'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Charles W — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 22:44:01 GMT

The problem I have with her comments and what makes them come across racial is that she is referring Lynching of Tiger Woods who is a Black Man not cattle as you suggested in your article. I also find it hard to believe that you learned that Lynching had a racial connotation much later in life. Also not only Al Sharpton has found her comment offensive many black people has found this offensive, as well as the Golf Channel Network, so stop going after him and write your next article againt them.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kevin Johnson, Streamwood, IL — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 22:45:09 GMT

Amen. It appears the only way to shut Al Sharpton up is to catch him making some kind of comment that can be construed as "racist". But then again, who would be shameful enough to jump in front of the cameras as quickly as he does? It is ridiculous.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michael - Phoenix, AZ — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 22:49:57 GMT

I could not agree more. Al Sharpton does more to perpetuate racism than he does to curtail it. He is part of than problem rather than part of the solution.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bill, Chicago, IL — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 22:54:28 GMT

Tiger accepted the apology of Tilghman, but Sharpton feels that he has the ability “to object” Tiger’s action of accepting the apology. I would like to know how Tiger feels about Sharpton’s comments.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Wheeling, WV — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 22:58:33 GMT

Sorry, I disagree...
I was offended by the comment, I'm white, 59 and female. I'm not a golfer but I love golf and watching golf with my husband. When I saw it I was stunned.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chad H, Pasadena, Texas — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:29:49 GMT

Preach on Brother Mike. Political correctness has been the vehicle for Sharpton's free publicity for too long. We should turn a deaf ear to most of what he says until he learns to actually have something to say.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

D. Berdan — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:31:48 GMT

Well said. Isn't it funny how Al Sharpton is offended and demanding things that have nothing to do with him??? Why is that Mr. Sharpton? As a minority I find you Mr. sharpton, offensive, bigoted and racist. Perhaps you should really listen to what people say and not just assume things becuase you know what they say about assume don'e you? To assume is to make as ASS out of U and ME.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Annoymous, Los Angeles, CA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:33:01 GMT

Sharpton needs to get a life! He's a instigator and a "Blow Hard" who should be fired himself.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

CA, Honolulu — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:39:58 GMT

Utterly innocent verbal slip? How could you possible know that? Then you counter by saying Sharpton assumes she is a racist? Well you are assuming she is not. A time like this calls for wisdom and insight - something your commentary on this matter is seriously lacking. "Out of the overflow of the heart, the mouth speaks" FYI... Al Sharpton was not the only one offended.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Brian Hafner, Billings, MT — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:40:11 GMT

I agree. Rev. Sharpton turns everything into being a racist comment or act even though every sane person knows that to not be true. Kelly Tilghman should've been sat down and talked to. No suspension needed.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

The Voice of Reason, Greenwood, IN — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:41:16 GMT

Finally, a journalist in the mainstream media who does not placate Al Sharpton and his ilk for every so-called "racist" utterance. The world would be much less "racist" if Al and Jesse kept their hate speach to themselves.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Brenda Hunter — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:44:39 GMT

Shame on you!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

jmack,mia,fl. — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:45:30 GMT

Would it also not be offensive had the comment been "put him in an oven" if he were jewish?? Think about it FOOLS!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Angel MIras, Washington, DC — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:45:37 GMT

Clap, clap, clap... I agree 100% with Mr Celizic's column. Please don't make a huge deal of something that was unfortunate but had no intention of hurting anyone.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ginette Larosiliere, columbia, MD — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:46:04 GMT

I think that there are far more important issues to be concerned with in this day and age. Using the word "linching" may be offensive, but in this case, I don't see the necessity for all the hoopla. I think Mr Sharpton would serve us better by focussing on matters of social injustice, education, housing, healthcare etc...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ginette Larosiliere, columbia, MD — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:46:54 GMT

I think that there are far more important issues to be concerned with in this day and age. Using the word "lynching" may be offensive, but in this case, I don't see the necessity for all the hoopla. I think Mr Sharpton would serve us better by focussing on matters of social injustice, education, housing, healthcare etc...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michael San Diego — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:47:15 GMT

I agree that "Mug him in a back alley" is what would have carried less impact, but Tilghman's use of a very loaded word was lousy. We all have said something that we regret, but after one sees actual photos of lynchings (even in California) one becomes nauseous. Didn't a Supreme Court justice use "lynch mob mentality" in a hearing back in 1991? She should not be fired.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

G White,Bath.Ny — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:47:42 GMT

Tiger is a bigger and better man than Sharpton or the golf channel will ever be..Go tiger,God bless you..I wish you the best.I know a couple of people that would realy like to lynch me..G

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

David, San Diego, CA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:48:26 GMT

I'm not a Black American, but I do associate the word lynching with a Black man being hanged by the KKK. Mike Celizic's view of lynching does not cancel Al Sharpton's or anyone elses view. Mike's report focuses only on Al Sharpton, but many others may have the same connotation of the word.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

bob williams, sacramento, ca — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:48:43 GMT

They should have been suspended for two months or even fired. What happened to Rush when he made his comments. This is not the age to say anthing like what they said, especailly “Lynch him in a back alley." Who are you to judge one person and not everyone who makes un-kine remarks.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chris, Washington, DC — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:48:57 GMT

That was the best sports article I've read in awhile...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michael San Diego — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:49:21 GMT

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jeremy L — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:50:09 GMT

Well said...I could not agree more. We have all said something before where our body begins to cringe even as the words are coming out, knowing we made a tremendous mistake.

I think it is silly to think that her words were more than just that, a tremendous mistake, and one that we all make.

This is a larger issue, but I think that many African Americans are getting tired of Sharpton "representing" them on every little slip of the tongue.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

El Loco Arlington, VA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:50:53 GMT

What a twit, lynch is plain offensive. I was offended, and due to the fact that you have a big megaphone it compounds the offensiveness when you imply that you know your readers feelings. Just stay put and shut up. Unbelievable the bubble that you dumbasses live in.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:51:05 GMT

Very well put.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Karen - Mission Viejo, CA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:51:58 GMT

I agree - suspension was not appropriate - Tilghman should have been TERMINATED!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Luther Barber, Lexington, NC — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:52:49 GMT

Al Sharpton is only good for media fodder. There will never be racial equality in this country as long as he is able to bring every little incedent to the forfront and breath new predjudace misguidance into our fragile culture. He should have lived in the days the cowboys and indians. His forked tounge would have been displaced and we would never hear from him again.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JANE DOE — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:53:17 GMT

SHUT THE HECK UP!! UNLESS YOU ARE BLACK- SHUT THE HELL UP!! JUST THAT WORD ALONE BRINGS SHIVERS THINKING ABOUT THE ATROCITIES THAT HAPPENED. THEY DID THE RIGHT THING. AS A COMMENTATOR IT IS HER DUTY TO USE THE RIGHT WORDS. GOOD JOB GOLF CHANNEL. I BET NOW SHE WILL BE MORE CAREFUL. NO SHE DOES NOT DESERVE TO BE FIRED. SUSPENDED YES!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Edward Carter — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:53:48 GMT

Of course you would come to the defense of a female reporter as it seems that's what in vogue today. If you were descendant from a race of people that lived in constant fear of lynching at the turn of the last century, perhaps you'd have a different perspective. Kelly is a professional broadcaster and she should be held to the same professional standard as her male peers.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Joel, Brooklyn, NY — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:54:31 GMT

Boy, this is a stupid column. Celizic's "work" is usually unfunny, frivolous, and boring. But this is a new low, even for him. Does he really think that Al Sharpton is the only person in the country that is upset because an anchor says on live TV that a black celebrity ought to be lynched in a back alley? The racist malice of the "joke", intentional or not, is blatantly obvious. It's simply pathetic to watch Celizic (aging white man) falling all over himself trying to claim that talk of lynching blacks is somehow benign and that to claim otherwise is not only over-reacting but somehow automatically makes you a "misogynistic" Al Sharpton clone. Absurd. I am a white man and I am disgusted and ashamed by both the comment itself and this kind of crypto-racist defense of it. Instead of touting dated middlebrow Western novels by failed white writers as a panacea for racial disharmony, Celizic ought to try engaging with real African-American history and culture (try Toni Morrison, James Baldwin, or even Faulkner before you go spouting this idiocy!). Shame on Celizic. And shame on MSNBC for continuing to allow him to mouth his brand of foolishness.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Charles Laramie — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:54:36 GMT

When is Mr. Sharpton going to apoloigze to the Duke lacross players? Nobody ever brings this up to him. I watched the broadcaster make this statement and it's prety clear she didn't mean anything violent behind it. Soon in this country we will have to write down everthing we are going to say before we say so as not to hurt anyone's feelings. It seems to me that Mr. Sharpton likes using the racist word but if he wants to see a racist he could look in his mirror each morning.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JR, Boston, MA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:55:29 GMT

AMEN!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Carl Perez, Los Angeles, Ca — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:57:37 GMT

Celizic is out of line. The term lynch, especially directed towards a black man, connotes and reflects unmentionable racial hatred and injustice. It is a term that should not be used casually or flippantly, like Tilghman did. And it matters not that the target, Tiger Woods, was not offended by the remark.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Barry, Sunnyvale, CA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:58:18 GMT

It's amazing to me how the "race-card" is one way. If Kelly Tilghman was black would ol Al have made such a fuss- I doubt it. What if Oprah said what Kelly said- no way is Al on the march.

