rampant use of steroids (And I know there is no reason to believe that to be a factor here.) heightens the problem. Is it any different than the old woman who, unthinkingly, jaywalks and gets hit by a car? Poor judgement there as well. To quote John Donne "Everyman's death diminishes me...", so mourn him and his survivors, butjust leave it that bad things happen.....to all of us.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Lisa, Jacksonville, FL — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:37:33 GMT

Flying an airplane and riding a motorcycle without a helmet are risky, but not illegal in most instances. Unfortunatly, holding star athletes accountable for their behavior may result in money loss for professional sports organizations. Heavy fines of a few thousand or even tens of thousands of dollars is not a deterant to a thug making millions.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Gary Harrisonburg Va — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:38:56 GMT

Professional football, baseball, and basketball players are all either crybabies or criminals!

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Beth, Wichita, Kansas — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:46:04 GMT

It is a shame that this young athlete had to be the victim of a violent crime. Our society today holds little regard for human life. Regardless of what Sean Taylor did in his life, he did NOT deserve to be the victim of crime, with the ultimate price being paid...his life!!

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Dave, Pittsburgh — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 16:59:58 GMT

I agree with much of what you've said and would hasten, as a teacher, that we have been so loathe to teach our young people about the connection between actions and consequence, that an entire generation feels as though the world is made of Nerf. We see the same sort of behavior from so many and what makes me most sad, is that often a bit of guidance at the right time can change or save a life. My father gave me an open-handed smack in the mouth when I started to believe in myself too much. It was perhaps the lesson that saved my life. Hopefully the next generation will understand and do a better job with its children.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Geoffrey Mallard — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 17:19:30 GMT

Perfect.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Laura Simpson, Santa Clarita, CA. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 17:25:20 GMT

I am a football fan. My husband has gently taught me over our 29 years together about this wonderful game and all that it entails. It is a game of "gladiators" - young, strong, testosterone fueled combatants who carry what they think is invincibility into their everyday outside the stadium lives. We are who we associate with and sometimes the associates are less than stellar. Fame and money attract unsavory attention and even when lives are turned around and headed in the right direction the bad stuff is still carried along. The bad guys don't care if you trying to be good, they only know how to be bad. As a mom and a wife I mourn with Sean Taylor's family - his mother's baby is gone and the wife's comfort is lost forever and the young daughter has no daddy.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Nextedition, Los Angeles — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 17:50:19 GMT

This is the only time I have respected -- and agreed with -- something Celizic wrote.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Steve Karn — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 17:58:50 GMT

Can't believe that you can compare riding a motorcycle without a helmet to pointing guns to solve a problem.

Geez!!

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Brock Wells, Basin City, Wash. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 17:59:18 GMT

It seems to me that many of these young men are just continuing to do what they have been allowed to do most of their lives. Others have always bent or broken the rules on their behalf so they could play their sport. Accountability has been loosened all along they way because they were good and would help their team win. I am a coach and have been for years, and all my own children have succeeded at sports at various levels. I am very aware of what coaches, athletic directors, and administrators can do to encourage a lack of accountability in a student athlete. As long as kids are allowed to sidestep the rules so they can play, as adults the same thing will happen.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Rob Rust, Richmond, Virginia — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 17:59:30 GMT

A very well thought out response to Sean Taylor's tragic death. Clearly his fellow players have been moved by his death. Certianly this sort of recognition more clearly indicates the value of a person above and beyond their reputation within the game or whatever personal lapses a person may have committed.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ja Angell — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:05:49 GMT

Keep looking for something intelligent to say on the subject.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Paul, San Francisco, CA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:06:21 GMT

Who out there ever agrees with what Mike Celizic has to say. I believe he writes articles with assinine headlines only to get clicked. It's like he gets paid for each mouse click. Thoughts?

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Mike L, Fairfax, VA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:07:00 GMT

Probably the best article I've read so far on Taylor's untimely death.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

E.M., Indianapolis — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:08:50 GMT

Thank you, Mike Celizic, for yet another outstanding article. You said it better than I could. Of course, that could be because you are a pro. At any rate, you said what I have been thinking, but you said it in such a way to avoid offense. Well done.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ira Hargis, Mounds, OK — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:14:13 GMT

Mike, I enjoy reading your material. This makes more sense than much of what I have read. A tragic event no matter what the young man's past may have been. We are a country of second and even third and fourth chances. Sean should not be vilified for what he USED to be, but remembered for who he had become. God bless his family.
By the way Mike, as a Yankee fan from the Hank Bauer, Allie Reynolds, Vic Raschi, Ed Lopat days, I forgive you for the evil things you say about my Yankees.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Cesaria — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:14:31 GMT