What's really disgusting is that Sharpton warrants any credibility. He is an angry black, sorry Africa-American man who still thinks Rosa Parks is being denied a seat on the buss.

Wake up Al, you make a fine living for spouting off about racism- obviously you don't want it to end. People like you make the loudest noises about race as you line your pockets perpetuating racism. You do a dis-service to Ms. Parks and Mr. King with your antics.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michael Boyd, Irving, TX — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 23:58:43 GMT

For Shame! I am a big fan of Kelly Tilghman, who is an excellent golf announcer and to be paired with Nick Faldo and his extraordinary sense of humor must and does present a challenge for humorous response. Her response can be interpreted as saying there is no way to overcome Tiger's inate ability on the golf course. Perhaps one of these days a golfer will come along that has a natural talent for the game with the same work ethic instilled in Tiger by his father and the strength of will instilled by his mother. Or even some of the current golfers could follow Tiger's example in balancing extreme fitness, consistent concentration and family life and maybe get close. They will not catch up since they started too late.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michael Davis, Austin, Texas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:00:40 GMT

Ultimately, I would like to see Tiger Woods step up to the microphone and say, "I'm not offended by what Kelly said. I don't agree with the Golf Channel's suspension of her, and I hope that she returns sooner rather than later."

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kevin Barrett — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:00:46 GMT

Amen, Mike! I also thought of lynching as an old west kind of thing- never in my wildest dreams would I have made that association with racism.The good Rev. needs to tone down his rhetoric,after all, Tiger wasn't offended,why should the rest of us be- because he deems it so?! I don't think so...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Richard Frank Pearsall — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:03:17 GMT

No offense meant, no Offense taken, I don't watch the golf channel, but it did go too far, BOO Sharpton.
BTW I'm African American...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Doe — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:04:00 GMT

Simply a fantastic and well spoken response. Thanks for taking the time and risk to comment.

Anonymous - Sharpton scares me

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

david brooks — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:04:35 GMT

Al Sharpton was not the only one offended. My parents and grandparents lived in the South from the 1920s through the 1950s. Lynching was done to innocent black men throughout their area. It was a way for certain white men to demoralize and put fear into blacks. Please do not minimize a term of an act that was used to belittle and demoralize a people. This term brings to surface very severe emotional scars to many blacks over 50 years old. Imagine walking home from school or work everyday afraid of being attacked for no apparent reason; and the perpetrators would not be punished.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Faheem Amir — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:05:14 GMT

I am always amazed at how white americans believe they can tell black folk how to respond to something we believe is racist. Anyone could have taken a second to listen to Black radio today, and would have found Al Sharpton is not only Black person who believe this woman should be fired. It is still strange that many white americans have yet to realize that because they see a statement or act as innocuous does not mean Black folk will see it the same way. However, the insult is not stopped there, many go on to say black folk are being too sensitive or political correctness is out of control. Her statement is neither political nor correct and I as a Black man find it offensive and believe she should be fired. Now how many White americans will stand up and tell me how I should view what was said?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Joshua Harrington, Moreno Valley, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:05:15 GMT

Very well said. I think it was a slip and I think it meant nothing at all racist. I think if it was up to Sharpton...White people would not be allowed to say Rope,Lynch,Tree,Post or any other item related to that dark part of our history. His racism is showing through everytime he comes after someone for saying something he doesn't even know held any racist intent.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Larry, Saratoga Springs, NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:05:50 GMT

This whole thing is REDICULOUS....she was actually complimenting Tiger by suggesting that he's unbeatable. It was clearly a joke and Al Sharpton is the biggest joke of them all. He incites people to riot when there is no justifiable reason for it. Get a grip Al. The media has allowed him a platform to speak from and maybe without people like him constatntly trying to make issues out of NOTHING.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

W Berger, Miami Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:07:01 GMT

Well Mike, Thank You for clearing up how a certain group should feel about an offensive word used to explain how to combat hard work, a life's sacrifice to achieve the pinnacle of a specific athletic pursuit.

I'm sure Mr. Woods was not offended by the comments by the Golf Channel Anchor as he must taking into considering the comments that have been made both in writing and potentially vocally. He is in the public domain and as such should remain unfazed if he is to achieve his goal of winning more Major Tournaments than any other golfer in history.

Here is where I'm challenged. "Lynched" is not a term I use in casual language with my friends. You stated several alternative word choices that would have made the point (Although I think you missed the most obvious... outwork Tiger - If that is possible).

Too often we attempt to define others who are not like ourselves and it every time it appears we might be closer to that moving past this truly American trait an instance like this rears it's ugly head and it makes you wonder if the design is to continue to presume to move toward racial equality interrupted by moments of clarity of what we are really thinking.

The debate should not be about a simple firing but how America continues to think these types of comments are "no big deal"

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

js, ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:07:27 GMT

The people who scream 'racism' every time anything happens weaken the term for when it really matters.

And no offense intended to any minority groups, but some people in those groups seem to act like their prejudices against others are somehow different than the prejudices some others have against them.

All signs that maybe we're really not getting anywhere with any of this....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Wayne Gish, Tacoma Wash — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:07:27 GMT

Thanks Mike,

As always, clear, concise, accurate. Jeff Rude wrote an article which came down on Tilghman’s side as well. Maybe if a couple more writers and a bunch more viewers (like me) make our point known, we can get Mrs. Tilghman back in the chair.

Thanks again.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John L Wolfe — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:07:43 GMT

I couldnt disagree with you more strongly.

And if Tiger was Jewish, could she say? "he should be Gassed"

Or Indian "He should be scalped"

No you are just wrong and showing poor judgement.
Her remarks were offensive. She should be suspended until she completes sensitivity counseling. And Maybe you should take some too.

America has changed Celizic.

Allowing this type of country club racism only opens the door.

America is done with it.

God Bless America

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike, Denver, CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:08:13 GMT

You hinted at it, but what about Sharpton's sexist remark - "this woman". This kind of thing gets way out of hand. Sharpton should live by his own rules and arrogant sense of morality and be held accountable for his sexism.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Joseph Bidwell, Indianapolis, IN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:10:58 GMT

Amen. Thank you for your common sense. We need more of it

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chris Chapman, Costa Mesa, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:16:00 GMT

You hit the nail on the head. Without Al Sharpton, I would have never given the comment a second thought, and would have instead focused on the compliment given. The only way that kids are going to take Tiger down is to beat him up. Hey, maybe it would have been more PC to suggest that they use slingshots?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Carol Anne, Seattle — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:16:33 GMT

Two wrongs don't make a right.

Tilghman said something racist and offensive, and Sharpton did his "horrors!" act. A short suspension for her seems just fine to this white woman. And as for the Reverend Al--who listens to him? Anyone?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Lars Olsen, Kennewick, Washington — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:17:05 GMT

The future looks darker now, more than ever, with the continued bashing of people that "offended" somone. It is a sad day when executives cower to a very few that were offended. Tiger himself has been hammered about what he has said as we all remember the "spaz" comment. Tiger knows what it is like to have every word disected as to what it could mean. If the small minded "offended" of the world continue to dictate what we hear, soon all we will hear is silence. Kelly blesses us all with her grace and charm and I know that she will continue to do so, unfortunately more carefully than before. As for The Golf Channel...they made their decision, and in so doing gave more voice to people that feed on hate and racism. I am ashamed that people that value the integrity of golf do not understand that they themselves are feeding such negative people.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

EZPikins, Wilmington, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:18:00 GMT

Here, here. Sharpton is the most racist person with a public voice that I have ever had to suffer through. He has caused more hate between races than he has healed by a fair margin. I have friends of all color and I am a heinz 57 myself. I'll put my chips in with Bill Cosby, thank you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Arlen W. Moss, Madison, WI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:18:31 GMT

While I have no interest in defending Opportunist Sharpton, your response to this incident is lame and unnecessary.

Note the misuse of the term "women" in the quote attributed to Sharpton. How is the use of language such as "that woman" misogynistic? It isn't. You simply felt compelled to comment on a statement which meant nothing and a response which means even less.

Retirement should be looming.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Steve, Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:19:32 GMT

good job, Arnie step up and end this now!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Keith W, Seattle WA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:19:52 GMT

For once in my life I will have to agree with Mike here (I am from Seattle and he never picks the Hawks or gives them much respect). Al Sharpton loves to jump on any comment he considers racist, and this was truly a case of a bad choice of words. For him it seems to be another way to get publicity, even though he might be ruining someone's career or reputation. If Tiger was not offended by it, how can Al Sharpton honestly think this person should be fired, or that they meant any ill will? I think he is the one who needs to take some classes on racial understanding.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tonya W, Seattle, WA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:21:48 GMT

No offense may have been taken by Tilghman or Tiger, but there was offense taken by me. I am a white American that grew up in the Deep South. I know racism. Tiger knows racism. Intent aside, the term lynching is laced with racism. Lynching, by law in the United States, is not only a felony but a hate crime as well.

Lynching was used as a means of terrorism, and vigilante justice, in other countries long before the Civil Rights era of the US. But to us, Americans, it is a piece in the fabric of our history. It is an act of terrorism on black Americans by white Americans. That is how we know it. That is why it is personal and that is why it is not funny today as it was not funny fifty years ago.

Americans should take a notice of their history and out of respect for the success in advancements that our society has made, vow to only further those advancements. We have come far, but we have further to go as evidenced in this situation. Statements like this set us back; statements like this are not only insensitive, but ignorant. They make Americans look stupid.

People who have positions in our country that allow them to sit in front of the cameras, to come into our living rooms, are not only charged with the responsibility of their jobs but to be respectful of the millions of people who watch them. Sure, if we get offended, we can turn off our TV sets, but why should it come to that? Why can they think before they speak? And why should we defend their ignorance?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kris, San Diego — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:22:35 GMT

good call. I completely agree with you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jon — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:22:53 GMT

You are wrong. I have little doubt that it was a simplke mistake and the sportscaster is not racist. However, the slip of the toungue was so offensive and becuase of her position, she absolutely should be suspended. I do agree that Sharpton should butt out as that hypocrit has made equally offensive remarks.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Doug, Savannah GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:24:10 GMT

Sharpton makes me want to vomit every time he opens his mouth!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

sam — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:24:20 GMT

Being a black male of 58 years I hope the golf channel listens to you and puts her back on the air.Sharpton is an idiot...a rascist idiot and someone has to say it...tell him to get a job and leave the world alone...i watch the golf channel and enjoty the lady and her comments..man, what have we come too if people like SHARPTON CAN GET SOMEONE SUSPENDED FOR A SLIP OF THE TONGUE....ITS A SAD DAY FOR AMERICA

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

d. prentiss Frisco, Tx — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:25:03 GMT

Tilgham meant what she said. I noticed her lips movement as she spoke on the video. I don't think she was joking!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rosa Santana, Sacramento, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:26:15 GMT

Very well said, I’m very disappointed with the Golf Channel for letting them-selves be so easily pushed around.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tyler, Kansas City, Mo — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:26:24 GMT

Exactly. The word "lynch" did not originate in a racial context, but rather from William Lynch, who, in 1780, decided he would administer vigilante justice to criminals since there was little enforcment from the government. It was a raceless context. I have never thought of "lynch" as a race specific term until this recent incident. Yes, you read about blacks unfairly lynched, just as you read about blacks unfairly beaten. Will Sharpton claim "beat" as an exclusively anti-black term next? Sharpton is nothing but poison to people, language, and race relations.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bill, Holden, Ma — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:27:16 GMT

Nice job, Mike. No one in the mainstream media has the guts to call the "reverend" out, lest they be suspended for racism...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

chicago, il — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:27:17 GMT

I agree she needed to be suspended. It is an inappropriate analogy, or at the very least a poor one. It is not even funny. It is hard to see it as a facetious remark.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Torrey Wolbert, Tooele, UT — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:27:42 GMT

Hear, hear Mike! I am SO tired of the supposed Reverend Al Sharpton! The man is one of the most racist people in our country! i hate to break it to him but white people did not invent racism!(i.e. see Rwanda, Ethiopia, Liberia, etc). Please take a page from the good Dr. King, and learn how to respect ALL people!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Joe, Colorado — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:28:03 GMT

Why is there an issue as long as Tiger wasn't offended? It's like the old line about a tree falling in the wood and nobody hearing it...can it really be an insult if the person it was aimed at didn't take it that way? (And if it can, then shouldn't Sharpton be calling out Woods for letting her off the hook?)

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

bill gray, havasu, az — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:28:26 GMT

Amen

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jordon, Fresno, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:28:39 GMT

I agree fully to your comments towards sharpton!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jason, Chicago — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:29:20 GMT

Right on Celizic. I hope Obama wins so he can instill pride, possibility, and self-confidence into people of color. I'm sick of Sharpton and Jackson and their insecurities.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

B. Kent, Little Rock, AR — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:29:44 GMT

Agreed. Sharpton needs to understand that this is a different generation of young Americans who are not well-versed in the history of a term as it pertains to slavery or black history. All he does is breeds life into racism and keeps it alive and well in the hearts and minds of Americans every time someone says something that offends him. As for the young woman and many other young Americans, maybe ignorance is bliss, but it's better than raw hatred - and that's not what this comment was. As long as Tiger gets it I personally don't care.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

D. Wolford — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:30:05 GMT

Mike, you are spot on here. My thoughts exactly but I couldn't have expressed them as eloquently as you. Well done.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

RCM. Seattle, WA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:30:14 GMT

I'm not black but I find the use of the term "lynch" offensive and feel that it does indeed have racial overtones. People in general need to recognize that even if the intent of the person speaking is benign, the words still have impact to the listener. We all know Al Sharpton is a media-loving soapboxer. But just because Sharpton is using this as his latest platform doesn't cancel out the fact that Tilghman's use of the word and the context it was used in are shockingly inappropriate.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave Lewis, Washington DC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:30:57 GMT

I do not believe she meant any I'll will toword Mr Woods especially since she is acqainted with him. Mr Sharpton should take a good long look in the mirror of judgement before he makes comments and demands of Networks and the American People. It would be nice if Mr Woods would tell the Network to grow up and give it rest already. He is one of the most gracious athletes of our time and if he's not offended and knows Kelly Tilghman had no intention of offending him perhaps a statement from his camp can put a better spin on an uptight preacher and a Network who can't handle an honest human mistake.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

KBellows — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:31:01 GMT

Please Mike,
You're missing the point entirely. It doesn't matter if Al Sharpton commented on this or not (or you for that matter)--"lynch" in case you didn't know is a word that most of America DOES associate with racism. What a self-righteous position you take--you are referring to books and there are people who have had this term not only used but applied in the worst way to members of their families--not because they were some ne'er-do-wells, but because they were black. That's it. Much like the term concentration camp refers specifically to the persecution of Jews during WWII. She not only deserved a suspension for being so irresponsible with her words, she's lucky she kept her job.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Scott Adams, Seattle, WA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:32:08 GMT

Thanks for your column Mike.

Some sense out of the nonsense!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave Lewis, Washington DC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:32:11 GMT

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tom, Chicago, IL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:32:18 GMT

Great article. That is really pathetic of the Golf Channel. And Sharpton is a racist based on his knee-jerk reaction to what any white person says.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jeremy CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:32:32 GMT

Bravo!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Lawrence Hammond, Midland, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:32:45 GMT

I am sorry, but I see nothing in Miss Tilghman's remarks that could or should be caterogized as racist. And certainly Mr. Sharpton and others of his ilk have no credibility. They are flame-throwers and will use any excuse to 'get headlines'. Miss Tilghman's apology should have sufficed, no other action on The Golf Channel was necessary. Weak kneed GC executives should be ashamed of themselves - I ask, "Was Mr. Woods offended?" From all reports he was not and took the comments in their totality and not parsed to find outrage....good for him...there seems to be a shortage of common sense throughout the media..I know Miss Tilghman will survive this episode and I will miss her commentary during her enforced absence. The Golf Channel should be ashamed....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Anthony Nwaneri, Chatham, NJ — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:33:16 GMT

Mike, I am a fan of yours and regularly read your postings, but I believe that you are absolutely wrong on this one. As you acknowledged the term is offensive to people in general, and to African-Americans, especially. But the reality is not only is Tiger an African-American, he is also the only (readily recognizable) African-American in golf, and thus, is not just a personal attack, but is almost an indictment on the entire race. The words are, without a doubt, hurtful. But in this climate of hate where nooses, seemingly from a bygone era, are popping up everywhere from New York City's Columbia University to Louisiana, as if they are part of the latest trend, such language is unfortunate and untolerable. Now I don't believe she's a racist. I believe she meant it innocently in the colloquial term and in an odd way as a flattering remark. But as these past few months have shown, we as a country are not yet ready to move forward. Those that would use a noose to lynch are still among us and are willing to follow through on their threat. As a result, the non-punishment of this anchor will be a sign that we as a country tolerate not just her comments, but the use of a noose as a method of terror and fear. As good Americans, we cannot let that stand. She should not be fired. Her choice of words were poor at best. She has apologized and she should be forgiven. Frankly, as an African-American, Mr. Sharpton is flat wrong. Her comments when taken in context do not rise to the level of what Don Imus said to the girls of my alma matter. The malicious intent just was not there.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

(Richard Bass, Baltimore, Maryland): — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:33:39 GMT

Even today, I do not associate the term "lynching" as a racial slur and I'm a 66 year old physician. You are right in that the Golf Channel has reacted to Al Sharpton, who is no mental giant, and in my opinion is more racist than any of those he has accused. This rediculous issue, with the help of the media, will now take on a life of its own, and Al Sharpton, once again, draws attention to himself while injuring another.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Craig Daniel, Shanghai, PRC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:34:33 GMT

Amen. Thank you. Wrote to the Golf Channel producers yesterday and said the same (not as eloquent).