The thing that has bothered me most is the glee that I've sensed in some people after he was shot and to a lesser degree after he died. And when I say some I mean white. It's as if because he was a black male and one who wasn't a David Robinson clone that he not only deserved what happened to him but that all his life amounted to was fulfilling a violent prophecy. Words carelessly yet automatic such as thug were thrown around and judgements on his life, his personality and his worth as a human were made and it was interesting that in all that, not much sympathy was given towards his family or the fact that he not only was valued by his team as a member but more of a person who was also changing his life, but that he was a father. For some it wasn't surprising that his life ended and perhaps in the way that it did, but for me it wasn't surprising that his death garnered such ugliness from 'some' people.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Roderick Richardson, Arlington, TX — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:16:46 GMT

This is the most sensible column about this tragedy I've have read, yet.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Reggie Newton, Chicago, IL — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:31:02 GMT

Amen to all that. Great column.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Joshua Makori, E. Lansing, MIchigan — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:34:01 GMT

Great analysis. However, you conveniently forget one thing because race is a very sensitive issue here in the USA. Successful black players find it difficult to leave their old dangerous ghetto liasons behind. I guess it is an education issue; these guys are recruited before they even know how to spell their names properly!! (no pun intended). What do you expect? They have no analytical ability of any substance. They think that success is a big expensive car and continuous partying with reckless drug peddlers. I wish they can take the advice of their wives/girlfriends who in most cases are smart-thinkers whose spouses do not ask for advice.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Dave Aaron, Hartford, CT — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:51:57 GMT

Well put, Mike. Unfortunately most will dismiss it as "another Black kid with money who didn't know how to act and got himself killed."

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Brian S Traverse City, MI — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:54:31 GMT

well written article with a good prespective. I was at first sucked in to thinking it was just another thug getting into trouble. The press is doing a good job pointing out all Taylor's misdeeds i.e spitting in the face of that guy in the playoffs a couple years ago. That had nothing to do with this young man getting shot.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Jim Vienna, VA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 18:55:28 GMT

A lot of times I disagree with you but what you said in regards to Sean Taylors death is right on.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Steve Rich — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:02:13 GMT

Why is it so important to focus on Taylor's life style, we should focus on the crime commited against him. He did not deserve to be a victim of crime, no matter what kind of person you thought he was.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

BrePhiladelphia — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:05:46 GMT

It's surprising because Taylor was in the spot light, but its not surprising considering his age and his race. All over America, young black men are being shot to death. He's actually smack dab in the age range. I'm not surprised at all. My prayers go out to his family.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

N. Wilson — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:10:15 GMT

I am glad someone wrote in response to Leonard Shapiro. The bottom line is that a young man is dead and shouldn't be.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

PO, Alexandria, VA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:11:55 GMT

You seem to be saying Sean Taylor was involved in some current "risky behavior" that lead to his death. The currently known facts (as released to the public) don't bear this out.

I admit that the break-in a week before is suspicious. It appears to be a threat or warning of some type.

Having said this, people need to get a grip on life. Sean Taylor was a man who met a tragic end, as so many do. He was not a pillar in the community (maybe he would have become one, maybe not) nor was he a blight on society. I've spent three days in media HELL in the metro DC area because of this. Every news cast (especially the morning news) has spent the majority of their air time covering the same bits of information about the tragedy all the while claiming to have an "update" or "breaking news." Surely there must have been something that happened over the last 3 days other than the murder of a professional football player.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

mpa@hotmail.com — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:14:09 GMT

Mike Celizic is a writer? My seven year old niece can write a lot better than this guy. Send him back to grammar school.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

mpa@hotmail.com — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:14:36 GMT

Mike Celizic is a writer? My seven year old niece can write a lot better than this guy. Send him back to grammar school.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Mike Dumas Dallas Texas — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:14:58 GMT

Just another young, rich thug. Look at his background, at his actions on the field and off. Nothing new here...watch the news where you live, what dominates the crime stories...everything in this story...nothing to see here, move along.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

PR, Wash DC — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:19:01 GMT

Like you said, younsters get in trouble. They get involved with the "wrong" people, do stupid unlawful things and end-up dead, seriously injured, or in jail; sometimes that is what it takes for them to learn and hopefully they live to learn from the mistake.

Young people die every day, we just don't hear about it...and it is a shame. As a professional athlete, Sean Taylor's incident is in the spotlight. Could it have been a burglary gone "bad"? that is possible, but the odds are that it was probably a personal "payback" for "shady" things Sean Taylor was involved with.

If this was due to his own choice of being involved with the wrong people, then it is a tragedy he didn't learn prior to his involvement causing the end of his life. If it truely was a burglary gone bad or some sort of fowl play that Sean never suspected, then it is still a tragedy but easier for his family, friends and fans to "swallow".

Rest in Peace Sean Taylor, you will be missed by many people.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

J. R. Harvey — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:27:02 GMT

I normally love columns by Mr. Celizic. I read a similar column on by another site claiming that it Sean Taylor had this coming to him. Huh? This is absurd. This is a man who at age 24, had turned his life around. I'm sorry if everyone cannot walk the high and mighty at age 21-23?

But this man was not at a nightclub throwing the deuce sign up. This man was not gangbanging in the streets of Miami. This man was in his own home, minding his own business when this senseless crime occured. It's time to put the pens down gents and stop pointing the finger at the victim.