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Stephen Marc, Atlanta, GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:36:57 GMT

You really summed it up well. My personal experience is similar to yours - I did not hear of lynching in a racial context until much later in life. With each new witch hunt, the Reverend Al Sharpton makes himself less relevent to constructive racial dialogue.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Enrique,Tallahassee,Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:37:19 GMT

I guess Ms Tilghman and Mr.Celzic forgot to make an American history course in college.
It is just ignorance rampant even though Kelly graduated from Duke.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dan G, Las Vegas, NV — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:39:26 GMT

Thank you for saying what most people think.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave Warren — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:40:40 GMT

Thanks for the article. I believe everyone already knows Sharpton is a joke. He grabs attention anyway he can, it's just disappointing that some people aren't educated enough to see him for what he is, an embarrassment to the African American Community.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Lora Lee, Palm Desert, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:42:02 GMT

Al Sharpton is really getting to be a bore....He needs to get a life - obviously he doesn't have one, or at least not one that's worth anything....maybe he could use some of his passion to help those who are really in need instead of being the self-serving wannabe he has become.....Maybe he should see Dr. Phil - they seem to be very similar - full of themselves....gonna save the world.....NOT!!! How could The Golf Channel take anything the Rev says seriously - shame on them for not backing their employee, especially when the person who's causing all the trouble is not the least bit credible...I'm sure Tiger and Kelly are on the same page where this is concerned and certainly capable of taking care of any issues/non-issues they might have.....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

derek — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:42:53 GMT

well said.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Patricia Winter,Houston Texas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:43:02 GMT

People like Al Sharpton are the ones that help festor the racial divide in this country what does he do for a living I watch Golf channel & it was not meant to be the way Mr. Sharpton says, he needs to monitor all the Rap songs & the rappers.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ken, California — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:43:18 GMT

Mike hit the nail on the head. Sharpton is the biggest bigot of all, and he has done more to incite racism in this country than any other single individual (though you could throw Jess Jackson on the table and make a heck of an argument). The only one who was lynched here was Kelly, and it was Sharpton who kicked the chair out from under her. Are we ever going to start ignoring pious fools like Sharpton and his ilk, or will we continue to make good people feel foolish for their honest mistakes in order to appease their racist blood-lust?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John, Lake Forest, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:45:18 GMT

Hear, hear. Very well said, and I cannot agree more. Shame on Al Sharpton and on the Golf Channel for humoring him.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

tonya pharr — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:46:28 GMT

Are you out of your mind? If it were a derogatory about a Jewish person, then she would have been fired by now. Think about her choice of words ... "lynch in a back alley"... hello... African Americans were lynched for hundreds of years... there's a racist connection...and Tiger is an African American. Why does it have to be spelled out for you to understand it was clearly inappropriate. It doesnt have to offend you to be offensive. I'm all for Freedom of Speech but prejudicial comments have no place in a professional, live broadcast.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Xer Nawoc — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:47:19 GMT

Wow Mr. Celizic, well said.

I find it highly ironic that A. Sharpton got so up in arms about the word "lynch" when a lynching is exactly what he call for for Kelly Tilghman.

A. Sharpton should be ashamed of himself for politicizing this innocent choice of words when there is so much actual racism going on in our world.

Sharpton, either find a legitimate cause to champion for or get a life.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tripp, GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:47:23 GMT

If it doesn't bother Tiger then it is none of Al's business. Maybe instead of criticizing everything that has black,white implications he should get out their and help white people and black people alike by teaching them not to do things like this. All he ever does is jump on the racial bandwagon. Hey Al, ask yourself this- What will people remember you for when your time is up? Aid for the less fortunate? no. Helping people learn the value's, ethics and the common sense of taking care of each and every person we come in contact with? absolutely not. You will be remembered for being a racial bandwagon whiner who only come out of the woodwork to gripe about Black people being mistreated. Instead of griping publicly about it why don't you remain anonymous and schedule a meeting with the people who are responsible for this ignorant behavior and counsel them in a unbias way and then thank them for having an open ear and listening to you and thank them for their time. Be proactive Al, Not Reactive. It's best for all of us, Black or White. We all bleed red.....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bev Yount, Yucaipa,CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:48:13 GMT

She should have been fired on the spot. Statement may have inspired some phyical action against Tiger. At best it was a stupid remark and shows she has no class or breeding.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim ,British Columbia , Canada — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:48:38 GMT

You hit the nail on the head ! Sharpton is an idiot if he thinks Kelly meant anything racist . I heard his comments on CNN and it almost left me speechless the absurdity he was saying . I feel most fortunate that I don't have to listen to his ramblings on a regular basis ! Shame also to the Golf Net for their uncalled for reaction to what really is a non issue . Oh well just another Jerry Springer wannbee !

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Eric Rutherford, Paramount, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:48:43 GMT

I find it so interesting how white people or people in general trivalize or minimize othe people's feeling. The word "lynch" when used in association with African-American has a very negative connotation in our community. You don't have to understand it, to respect it. Who are you to decide what people should and should not find offensive? What she said was plain in simple in poor taste and unacceptable. Had she said "mug him in a back alley" you're right, no reaction but she didn't. It's the difference between being polite and being rude. The word "lynch" simply has a more personal meaning to African-American, much the way I'm sure "gas-chamber" has to Jews. They're not just words, they conjure up emotions associated with death, hurt and pain. I would say I was disappointed in your comments, but that would suggest that I expected something much more!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sam Eleanor, Tarboro, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:49:16 GMT

I grew up in the south during the 50's. Like you, I associate lynching more with the old west. If it had been said about a white player nothing would have happened. It is time for people to stop being so thin skinned. Consider the intent behind the comment. It did not bother Tiger, it should not bother Al.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Golf Fan, Jupiter, Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:50:01 GMT

Mike,

As a frequent reader of your column, I'm surprised at your reaction. Kelly Tilghman, like any public figure, must be held accountable for the words she choses when broadcasting.

If she refering to a Jewish Golfer, and suggested he be tossed in an oven, I don't believe the Jewish community would take as light hearted humor.

She is well aware, as you are, of the historical meaning of lynchings in this country as it pertains to african-americans.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Maria Loi, Vancouver, BC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:50:28 GMT

Making a mountain out of a molehill. Mr. Al Sharpton is getting out of hand. Shame on him and you are right! Tiger knows Kelly for 12 years and he knows that she does not mean to slur him, maybe a little jealous of his ability but that is human! There is nothing wrong with that. Oh my God, what is going down in USA.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Glenn Graham, Dumfries, VA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:52:23 GMT

Mr. Celtzic, I don't know you and normally I don't read your column until it is about subject that interest me (welcome to the club, right?). You just said you didn't know the overtone the word "lynching" implied until later in life. I still think you don't understand the term until it applies to your race in negative way. Regarding the cowboy book, so what if lynching is referred but not related to race. There are many books available that are related to race and lynching, better yet, try reports issued by our Federal Government.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Al Russert Chicago, IL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:52:26 GMT

You are such an MSNBC suck-up. Imus didn't deserve it either.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bill, Oceanside, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:52:45 GMT

Thank You Mike. It could not have been said better. Al Sharpton's comments only serve to prove what a fool he really is.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kaelinda, Romney, WV — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:52:45 GMT

But that's what we've come to in this country. There IS no more freedom of expression. People can't say what they want to say without paying dire consequences. From government employees to newsfolks to school faculty and staff, freedom of speech has gone the way of prohibition, I'm afraid.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jason, St. Pete., Fl — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:52:51 GMT

If you feel Al Sharpton was the only person offended by these comments you should be fired or at least demoted. I would request your replacement to have at least slightly below average intelligence.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chris K, Concord, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:54:09 GMT

Color me shocked, Al Sharpton offended? I have grown up, lived amongst black people my entire life. Everything from their history and culture I have shared. There is one thing most of my friends agree on, Al Sharpton is a person that keeps Black America held back. Many would love to try and forget about the past and remember the sacrifices their forefathers made as a reminder of how far they have come and how much better they can do today. But when Al starts talking he reinvigorates all of the hurt and angst his people have inside of them that most of them would rather just let go. I know what Black America has suffered, I'm sorry for it.
But I am also tired of having it shoved down my throat constantly. My family didn't even move to this country until the 30's. Everyone in history has gotten the shaft, none of it is right. But we are hopefully a wiser culture now to try and move forward and create a better life for ourselves. This isn't the past and the longer we linger in it the more we are doomed to repeat it. Al Sharpton never wants to leave it, he never wants to let it go. It's no different than revenge and look how that eats away at you. There are better representative to the Black community and most people know it. But for some reason the networks love to give this man the attention he so desperately desires. I guess it doesn't matter, I'll just be labeled a "racist" who doesn't "understand".
Let's be realistic here. In America, money is the new color divide, as least as far as I am concerned.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

GCraig, San Francisco, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:55:04 GMT

Shame on YOU. What she said offended more people than Al Sharpton, it offended ME and it has offended every person I've told about this, of all races, all of whom said they hadn't yet heard anything about it. I'm a 56-year-old African-American woman and not one known to be quick to take offense or label someone a racist -- but this comment was OUTRAGEOUSLY over the top! I'm not old enough to collect Social Security, but still old enough to remember when news reports of lynchings of black men were standard fare in the Black press. I grew up in the South and just like any other Black child of my generation, I had to be schooled in what I could or could not do lest I meet with violence from white people, especially in rural areas -- and we all understood that that went double for my brothers. What I'm trying to impress upon you is that for MANY African-American people, lynchings are not just part of some ancient history, the whole subject evokes very strong feelings about the racial hatred we have experienced in this country. Jokes about lynching a black man are NOT funny to us, and they're certainly not going to get a smile out of the families of the over 3,000 ACKNOWLEDGED lynching victims -- not taking into account those whose relatives just "disappeared" after having offended some white person. And who cares if Kelly Tilghman was unaware of the offense she was committing, as hard to believe as that is? Perhaps a suspension is what's needed to drive that lesson home. And as far as Woods accepting her apology, good on him to be so magnanimous, but that doesn't cover ALL of the people who are shocked, horrified and yes, offended, by jokes about lynching a black man in a back alley.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

April, Duluth, Minnesota — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:55:49 GMT

Everyone including Tiger Woods should be offended by the fact that this woman said he should be lynched in a back alley. Since when is lynching only offensive to black people? It should be offensive to EVERYONE!!

I do like how Celizic tried to tell us what she "really" meant when she used the word lynch. Apparently he's a mind reader!!

I don't care if she is a friend of his or not. Quite frankly, I wouldn't want a friend who thinks it's okay to say that I should be lynched. Innocent verbal slip? I think not!! If we're going to dish out punishments for people who make racist remarks, we should not be picking and choosing who to punish.

The "shame" should be on those who think it's okay that this woman said it simply because she knew Woods. It's not okay, no matter how much you try to delude yourself into thinking that it is!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

wagonmaster, La Habra, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:56:00 GMT

If lynching is okay, why is everyone so upset about the noose found on the professor's door or the nooses in the tree?
If "did not mean to" is the reason, why did Howard Cosell get fired for referring to a football player as man's cousin - a monkey.
I believe this woman should have been fired. Certain words or objects do mean different things depending upon the context, or other factors such as race, religion, sexual preference etc.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dr Boogie, Madison, WI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:56:22 GMT

We are certainly getting awfully touchy about words. This was a pretty innocent comment when yoou think about it, unless you're Al Sharpton of Jesse Jackson.
There is a point where political correctness just plain gets out of hand and this is one of those points.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

KB, Texas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:56:41 GMT

Why do people give this fool the time of day, much less air time. If the liberal media would report what was worth being reported, the U.S. would be a better, less hate oriented enviroment.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Alan Indianapolis IN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:58:02 GMT

How is the word lynch racial? I think everyone is over reacting. And if tiger Woods was offened then why should anything be done. I have watched the golf channel for years and have followed tiger since he came out on tour. She's a good boardcaster that said jokingly what it would take to beat tiger on tour. Worse is said about our president daily. But Mr. Sharpton gets another 15 mins.Because a TV channel jumps because of Mr Sharpton.I am sure she was sincere when she talked to tiger. After all Mr Sharpton he even said they were friends. I guess you think you know better than Mr.Woods.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Richard Harris, Baltimore, MD — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:58:09 GMT

That you could excuse the use of a term that brings to bear generations of hatred and barbarism is to me, unthinkable.

In this day and time one would hope that even someone who is as removed from the black experience, as this writer obviously is, would recognize that there are some statements... some insensitive remarks which cannot and should not be accepted under any circumstances.

It was not long ago that a black man could be dragged from his home and beaten, defiled and lynched for the slightest of imagined afronts made to a white person. There are few of my generation who cannot still conjure haunting images of Emmit Till or dogs being set upon peaceful protesters among other unspeakable attrocities.

So, I assure you, this statement is not in the realm of acceptable behavior for any person, most definately, not by a person who would hold themself out as a friend.

I fear for a people... I fear for a nation who so cavalierly forget the past, for they are most definately destined to repeat it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dr Boogie, Madison, WI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:58:16 GMT

We are certainly getting awfully touchy about words. This was a pretty innocent comment when you think about it, unless you're Al Sharpton or Jesse Jackson, those pillars of wisdom and touchiness.
There is a point where political correctness just plain gets out of hand and this is one of those points.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

joe blow — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:58:20 GMT

I disagree. Words have power and certain words are positively explosive.
I would never label Ms. Tilghman as racist. However, she, as a broadcaster, has to be more thoughtful and circumspect in doing her job. I'm certain she would never use a term about sexual or physical assault about a female golfer. Neither would she make a comment about Jews using an insensitive expression.
The fact that she and Tiger Woods are friends is immaterial. There are a lot of African-Americans who watch the GolfChannel as well as people who were offended by her choice of words.
I, personally, believe Ms Tilghman does a professional job on the GolfChannel. But everyone is accountable. She is unfortunately learning this basic lesson the hard way right now. It's a mistake she won't repeat. I'm certain.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Larry, San Francisco, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 00:59:34 GMT

Lynch is a commonly occurring Irish surname, and growing I saw many westerns where there were lynch mobs, dispensing frontier justice, and killing often innocent people by mistake, eg The Oxbow incident.

Typical Al Sharpton going on his usual rant about a word that applies to so called Vigilante justice, applies to anyone, of any race

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

F Green, NY, NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:00:07 GMT

Amen! I pray that one day Mr. Sharpton will get a moment of clarity and see just how much irreparable damage he is single-handedly causing race relations in this country.
Ms. Tilghman, what an absurdly harsh punishment for a simple slip of the tongue. Maybe your critics should try being perfect on live TV sometime.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

C Thompson, St. Petersburg FL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:00:16 GMT

Okay, I'll grant that what she said was innocent enough. Stupid but innocent. Further I'll grant that maybe we've become too sensitive about off the cuff remarks. But the fact remains, it was a poor choice of words and if they were said on any other network, she would have been fired. The word lynch is offensive to a great many people. Perhaps not the people who have the luxury of going through life never having to think of themselves as white Americans, but like it or not its a bad word. Just as the N word should not be uttered by anyone of any race, neither should the word lynch. So yes she should have been suspended (without pay) and yes she should be given sensitivity training. No she shouldn't be fired. And Reverend Sharpton might do well not to be too sensative in the future.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John C SF Bay Area — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:00:39 GMT

Thank you, It is about time a column fired back at the beloved racist Reverend Sharpton. It seems as if Sharpton and Revrend Jackson only run around and get involved in what appears or is injustices to one particular race. This I find myself to be quite racist. The term lynch has a few meanings as you stated. If the Rev is worried about racist terms why don't they start really going after the sub culture that thinks as long as you are black you can use the N***a word anytime you want. I am caucasian and I find the word ffensive when I hear it coming out of their mouths. Lets do away with that word before we go after words with far mor meanings.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bill — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:00:54 GMT

Agree 100%

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Karen Sommers, Sydney, NSW, Australia — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:01:32 GMT

I think what Kelly Tilghman said was totally out of line, she used this term Lynching as a way of getting a laugh, Kelly I'll be laughing when you get the arse!
I think Tiger was too forgiving, lyching is an unlawful act that refers to mob attacks on an individual resulting in death. To be a commentator is one thing, to make a joke at ones expense on something awful is another.
Get rid of her or I'll boycott Golf!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JOH DOE SEATLE, WASH. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:02:21 GMT

I think the 3 Reverends, Jackson, Sharpton and Whitlock just offered up one more word in the English language we can't use with a particular race. These 3 Einsteins must sit around all day with nothing to do bu see what words we can't use any more, they are our new Websters.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jimee, Newburgh, NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:03:31 GMT

As usual, Celzic got somebody's number. It's ok if you don't like it. Thanks, Mike, for exposing the racial instigator Sharpton for what he is. Here in the Hudson Valley we know all about his phony attempts to stir up racial trouble. He is the problem, not the solution.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

dick phillips, grove city, ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:03:54 GMT

I agree.
Why does the media give this man an ounce of publicity? All he does is create a mountain out of a mole hill. If there is a racist person in this whole story, it is him. I grew up watching westerns and the word lynching had nothing to do with racism. If he got to fire everyone he felt said a racist remark the unemployment rate would be unbelievable. Does he want everyone fired because he cant find a legitimat job or maybe he hopes he may qualify for one?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Curt, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:04:40 GMT

Mike Celzic,

Thank you for some common sense.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Matthew, South Carolina — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:05:00 GMT

Might be a stupid comment, but this is a huge over reaction. Would I expect anything less from un-Sharpton. He's going around saying everyone else should be fired for comments less than what he says ever day. Why hasn't that racist been ousted, or are some people around him to stupid to realize that he's nothing but a racist idiot.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kelly - Sacramento, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:05:39 GMT

This was not an offhand use of the N word or calling someone a 'ho'. This was a sportscaster making an extremely inappropriate (jovial?) call for competitors to take Tiger Woods into an alley and lynch him. There is no room for that anywhere. Don't kill the message just because Al Sharpton delivered it. If Tiger Woods were your son or your husband or your father you'd understand what a horrific thing this was to say. Suspension doesn't go far enough.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

cardwell Lynch II, Long Beach CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:06:24 GMT

Mr. Celizic here is what you might not understand...
When someone who say is from South Carolina and grows up around a Golf course, where I am guessing even though there is a high black population in S.C., there aren't a lot of blacks are, uses the word Lynching in regards to a black golfer, one must pause and think,"How is that this phrase in this context is still in her verbal golf commentator dictionary??" I as a black man that plays golf, happens to be named "Lynch" and lives in California believe that Ms. Tilghman must consciously and or subconsciously feel negatively about black people. It's this neo-racism that is now subtle and below the radar we minorities deal with and have to be aware of. Ms. Tilghman is not going to drop any "N-Word" bombs on the air or even in public but if one listens you may hear the racism i.e. "...Lynch him in a back alley..." So don't tell me a double major from DUKE was Dumb enough to make this mistake. So even though Sharpton [finally] got the story and did his usual boycott/fire Tilghman thing, the situation shouldn't be just blown off. She should be suspended/reprimanded for the 2 weeks or whatever so she can reflect on what she said. Then we all move on. (Hopefully Sharpton too!)