Would you have sang the same tune if it was Michael Jordan or Tom Brady? No. A senseless crime as such has nothing to do with a man crashing his motorcycle or a run in with the cops years ago. I'm sorry but I can't agree with you on this column Mr. Celizic.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

S. Pancoast — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:27:06 GMT

"Every man's death diminishes me" is so appropriate when we lose young people who have so much to contribute and have so much potential. The one issue that hasn't been widely discussed is security for young athletes. They may not need Secret Service but they do need to be aware that because of their new financial status, they are targets in many respects. This was another senseless murder that keeps us shaking our heads over another tragic end to a promising life. Our condolences to Mr. Taylor's family and friends.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Amy Parsons Ellis, Greenville, NC — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:28:44 GMT

Finally…a compassionate voice in the media.

So much of what we’re reading surrounding the tragic death of Sean Taylor makes every attempt to find a suitable scapegoat in this horrendous situation. Fingers have been pointed in all directions: Sean’s not-so-perfect past, the area in which he lived, the lifestyle of professional athletes and the younger African-American population.

Rather than trying to make sense out of something that is so far from sensible, Celizic presents us with an unbiased view; one where blame isn’t cast and humanity as a whole is held accountable.

There is nothing that Sean Taylor could’ve ever done to deserve this and his daughter certainly does not deserve to live without her father.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

jim ragland- Bloomfield, Ct. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:46:05 GMT

I consider the article written by Leonard Shapiro completely condescending, biased and out of touch with reality. I can also completely understand why Taylor did not like to talk to reporters. The few times I had to deal with them during my years as an athlete I found reporters to be rather "fluid" and "free-flowing" with the truth!

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Derek J, Tulsa, OK — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 19:51:03 GMT

Excellent article. It made me reflect on some of the risky behaviors I engaged in in my past. It all comes down to people learning that you can't do whatever you want to do whenever you want to. There are rules that must be followed. And the rules are for your own good. It is far better to have young males suffer the consequences of not following the rules as children rather than progressing through life believing that they do not have to follow the rules and suffering far greater or more tragic consequences as young adults. We do not help children by giving them avenues to avoid the consequences of their actions. And failing to learn that everyone must follow the rules.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Bill Rahn, Riverside, Ca. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:08:42 GMT

I'm not buying all the B.S. that Mike Celizic is putting out. It sounds like Taylor was just another NFL thug.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Gilbert, Buckeye, AZ — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:09:34 GMT

God rest his soul, and bring peace and understanding to his family, friends, teammates, and all the fans dealing with this tragic loss.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Travis — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:16:29 GMT

I've been trying to understand this for the same number of days as you Sir. I thought I couldn't, because I'm a 43 year old white guy.

But your words here, and the words of Michael Wilbon today, have helped me. I still don't really understand it, but I'm getting there.

What I wish I could figure out now is how to stop it from happening over and over again.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Scott MacKenzie, Phoenix, AZ — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:17:31 GMT

it was reported that there was a prior burglary a week ago and a knife was left on Taylor's bed. This time the burglar shot him in the leg. I believe there is a connection between the two events and that the shot in the leg was meant as a sterner message -- if they had wanted to kill him, he would have been shot in the chest and head. Hate to suspect gambling or drugs as the source of the conflict but it seems reasonable.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Bob L, Palm Bay, FL — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:47:26 GMT

Gotta disagree with the Thurman Munson comment. As I recall, he had bought and was learning to fly the private jet in order to be able to get gome to see his family in Ohio more often. I don't really think it was a "tough guy" thing. The last thing Thurman needed to prove was his toughness!

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Sensible fan — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:48:39 GMT

His past run-ins with the law go WAY back. So his daddy being a cop means nothing. Just another athlete who lived a thug life with the exception of the last 18 months since his daughter was born. So who is suprised ? Lived like a thug, died like a thug. Seems as if the U. of Miami is just churning out thugs faster than the other thugs can kill them. It's a shame he died but really, are you suprised by today's thug-athlete ??

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ed Winne, Oakley, California — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:48:41 GMT

You compare Taylor's death to that of Munson and Hancock but you must be a little off today. Munson and Hancock were killed in accidents, Taylor was murdered. Your last statement says "He didn't need to die." Nobody who is MURDERED "needs" to die. You need to apologize to his family.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Mirissa W — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:52:20 GMT

*R.I.P Sean!* you will be greatly missed!.... You will always be in out thoughts, hearts and prayers!

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

keepinganopenmind — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 20:53:43 GMT

Hi Mike--
I wouldn't have known this guy from Adam, really. I'm not a huge NFL fan, though I follow a few teams that I'm loyal to, and I mean follow in a general sense of the word--did they win or lose?