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

A.C. Murphy, Abilene, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:07:00 GMT

You are incorrect. She not only offended Al Sharpton, she offended ME. I am an African American woman living in a small Texas town. It is appropriate that she be reprimanded and suspended... add some cultural sensitivity training to that package also.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Addy Sui, Boston, MA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:07:27 GMT

"What she said is racist. Whether she’s a racist ... is immaterial."

I think Sharpton accused Tilghman of saying something racist, not so much that she is or is not racist. I agree with Sharpton that the latter point does not matter because racism is not always obvious nor are we always conscious of our own racism. That she chose the word "lynch," however unconciously done, tells us that racism still exists in the fabric of America. It's in our vocabulary, in our institutions, in our behaviors. Most of us just don't know because we don't feel its consequences. I know she didn't mean any ill will towards Tiger -- they are friends, right? But that doesn't mean that Tilghman doesn't have any unconscious stereotypes or racism towards blacks in general. I think it's important that this incident teaches America that racism still exists, and however unconsciously done, it still matters.

I don't respect her any less because she accidentally said something with a racist connotation. I think all Americans stereotype or are racist in some manner because the color of our skin is still the first thing we notice about each other. What we do about those (conscious and unconscious) stereotypes and our racism, is another question. I'll use myself as an example. Do I pretend I'm not racist and continue to cross to the other side of the street every time a black man in baggy clothing walks my way? Or do I acknowledge the racism ingrained in me since childhood and work actively to eliminate those prejudices by continuing to walk straight ahead?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jeff Kassmir, Mesa, Az — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:07:41 GMT

I agree with Mike's comments and would like to think that people can make innocent slips of the tongue without being crucified for it by someone who seems to want to stir things up and get more face time, more so than trying to find the gist of the original comment.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Anonymous, Indianapolis, Indiana — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:07:46 GMT

Amen. The Reverend should practice what he preaches. I was raised to believe you should set a good example, especially if you are setting yourself up as a moral authority. I don't believe I have ever seen Mr. Sharpton forgive and forget, but he will always use every opportunity to stir up racial hatred. His hatred of whites and contempt for women is glaringly evident, sadly. He claims to be a Shepherd of our Lord. I see no evidence of that in his public behavior.

In this instance, he should follow Tiger's lead on how Tiger perceived what was said, as he (Al) was not the one supposedly "wronged", and accept that it was not meant or received with a racial connotation and keep his proboscis out of it.
Tiger's response is a mature one that could promote healing between our races instead of fanning the flames of hatred.
There are more of use out here who manage to have friendships and relationships with those of other races than you might think. I don't think of my friends as black or white or Puerto Rican or whatever. I think of them as my friends, people whose company I enjoy. I thank God for putting these good people in my life. It gives me hope that despite people like those with Mr. Sharpton's attitude, we might one day be able to talk to one another without having to be careful to not say certain words in fear of offending someone because someone else attached the label 'racial slur' to a word.
I would like that day to be soon, Mr. Sharpton. Maybe you could contribute by toning down the rhetoric, shedding your 'holier-than-thou' persona, and remembering we are all imperfect, (saved only by God's grace) stumbling around trying to do our best in spite of that imperfection.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Julian Langham, Houston, Texas. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:08:39 GMT

How pathetic it is to watch as the people of this great country, the United States of America, fall to their knees begging the pardon of the Reverend Al Sharpton every time he seizes upon the opportunity to flaunt his righteous indignation in the name of racism. I'm not an American, and I'm embarrassed for you all.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jon, Charlotte, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:09:05 GMT

I have never read an article more true. Thank you for being the one person with the guts to call Sharpton out.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Steven, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:10:51 GMT

This is the most clueless columnist this side of fox sports. When did it become acceptable to make a reference to a black man and lynching by anyone let alone a white woman? Just because they are good friends or maybe good friends does not give her the priviledge of saying something like that. White america can choose to ignore the remaining racial tensions if they choose but when something as insensitive as this is said it only underlines the apathy they feel for black america. If you were referring to a Jew you wouldn't say "My they should lock him/her in a concentration camp" because that is racially and culturally insensitive. The reason that this is deemed acceptable is because that white america has not accepted responsibility for its role in slavery, black oppression and racism and until it does then any comment that refers to lynching or Nigger spoken by a white person will be infuriating to the black community. I am black and I have white friends and they wouldn't dare utter a phrase like that to much and certainly not on national tv. You said shame on the network and shame on the director but shame on the anchor and shame on you for denying the history of the word and continuing to be insensitive at best. Maybe you feel like Ron Paul's Newsletter was great literature.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James D — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:11:57 GMT

I just cant understand why you folks just won't get it! There is NOTHING TRIVIAL about lynching. Perhaps if someone started making light of the Jewish Houlocaust, you would understand. The suspension of this individual who went to a southern school and surely knows the reference was odious, was deserved and appropriate. If the Golf Channell had the enlightened view of most people of decency and had taken action right away Rev. sharpton would not have to be involved.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Anna Bowman — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:12:52 GMT

Mike your column is absolutely stupid. First of Al Sharpton did not get Imus fired. The incident about the Rutgers basketball team was championed by the Association of Black Journalist. For you to deny how many African American men were lynched in this country is insulting. Lynching is a specific term that refers to hanging African American men and some women. When cattle rustler or horse thieves were caught they were simply hanged, not lynched. The problem is that caucasion people like yourself and like the newscaster and Dom Imus refuse to respect Americans of African decent. Google the word lynched and see what links you get or listen to the song Strange Fruit. Everybody in the world but you seems to know that lynching flourished in this country during and after slavery and was perpetrated on African Americans by caucasions. If you really think that Al Sharpton is the problem then you should be suspended for two week also for being so out of touch with reality. She offended me and I e-mailed the station with my complaint. I don't even know Al Sharpton.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Karen, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:13:29 GMT

Mike Celizic is an idiot. As an African-American woman I don't think lynching is an appropriate subject for a joke. But, let's add some more contexts to Celizic's theory to see how it holds up. Commenters should submit "jokes" about the Holocaust, 911, Abu Ghraib, Hiroshima, etc. I think we’ll quickly find that human suffering, degradation and slaughter is never to be taken lightly under any circumstances. Remember, what's usually considered acceptable is all relative to who you are. When the public airwaves are used, respect for everyone’s history must be adhered to. I say hold those who spew accountable for their venom regardless of their “intent”!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Eddie, Mission Viejo, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:15:05 GMT

If I made a joke about the holocaust in jest should I have no repercussion. Should she be fired, absolutely not. Should she have a "timeout" for being careless. Yes she should.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Robert Schultz, Battle Ground, WA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:15:46 GMT

Rev. Sharpton should practive what he preaches; literally. As an African-American, he was understandably offended by the remakrs of Ms. Tilghman, but a Christian, he is OBLIGATED to forgive such an offense (even if it were repeated again seven times seventy). While Afrcan Americans may gain from the reverand's remarks, Christians everywhere have already lost. He should know that forgiveness trumps offense every time.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

odell metcalf wadsworth il — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:15:52 GMT

Mr Celizic,

If you want to address racism you probaly will need more experience on the cruel recieving end of it. Say, like Al Sharpton. He knows it when he sees it, hears it and smell it. I am sure you are skilled at what ever you do for a living. Don't shoot the messenger because you don't like the message.