I'm trying to keep an open mind about this tragedy since I know nothing about his background and also feel that everyone deserves a fair shake.
However, I do find something troubling about this story, that being the break in last week, where someone allegedly left a knife on one of the beds in the home. Sounds to me like someone had an axe to grind and a warning to issue. Then this latest break-in, where Taylor is shot after the intruder burst into the room. The baby and girlfriend are not harmed, thankfully...but it does get one's mind to think, huh...that ain't right. Something about this whole story doesn't add up for me. Maybe I watched the Sopranos for far too long, but I just have this horrible feeling, deep down, that we're going to hear this story is going to take an unexpected turn...

I hope to God I'm wrong...

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

lora forest city nc — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:05:52 GMT

ANOTHER SENSLESS MURDER OF A RISING BLACK ATHELETE, WITH SO MUCH POTENTIAL, SO YOUNG, IN LOVE, WITH A SMALL CHILD THAT WILL NEVER KNOW IT'S FATHER, WHEN WILL IT STOP, MY ONLY PRAYER IS THAT THE SCUM THAT DID THIS WILL BE CAUGHT, AND HIS LIFE WILL BE TAKEN AS WELL BY LEATHAL INJECTION, THE ELECTRIC CHAIR WOLULD BE EVEN BETTER.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Olivia Vansar, Washington DC — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:08:42 GMT

Hi. Please have your editing staff work harder. There are many grammatical errors in this piece. Also, I am not a sports fan, but I do know that this Roethlisberger guy did not die due to his motorcycle incident.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Jim Christian — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:19:23 GMT

"Reading the wires, I can see I’m not the only one having trouble making sense out of what makes no sense to most of us but clearly seemed like a reasonable act by the as-yet-unidentified gunman."

Not sure what you meant by that, Mr. Celizec. Was the shooting of Sean Taylor in Taylor's own home in the middle of the night, during a break-in to Mr. Taylor's home REALLY seem like a reasonable act by an as-yet-identified gunman?

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Mike Davis, Richmond, Virginia — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:19:33 GMT

Mike,

I feel that you are correct in your analysis of the youth culture in the United States. Further, it is most apparent that this shooting was likely retribution for something we are unaware of, and unfortunately may never find out. I am an avid fan of the Redskins, although I always had reservations regarding he erratic behavior of Sean Taylor. I am also quite hesitant to believe that Sean completely changed his personality and temperament in a matter of 18 months. As a therapist, I have some insight into personality, and it generally takes about 10 years of consistent therapy to change personality deficits. However, I also am a Christian and believe that the Lord can work miracles. I just hope and pray that Sean's child and family will find peace following this unfortunate tragedy.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Jim Christian — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:19:39 GMT

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Jim Christian — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:20:48 GMT

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Bryan, Tampa, Fl — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:27:08 GMT

Great Job Mike! It is a relief to read a column that brings out what we as HUMANS have in common as opposed to fingerpointing. I hope this becomes contagious.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

steve - dc — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:27:23 GMT

He never brandished a gun. Seems no has the facts straight in that case. He fought a thief and a thug who then shot 15 bullets into his car after the fight. To me that guy should've gotten beat up. Just me though. The media is just super lazy these days. I thought reporting was about research and facts? not. Quit re-hashing the lies you hear elsewhere. His case file is public and can be found quite easlily.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/discussion/2007/11/28/DI2007112800743.html

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Bruce B Chattanooga, TN — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:31:35 GMT

A well stated plea for people to redirect the common cry "another young black man dies due to violence". It IS a common thread amoung the younger crowd, and not even just athletes, nor just men. Simply look at the record of drugs, accidents, and personal failures of female teen stars these days.
You are wrong about Shapiro, the crux of his piece was stolen from Wilbon as he admitted; his thinking was not original and most repulsively, he basically made his premise with 'we shouldn't be thinking about this, but ...'. He should have taken his own advice and waited for more facts before delving into the dark side of Taylor instead of pontificating before the body was even cold.
I see today, Wilbon does the same thing, yet somehow wants to link someone who died of a self-induced drug overdose (Len Bias) with a victim of a crime, simply because they are both young and black in America. What Wilbon had right, was that Taylor, as a MAN, should have taken more personal responsibility for his life and the safety of those in his life. Had he heeded advice to relocate, had he taken more care after a recent breakin, had he . . . Get the point? While not blaming the victim for the act, the victim DOES have to take responsibility for the circumstances in most cases.
Its a shame he didn't get the chance to complete his adjustment to the big time. Its a shame he had to cross paths with thugs and that that may have come back to hurt him. Its a shame his daughter and her mother had to experience this tragedy and prayers go to them to continue the kind of life I know Sean Taylor was hoping to establish for them.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Marie — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:39:08 GMT

I wholehearted agree with "you can’t legislate brains into people, especially young, competitive males." Add "especially those with an inflated sense of their own importance by virtue of their ridiculous fame and salaries." I shed no tears for each one that falls...

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Stop Apologizing — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 21:51:59 GMT

Wow, are you ever reaching at straws. I realize how tough it is to write an article about this but come on. How many people seek revenge and try to kill you because you have a pilot's license or you drove a motorcycle without a helmet? These are not the same testosterone driven acts.

Obviously, he pissed someone off to a large degree. Stop being surprised. When you choose to employ lots of people with a pattern of inappropriate behaviour (legal or not), it should not shock you when bad things happen. Are you surprised people get beat up and killed in prison? Nope. Same scenario.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

manniblack — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 22:03:43 GMT

Of all of the artilces on the various web pages I have read in the last few months, this is one that I can honestly say deserved to be read. And not only read, but reflected upon. Regardless of the circumstances, this young man didn't need to die. I sincerely hope that no one posts any thoughtless, careless comments and disrespect the loss of a human life.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ricardo Montalbon — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 22:12:11 GMT

Proofread before you hit the send key.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Lauren, Arlington VA — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 22:14:51 GMT

I live in the DC area and love the Washington Redskins. I agree with everything you've said, and also think that athletes tend to induldge in risky behavior. But also thank you for pointing out that Taylor's death is still a tragedy.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Bob — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 22:31:14 GMT

Palmetto Bay is one of the nicest neighborhoods in Miami. Old Culter Road is a famous road because of the many mansions and affluent homes that line it. It is also very close to Gulliver Prep Acadamy where Sean went to high school. I grew up in Miami and would have loved to live in that neighborhood or go to Gulliver. Gulliver has most white rich kids as students, they send many kids to Ivy League schools each year.

This isn't about being black. Or him going to the universtiy of Miami. It is about him being robbed. That cane happen anywhere to anyone.

His past problems, which are way overblown compared to so many other athletes, have more to do with him being young, rich, and full of testosterone than where he grew up, where he went to high school, where he went to college, etc.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Maureen Johnson, Washington, D.C. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 22:53:17 GMT

I appreciate this holistic, balanced, compassionate and thorough report on this tragedy. It is the best I have read. Thank you for considering the humanity of it all.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

John Doe Tokyo Japan — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 23:07:02 GMT

Hi Mike,
First of all, thanks for your as usual, different and honest appraisal of the tragedy of Taylor's death. I, a white man of 56, born in Chicago and now living in Tokyo Japan (where guns are illegal) mourn for a brother, a fellow USA citizen.
I grew up idolizing Ernie Banks, Gayle Sayers, and Walt Bellemy, oh yes, and Bobby Hall and others, so my role models of the 50's and 60's were much different. Were we living in a happier, more fortunate age?

Also, I'd like to thank you for printing my letter in your blog sight about the Ricky issue concerning MJ. I hate to say I told you so, but I imagine his pulled rib muscle ending his season is just another tell-tale sign that things were not all right with the man, his comeback was way too premature, and that's another effect of the smoke. It tends to exaggerate one's expectations.
Still I'm the last person who can claim to be a prood on the subject, having spent more than a few years, experimenting, enjoying/suffering, from the effects, and finally kicked the habit all-together like a person from AA.
Take care, and please continue telling it like you see it.
Sincerely,
John "Tokyo" Doe

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Tracy Griffin Tulsa, Ok. — Wed, 28 Nov 2007 23:09:03 GMT

Mike, Your article was right on time. Folks have not brought into the equation the facts of all the preceding risk takers that have paid with their lives. They just had to prove what a "Jock" they are, or "How much of a Man" they were or just blind stupidity.
These same scenarios are played out every day across our country but these incidents and items don't reach the mass public the same way that high profile Athletes, Movie Stars and others do because of their notoriety.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

marc young — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 00:00:01 GMT

i think people reflecting on his criminal past and the trouble he got in shouldn't even be a topic. this young black man got shot while at home in his bed. he wasn't involved in any risky behavior or putting himself in harms way. we should be discusing how he played football, how he loved football, and how he become a family man thats what i would like to read more about, instead of about him skipping a nfl rookie meeting, that doesnt seem important. i pray his family is able to get through this diffcult time of grief.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Wagner, Washington, D.C. — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 00:14:13 GMT

Thank you for this article. I teach kids with special needs at a DC-metro area school. My students are older, almost all are black, and this tragedy has been at the forefront of their conversations. Often needing to instruct and counsel them on the consequences of their behavior, the points raised here are so appropriate to my conversations with them. How often I hear the words, "(I got in trouble) only because I am black!" How often I say, "That is an excuse for not making a change in your behavior... after all, you can't change your color. What an easy 'out!' Cowardly, don't you think?" No, it's not about color... it is about acting out according to our cultural preferences, and all those roads can lead to a tragic end.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

John — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 00:45:14 GMT

How do you know it was a murder? Sure looks like he accidentally shot himself in the thigh, probably the most common accidental shooting scenario when it comes to this kind of incident. Sure seems strange that we don't hear about a suspect, 911 call or anything else. Either he did it accidentally, she did it to him accidentally, or one of his pals did it accidentally and fled at Taylor's behest so he wouldn't get into trouble.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Lora Reynolds Richmond, va — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 01:17:33 GMT

All said and done we have lost another great one. but lets not for forget for everyone we lose we also gain yet another rememberance that will never be forgotten in our hearts and souls. So lets just pray and hope that the Family pulls thru.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Lou Chatman, Phoenix, AZ — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 01:41:31 GMT

Do you guys actually believe this was a robbery gone bad??? You are really out of touch with reality if you do. I smell a setup!