Dell

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Doe, Virginia — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:16:14 GMT

Mike, you just don't get it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Garrick Purdie — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:16:39 GMT

Mr. Celizic is mistaken in this. The fact is that the broadcaster made a reference that many African-Americans find racist and hurtful. I SHOULD NOT EVER HAVE TO HEAR THAT!! That is the point, not if she meant it or not. It is also immaterial that Tiger and the broadcaster are friends. She is not commentating for Tiger Woods. She is commenting for MY benefit, the television viewer. And she screwed up big time. Sometimes it does not matter what your intent was. No worries though. The Golf Channel will not EVER be turned on in my home again as long as she is there. Given golf's sketchy past with people of color, they won't miss me anyway.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

KingCrusher — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:17:00 GMT

Amen.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Somebody, Dallas, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:18:16 GMT

As a 42 year old African-American, I'm offended that there even needs to be an article on this. I've experienced several forms of racism and it's quite clear from the telecast that Kelly Tilghman meant no offense. Actions like those taken by the Golf Channel only breed resentment among races. Fortunately most of us are not so easily offended.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Richard — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:18:45 GMT

Your wrong Mike; I am offended, I guess that makes two of us.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Stanley Anderson, San Francisco, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:18:55 GMT

Your perspective is a bit naive. I agree that a two week suspension may seem over the top, but suggesting that there be no reprimand for such an egregious offense would be a serious error in judgement. All people, not just people of color, have the right to not be vilified regardless of context. There are a host of things that well meaning people say in jest, or by mistake, to make a point. In private conversations, these areas can be addressed on the spot, or even overlooked if appropriate. On television, there is no room for such "thoughtless" errors. I personally don't believe the Ms. Tilghman is a racist. I do believe that her words have stirred the indignation of all people that have ever been verbally assaulted on purpose or otherwise and she should therefore be punished.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Anonymous — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:20:12 GMT

Agreed! Sick of hyper-sensitive reactions to just about any word in the dictionary.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Amanda M. Brooklyn, NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:20:58 GMT

I don't think she is a racist, only what she said was not funny, rather it's very offensive and hurtful to me as a young black woman.

Perhaps she should not be fired but she must make a "public apology" because she was speaking of Tiger Woods but she was speaking to the general public therefore she should apologies to the general public as well. Also, She should be suspended for another month or so with no pay and she should be send to a sensitivity class or something to curb her thinking for Public television because that kind of remark is unacceptable on national television.

Thank you,
A.M.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rob Morris — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:23:16 GMT

I agree with M.Celzic, esp. after viewing the video. Nothing was said about Nick Faldo's comment, (nor should there have been). K.T. just added to his commentary. There is too much critisizm (sp?) of sports analysts & what they say. Please, give them the benefit of the doubt. Best of luck, & best of golf to Tiger & all his competiters!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Barry, Anderson Indiana — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:23:45 GMT

Mike, for once you have written something worth reading. Al Sharpton breaths racism and feeds it. As soon as he is off this earth the world will be a better place. We all knew what Kelly meant. No harm intended. Im sure most African Americans knew that also. SHame on Al Sharpton. Hes fat and lazy and this is what he does. Until the networks stop giving him his 10 minutes..racism in this country will continue to be at the forefront.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ace Freely — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:23:51 GMT

Agreed. All Sharpton is a tool. If the standard was you get fired for saying something stupid, he'd be fired every week on the week.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Matthew — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:23:59 GMT

She should be suspended.

Woman is not a "misogynistic" term. "This man" can be used as well if the perpetrator was a man.

Also, imagine if a man said:

"Rape her in the back alley"

The man would be held accountable and so should she.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

J Shepard New Braunfels, Texas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:25:32 GMT

I fully agree.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Butch Strubble, Tallahassee, Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:26:10 GMT

Shame on the Golf Channel for investing an instant of their time listening to that doofus gadfly, Al Sharpton, and for suspending Kelly Tilghman.

What? Are we supposed to drop the word "lynch" from our vocabulary? How about coon, or colored? Is ol' Al gonna start foaming at the mouth because he hears somebody say they went "coon" hunting last weekend, or that we "colored" some Easter eggs?

I've got two words for "Charlatan" Al Sharpton; Tawana Brawly.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Scott Coatsworth, Pittsburgh, PA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:26:18 GMT

Thank you, Mike. I only wish that the entire media community was wise enough to not even afford Al Sharpton his undeserved 15 minutes.

I urge The Golf Channel to reconsider their suspension of Kelly Tilghman - she doesn't deserve it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim Myrtle Beach, SC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:26:46 GMT

It's a shame that Al Sharpton is taken seriously as a voice for morality, or for what is right or wrong. Can I get Rev. Sharpton fired for things I find offensive that he spouts off about on a regular basis? Kelly Tilghman had no intention of offending anyone, let alone Tiger. She's getting shafted because a real racist found something else to keep his name in the news. It's a sad world.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

allen mcneill, parkesburg,pa — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:27:43 GMT

She should not have been suspended.The apology was appropriate enough for an on air co-anchor. The Al Sharpton "Racist Police Dept." is at hand again, saying that a word was blurted out with offensive racial overtones on the air. I didn't know Al was into golf? Look, I'm half native american and irish-scottish. I hear indian and cracker terms and they don't offend me because I don't let them. Just stop it, Al.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dwayne California — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:28:20 GMT

Al Sharpton is a disgrace to the black community and is the biggest ambulance chaser in this country. He would be out of business if there were no racism, therefore he continues to fuel the exact thing is supposedly hates. He is the perfect example that shows a person can be any skin color and still be a racist.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John, Atlanta, Ga — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:28:39 GMT

I couldn't agree more, sometimes I feel I'm the only on that can Al Sharpton causes far more racial hate than he would ever have the capacity to cure. He is an insult to all MLK stood for.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

David Larsen, Irving, Tx — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:30:05 GMT

Finally someone with a real public voice says something about how Al Sharpton conducts his witch hunt and tries to rid the world of all the "horrible racists". Its time that people with a public voice standup and speak out against Sharpton's tactics for personal gain and fame.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Andy, New York City — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:31:53 GMT

I'm a black man and must say that lynching, when used by a white in the context of violence against a black, is bound to have racial overtones. And also coming right on the heels of the Jenna Six where some white youths tried to get some black youths by hanging ropes in a tree, and also coming in the heels of episodes of nooses appearing in various public places, evry person with access to media has to check their brain before they open their mouth. That said, I do believe, however, that this golfer was not espousing race in her comments about Woods. And I have no problem with the suspension because it would make it harder for the next commentator to slip that easily. As for Rev. Al, he has to do what he has to do. In a country where people are still overt racists, blacks need a voice, and that's where Rev. Al comes in. Like him or loathe him, he is serving a purpose.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

minority girl, ws, nc — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:32:16 GMT

I am so sick of people who claim raicism for every little comment. Who among us has not spoken out of turn or maybe just said something that was not totally appropriate for the given situation? If the subject at thand (Tiger Woods) understands that it was a statement meant in jest, perhaps the Reverend Sharpton should also take note and focus on issues that are more demanding not only of his time, but also of ours as a collective society. As a minority female, I have had it up to here with people who claim to be speaking out on behalf of oppressed minorities. I have worked hard to achieve my career level and satisfaction - I don't need anyone to speak out on my behalf to say that I was oppressed and I would venture to say that Tiger Woods feels the same way. He is fully capable of expressing his emotions and opinions without others stepping in on his supposed behalf as a minority male.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

jim - Indianapolis, Indiana — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:33:03 GMT

Tilghman is a dedicated commentator for the golf channel and I am 100% sure as is Tiger Woods that no animosity was intended. Give her a break and give me a break for suspending her is a joke and wrong. Al Sharpton is wrong in escalating this and he should know this. His credibility is waning with many and few if any people take him seriously and he know this also.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

jeff W — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:33:42 GMT

maybe sharpton wants her job, after all he doesn't have a real job!!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike, Greenville, SC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:34:24 GMT

Well said. With people like Reverend Sharpton scrutinizing every word "whitey" says, we'll never get beyond defining speach in terms of color.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Richard La Qunita California — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:36:02 GMT

Thank you for your thoughts. I totally agree this was taken way out of context for someone's own personal ego needs.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

IHW — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:36:40 GMT

Once again, Al Sharpton put himself and other African Americans in a position of being thought of as unreasonable and impossible to live with. It's really a shame that every person of 'non'color' has to constantly second guess themselves BEFORE saying anything, however innocent, to avoid the zealots who can't wait to pounce on anyone they want to persecute for persecution sake. I'd be willing to bet anything that most people of color are as embarassed by Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson as the two ought to be about themselves. I feel bad for our country and the direction we're going in.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Keith Henson — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:37:26 GMT

My wife and I just had a conversation about this (I'm white and she's black) and we both agree: Al Sharpton is the worst thing to happen to race relations in this country since slavery itself. His rantings do nothing but convince black people there is racism where none exists and makes (most) white people leery of speaking around black people lest they inadvertently say something offensive.

Honestly, the world could learn something from mine and my wife's relationship - she laughingly tells me I can't dance and smell like a dog when I get wet and I tease her every time she eats watermelon and fried chicken (both of which she loves) and we'd both die for the other - I simple couldn't imagine life without her.

Racism won't truly stop in this country until we stop saying racist things AND stop looking for racial intent in things said. It’s a two way street.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Henry Hale, Ashburn, VA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:38:12 GMT

Obviously, you don't know the sordid history of the word "lynch" in the Black man's world. Just because Al Sharpton made this an issue isn't going to let you minimize the situation.
It's absolutely appalling that you would think those words coming from a white woman's or anyone's mouth are trivial. Anyone that's idiotic to think that Black people don't associate violence with the word has no business being allowed to write a column for anyone.
You are the one who is shameful, not Sharpton, and you shouldn't bait most white people's hatred with the Rev. in order to make this situation right.
The suspension is totally acceptable, and there's good reason to feel termination should've been an option. Shame on you Mr. Celizic for being so out of touch with the world and how you're giving license to the resurgence of people thinking it's okay to use that type of term.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jeff Gallagher, Seattle Wash. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:42:18 GMT

Al Sharpton was not the only one offended, I was too. The media allows for too much to be said nowadays. Mike, you have become desensitized like the rest of America. The comment is offensive, and she should be fired. I'm sorry, but i just don't buy the excuses you provide for her. Professionals such as Tilghman in the broadcasting business should be able to control their mouths.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob Apo, Atlanta, GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:42:47 GMT

Congratulations Mike for having the guts to stand up to a bully. Has Sharpton ever even apologized in the many cases where he has wrongfully jumped on a racial bandwagon...? I'm thinking Duke here.