Google the comments of Antrel Rolle, a childhood buddy (Arizona Cardinals). He has some interesting thoughts on Sean's murder.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

David Sayles, Ithaca, NY — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 01:58:03 GMT

How can you compare Thurman Munson's plane crash to Taylor's death? "Thought he could fly a jetplane", last I knew you don't pick up a pilot's license by filling out a form. Many flight & classroom hours are needed. Yes, your right, Munson wasn't a thug, so why drag his name into this situation. "Never saw the need to make nice to the press" Gee, I wonder why.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Nick, Houston TX — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 02:10:29 GMT

May he rest in peace. That's all that needs to be said. He is with his maker now. He will be in good hands

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

kyle s, Salt Lake UT — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 02:47:09 GMT

This tragedy should open the eyes of many. Seeing the dramatic consequences of decisions made of years past. There is no clear explaination or reasoning we as a public can understand. Only thing to relize is just the flaw in human nature. Many people with vast riches or fame all of a sudden become targets or the third cousin from the second sister from the mother's fathers side who needs to help. Jealousy, envy, rage, all which isn't avoidable when your name is associated with money and success, especially if that where close to you feel left behind. The sports world mourns the lost of Sean Taylor..another casualty of an unseen battle we are too blind to see. RIP #21

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Jeremy F. Denver, CO — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 03:55:00 GMT

I am not a Redskins fan, never have been, but I feel so awful for that team right now. I have not felt right since I heard that Sean died the other morning, and who knows if it is something that we all will ever fully recover from. I send my respects to all those who knew Sean Taylor and considered him a friend. All I know about the man is what the media would tell us, and what I saw on Sundays. Wow, could that boy play some football. Just a tragic loss all around. I am rambling and at a loss for words.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Taray "26" Adkins, Sanford Florida — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 04:35:27 GMT

I don't like the things you all are saying about Sean Taylor, he was a great man, father, and player. For you to even say something stupid about maybe its a black thing, or where he lives, your house can get broken into no matter what time or what day it is. The man loved and he was proud of where he was from, most kids like Sean Taylor will never make it but he came home to give people like myself hope, yeah he had the money to move in a big house in a better neighborhood, but thats where he wanted to be...Sean Taylor is a person i looked up to because i play safety also for a semi-pro team in Orlando called the orange county falcons, and i wear the number 26 because of him. People can bad mouth Sean because he had an attitude problem,or he broke some laws/rules to play safety you have to be tough, that's why he was feared on the field, and loved off of it. (R.I.P. SEAN TAYLOR)

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Andrew Thrush, Kent, OH — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 04:51:01 GMT

To Jim Christian:

I believe he meant the man who shot Taylor thought it was a reasonable act.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

JP bealeton VA — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 06:00:23 GMT

Taylor was a good man. Simple as that R.I.P. Your article gives me the impression that you think some players should die. Do you think all sports players are dumb and animalistic? Someone was jealous of him. If the police spent as much time on Mike Vick for playing with dogs,they might actually catch this criminal.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Jack Wang, Temple City, Calif. — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 08:31:40 GMT

In response to Jim Christian:

I think the man meant to write "Reading the wires, I can see I’m not the only one having trouble making sense out of what makes no sense to most of us but clearly seemed like a reasonable act TO the as-yet-unidentified gunman." Once you replace the word "by" with "to," the sentence seems to make a lot more sense.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Robert Jones, San Antonio, Texas — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 09:39:06 GMT

Thank you for that. I'm not trying so much to make sense of it all, as to honor the man. Everyone please pray for Sean's family and his little girl.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

paul grimes roy utah — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 10:11:57 GMT

as a cowboys fan this tradgedy real puts things in to perspective. it's not all about football, and football ratings. as a football fan everyone lost a hell of a player! my prayers go out to the taylor family,teamates and friends god bless you sean we will all miss you

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Simon — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 12:41:36 GMT

Clearly a lot of thought went into this article. It is refreshing to read an article that is not written without a fair amount of contemplation. There are too many people judging Sean that should take a close look at their own past actions. For someone who has been under media scrutiny for all of his adult life, Sean has come through it fairly cleanly. His "well documented" shady past actually only amounts to two misdemeanors.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

machias, milwaukee, wi — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 14:36:17 GMT

"He may have done some bad things, but who among us hasn’t?"
What an excellent and thoughtful article, except for the above comment. It is completely irrelevant whether Sean Taylor or anyone else was a saint, a sinner, or somewhere inbetween. Nobody deserves to die in the tragic manner that Sean Taylor did. Nobody.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Bianca- Chicago IL — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 14:55:29 GMT

It is clear that Sean Taylor's death was more than a "burglary". I hope that the Miami police are just saying so with other intensions, (and do not truly believe so). For someone to sleep with a machete underneath their bed is a clear indication that he was scared for his life. How does one live with themselves knowing they took another’s life? (A friend, father and son). Personally, I hope it ends with an eye for an eye! It sickens me to have such ignorant individuals walking freely.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Mike Dumas Dallas Tx — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 15:43:14 GMT

Looks like some serious editing of comments on this story. None about his lifestyle or past problems or his gangsta attitude....none...this guy was apparently an angel in the past, contrary to the truth. But of course, this comment wont make it through...its not glowing praise, just truth.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Derek Fry, Burbank, Ohio — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 16:37:14 GMT

sean taylor is a great man, father, husband, and football player. he wasnt really understood in the NFL but he is now and he is now in a better place.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Reuben Lee — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 18:15:37 GMT

Thank you for adding balance to the news reporting this tragic death. I felt Mr.Shapiro showed very little humanity. Like you said we all have a pass

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Beth Jarrett, Memphis, TN — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 19:48:23 GMT

As a Redskin's Fan - This is one of the few articles about Taylor's death that hasn't angered me. I have been very dissapointed in the press making assumptions about Taylor's death as if it were somehow, "deserved" because of his background, race - what??? How would anyone know so much about a man that was so reserved and quiet, especially when it came to the press? Great article and I appreciate you speaking out to your fellow press members and reminding them that we are all human. Sean Taylor's death is a tragedy and not something we should ever EXPECT to happen to anyone!!

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Doesn't matter — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 20:01:36 GMT

Some "Journalist." I see you have only posted responses that are in line with your sycophantic coddling of this thug. If this were random, or a robbery, where are the stolen items? Why was Sean Taylor the only one shot? Refusing to acknowledge that this was probably precipitated by his past behavior under the guise of political correctness will surely prevent the murderer(s) from being brought to justice. The same code of silence has stimied the investigators in the Darrent Williams case, because his friends refused to acknowledge that he was running with a bad crowd.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Terri, Ashdown, AR — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 20:03:33 GMT

This is an article that should be read by all. Being someone who is raising two sports-dominated sons, I too know that it's not always the background or the trouble from the past; but the choices that we make. Thanks for reminding us also, that the race of a person doesn't enter into tragedies that occur. This is a tragedy that hopefully can be used for life lessons for young men of any ethnic background wanting to follow in their footsteps.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Washington, D.C. — Thu, 29 Nov 2007 20:26:12 GMT

Thank you so much from a life long redskin fan and huge fan of Sean Taylor. You are right, he didn't need to die. Everyone is quick to judge him, especially due to the fact that he was african american, however, people shouldn't just have a knee jerk reaction like you said, that's discrimination. To me, Sean, was a young man. Not a thug, not a "black man", not a football player, but a young man with a bright future ahead of him. I'm just glad that we all got the opportunity to watch him play the game of football........no one will replace him.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

san fransisco hercalese — Fri, 30 Nov 2007 01:36:33 GMT

i sorry about sean taylors lose i hope you guys will still have him in the redskins memory redskins win this whole season for sean he wants you to be happy because he knows you can win

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Chris Chapman Ontario, Ca — Fri, 30 Nov 2007 06:28:14 GMT

Personally, I think there is something fishy about this story. I know that we don't know everything yet, but I am willing to bet that the police are building a case against his girlfriend. If Sean had personal issues off the field it is a safe bet that some of them were domestic. Cheating prehaps. Remember, all of the information we are getting is from his girl friend via everyone else. A week prior to the murder someone broke in and left a knife in the kitchen, then someone comes and kills him in a failed robbery attempt!?!?! Robbers are not usually shooters and the ones that are usually leave a big mess. Is it impossible to believe that they got had a spat, over who knows, she shot him in the heat of the moment, paniced and he bled to death while she tried to figure out how to spin this story. I don't think she tried to kill Sean, however, I think that is what happened, or something like that. Forgive me if I am wrong, this is a tragedy.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Sara, Damascus, MD — Fri, 30 Nov 2007 18:19:42 GMT

Jim... I had to read that line more than once myself... Mr. Celizic did not mean that it was a reasonable act... he is saying nothing more than it seemed like a reasonable act by the gunman apparently, because he shot Taylor.

Mr. Celizic, thank you so much for this post. It is one of the best that I have read about Sean yet, as well. Sean Taylor's past has constantly been brought up as if he was a "thug" but many of us that follow what people who REALLY knew him say... know differently. Clearly, the media is grasping at what they did know of him and blowing that up... Sean did not speak to the media often as we know, but even so I have still heard that those that did speak with him, found him to be humble and extremely polite and pleasant. I wish people would stop making him out to be something that he apparently was not.

Thanks again!

RIP Sean.. you are deeply missed

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Constance Williams, Washington, DC — Fri, 30 Nov 2007 20:01:19 GMT

I agree with what many others here have said. This was an excellent article about a senseless act of violence and the culture of young men. Everywhere. Young men everywhere are in a state of crisis to everyone's detriment.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Beverly Ferris, Henderson, NV — Sat, 01 Dec 2007 19:25:58 GMT

Not a single reporter or commentator has noticed a very obvious discrepancy in the information being made public...the people arrested say that they did not go Taylor's house to kill him, just to rob him. They thought the house was empty. If this is true, why did they bring a gun...why bring a gun to rob an empty house???????

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ken, Dallas — Sat, 01 Dec 2007 20:38:18 GMT

When you embrace the thug life and something tragic like this happen, people automatically think the worst. This very well may be a case of a burgalary gone bad but because of the tone set by today's hip-hop culture, and the embracing of the lifestyle by today's young Black athletes, it's not hard for people to come to a negative conclusion. No matter, it is still a tragic loss of a young life.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

W. Gibbs — Sat, 01 Dec 2007 22:43:06 GMT

Yes, This is the most balanced I've read. Although I don't agree with some of the things written by this columnist, I appreciate his fairness in this case.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Vivian, Washington, DC — Sun, 02 Dec 2007 08:38:17 GMT

The police have charged four suspects in what they're calling a "random burglary." Will Shapiro, Celizic and everyone else who blamed Sean Taylor's death on his past now issue retractions? It is shameful that he was slandered, that everyone adopted a "blame the victim" mentality, before all of the evidence was in.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Kimberly Gilpin, Denver, Colorado — Sun, 02 Dec 2007 23:22:50 GMT

Wonderfully articulated story! Kudos for looking at this tragic event from a perspective that removes blame and stereotype and instead focuses on the loss of a talented life way too soon.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Joe Johnson — Mon, 03 Dec 2007 00:25:27 GMT

I totally disagree with this comparison of "risky" behaviour by young men. Yeah, we all grow up with some type of "ethnic or economic" prototype, but the world is about choices. At what point do you take responsibility for your own actions. The choice to ride a motorcycle without a helmet, or fly a jet or even to drink and drive, does not in any way shape or form, equate with being a "thug." There is nothing illegal in most states, about riding a motorcycle without a helmet or flying a jet. These behaviours aren't close to the same as going out with the intent to commit a crime, buy illegal drugs; use guns or other weapons to intimidate or hurt someone; rape, rob, burglarize; or brutalize.

QUIT MAKING EXCUSES FOR THESE BEHAVIOURS - THAT ISN'T KNEE JERK, IT'S REALITY.

Your comparison is sad. Your view point is ridiculous. You say the gunmans action is reasonable. But how is it ever reasonable to enter another persons home without permission, ESPECIALLY WHILE ARMED? IT IS A CRIME!! The gunman or gunmen do not get to claim self defense - they were there to commit a crime. I personally think that when you kill someone in a commission of a crime - whether that was your intention or not - you should be charged with first degree murder AND FACE THE DEATH PENALTY. If you don't want to face that possibility - DON'T DO THE CRIME IN THE FIRST PLACE.

I hope these young men all do SERIOUS time - 25 years or more. I don't care that they are black. And I don't care that the victim was famous or black. These men killed a man, in his own home with his child and girlfriend both right there, while they were in the commission of a felony.

AN EYE FOR AN EYE. OR IN THIS CASE 4 EYES FOR AN EYE.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

John. Houston, Tx. — Mon, 03 Dec 2007 05:57:11 GMT

He was no hero. Just another in a long line of overpaid, selfish, "look at me", athletes who have no ending to their self-glory. He used bad judgement in not spending some of his money on a home security system. However, I would bet that he had a couple of expensive diamond earrings! Show me an athlete of today that doesn't. It is too bad that he lost his life. It didn't have to happen. Get a straight answer out of Joe Gibbs and he will tell you the same.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Proud Fan — Mon, 03 Dec 2007 14:01:59 GMT

It's amazing how immediately conclusions were drawn that Sean was involved in some sort of illegal activity. Instead of waiting to see what time would reveal most of the media tried to portray him as a thug who got what he deserved. I would love to hear their response to the truth: Sean was a victim of a incident unrelated to any of his past mistakes.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Ms. C, Houston,TX — Tue, 04 Dec 2007 01:11:44 GMT

This is a great article.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Tim Iverson, Taiwan — Wed, 05 Dec 2007 01:24:00 GMT

Oh, Please! Those of us who fly don't do it to show how "tough" we are.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Aaron, Stamford, CT — Sun, 09 Dec 2007 14:54:40 GMT

Can you really be that stupid? Can you not see the difference between endangering onesself and endangering others? Can you not see the difference between thrill-seeking and violent crime? If not, you are a pinhead.

Don't be knee-jerk about Taylor's death

Gary Fryer, Anderson CA — Mon, 17 Dec 2007 03:28:23 GMT

Mr. Celizic. You spent two days trying to think of something intelligent to say about Sean Taylor's death. After two days you were still unable to make an intelligent comment. Waving a gun is thug behavior. Riding a motorcycle or crashing a plane can't be similarly compared. Guess that's one of our problems. You write about these things but you yourself don't know thug behavior v/s stupidity v/s an accident. As a retired teacher, I HAD to recognize the difference.