It's beyond sad that Dr. King is no longer with us. I think that both he and Frederick Douglass would be ashamed of Rev. Sharpton and to some degree Rev. Jackson for many of the same unfair tactics.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JP Campion, Atlanta, GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:42:55 GMT

Shame on you, Mike Celzic. Your defense of Kelley Tilghman is evidence enough of your lack of insight into the implication of Ms. Tilghman's remark. I suggest you read the first chapter of "Snakewalkers" by Everett Spiller to measure the impact of the term applied to anyone, let alone a black man.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Fred — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:43:40 GMT

I have watched and admired Tiger Woods' talent for many years---And have the utmost respect for him as both a person and an athelete---I have Zero respect for a Racist and Hate-Monger such as the "Rev" Al Sharpton--In a world of true racial-respect and Harmony, Tiger Woods should come to the defense of "this woman" and speak against people such as Sharpton who make a living, seek the headlines and truly enjoy any opportunity to cause an offensive or racial divide in our nation--

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jerry Renteria — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:45:55 GMT

Wow! What a POWERFUL presentation of the facts.

I strongly support an effort to reverse the harm that has been committed.

Jerry Renteria

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

K Pelot — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:48:08 GMT

Bravo! It's about time someone started holding Sharpton accountable; one must wonder how long he would last if he held himself to the same standards he expects from everyone else. Equity is invaluable, but Sharpton has lost his focus in his search for headlines.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Greg Cox, Washington, DC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:50:15 GMT

While I agree in principle, none-the-less, the word "to lynch" comes from and 18th century slave owner in Virginia who believed violence induced fear was the best way to keep slaves in check. The very term is rooted deep in slavery and is, understandably, very offensive to black America. It is, to be sure, a completely inappropriate word to use by a broadcaster.

Incidently, most American western referred to cattle rustlers being "hanged" or "strung up" - not lynched. Having both read and watched Ox Bow I agree that the Rev. should be careful about rushing to judgement.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jonny Baltimore — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:50:48 GMT

Mike, you are a controversial git as well.
But I have to agree 100% this time.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

jerome jasse — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:51:33 GMT

good job. good article. sharpton is self serving at best and seems to get up in the morning looking to see what he can poke his nose into next. it's a shame he gets so much press and makes the rest of black america look so bad.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob, Maryland — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:52:27 GMT

I don't agree with you all the time but in this case you are 1000% correct. I'm sure Tiger knows it was in jest. All Al Sharpton wants is more time added to his 15 minutes of fame.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John, Baltimore, MD — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:52:29 GMT

Well said, Mike. Kelly was most likely guilty of a bad mixed metaphor - something we all do when trying to come up quickly with a throw away line. There's never been anything else in her repertoir to suggest ill will toward any ethnic group (or person for that matter).

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James Hughes, Plantation, Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:52:30 GMT

I completely agree with the writer, as I am a child born into a life with morals of equality, not of bigotry. I understand Al Sharpton is not wrong in being upset or even angry, he can chose what words offend him. I do believe he is wrong for his judgments, it's very simple, as an activist it is his job to shine the limelight on what he believes to be racist, unfair, or offensive, but where he oversteps the line is when he demands the punishment of those he accuses. To attack these incidents with such vengeance
is unnecessary and irresponsible, as a National Leader he should understand that his vengeance can lead his followers to hate the people he should be trying to help. Rather than demanding this woman's job, he should be offering his help, so that she can understand and learn from this incident. I believe Al Sharpton has the ability to help people, so long as he understands the power of his own words.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

MoeInaMus, Los Angeles, Ca. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:53:24 GMT

I agree with Sharpton "The channel has to be accountable to the public."

>not everyone automatically associates lynching with racism

Well, if you are black in America you do! I wonder why? Could it be that thousands of youg black men were lynched??

>If she or he looks guilty to him[Sharpton], that’s enough.

No, its what they SAY!!!! not how they look!

For this guy there is no racism unless someone calls you nigger and burns a cross on your hard. Well guess what - its the 21st century, they have upgraded. Ask the Dog!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ann thompson Idaho Falls, Id — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:54:32 GMT

Shame on Mr. Sharpton. I suppose the lynching of the horse thieves in the old West, was a racial event. Tiger,being the great gentleman that he is, was not offended. And, I don't think he needs Sharpton to defend him.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Josh Grulkowski, Wausau, Wisconsin — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:54:55 GMT

I say Tiger Woods should take a shot at Al Sharpton...and shove it in his face.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Greg, Chesapeake Beach, MD — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:55:01 GMT

Bravo! Very well said. Sharpton is a bust . . .

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Knoxville, TN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:55:06 GMT

Well Said!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dennis Haun — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:55:14 GMT

Amen..the reverend uses "Racism to his advantage only when it suits him and yes I am white. What would he do if he didn't have the racism card to drop. Reality is he needs a life and should spend his efforts helping the black community instead of using it only to HIS adcantage. This world needs less of him and more proactive folks with a vision and not a personal agenda!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

eric vonderhaar, seattle, wa — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:56:02 GMT

Kelly, the reporter, showed me she had NO racial intent. It was too quick and light hearted to be. Sharpton has to know that his penance for the reporter being to fire her only increases racial divisions. Shame on Al Sharpton and the Golf Channel for not standing up for what is right.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob Henry, White Plains, NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:56:12 GMT

Thank you Mr. Celizic for your very clear and reasoned discussion. Indeed Mr. Sharpton has much to apologize for himself, starting with the Tawana Brawley affair. Demagoguery is absolutely the right word.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Cole (Fishers, IN) — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 01:56:14 GMT

Shame on you Mike. What she said is completely unacceptable and for you to trivalize the comment as not a big deal is very very sad. She is lucky she wasn't fired, its not normal to have a slip of the tongue and inadvertently associate a black man and lynching. You're disrespect for Sharpton is unwarranted, and I question your motives in writing this article. Personally, I think you should be suspended for tolerating and being sympathetic to such a racist remark.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

ML, Seattle, WA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:00:52 GMT

Bravo for attempting to call attention to this type of repeated "Call to Arms" soap boxing Sharpton is constantly hyper-ventilating about. No doubt there are plenty of instances and issues where his attention could be an asset however it seems the past few years have disturbingly and sadly had him rallying on countless issues where no issue exist. Stir a cool, still pot of water with enough vigor and over-zealous attention and it too also begins to appear like it is boiling and dangerous. Is this just a need to attract attention and grow their notoriety and be seen leading a march associated with a current event? C'mon, they can't be that shallow and still in need, are they? You can include Rev Jesse Jackson in this regular shameful camp also.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Fred Robledo — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:01:17 GMT

She should feel extremely lucky she was only suspended for two weeks.
This had nothing to do about her friendship with Tiger Woods. It doesn't matter whether or not it offended Tiger Woods. The word she used was offensive to African-Americans. It's a word that never should be used, even in a "playful" way, and especially when the person being talked about happens to be black.
The problem with the sport of golf is that it lives in its own private world, most of the time in private country clubs.
That such a word should come out of her mouth is disgusting. What could she have been thinking about?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Carlton R.Williams, Tampa, Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:01:27 GMT

Ms. Tilghman, unfortunately, did use a word that is racially charged. In the context of making a comment about Tiger Woods, arguably the most famous African-American golfer in history, she stepped into a viper's nest. Racial bans at Augusta, the fact that most African-Americans at country clubs and on golf courses were working there and not qualified for membership, and lynchings of Black Americans are all phenomena well within living memory. Its the context that has set Sharpton off. Golf and country club venues have been exclusionary in the extreme. They have been domains of priveledge, reserved for the money and power elite -- largely, if not exclusively, a white power elite. To use the "L" word in reference to one African-American who has, by his talent, come to dominate a formerly all-white sport should provoke a prompt and acrid response. Tilghman suffers from an inadequate historical and social perspective. Lynching was a favorite pastime of active racist facists (KKK and the like) who sought, through their terrorism, to 'keep the "N" in his place. That you, yourself, did not become aware of the race-linked aspects of lynching "until much later in life" speaks volumes about your education and your appearantly narrow historical, social and political frame of reference. The Southern Poverty Law Center will be able to bring you up to speed on the numbers of African-Americans whose lives ended before jeering crowds for no crime other than being Black. Shame on you for not having acquired an awareness sufficient for you to understand Rev. Sharpton's point of view. For every cattle rustler or horse theif strung-up, hundreds of Black men died, not for their individual crimes, but in service to a rabidly ferocious race hatred. Get a clue!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Frustrated in MI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:02:11 GMT

Amen,

Sharpton breeds racism. Between him and Jackson they just stoke the hate fire of racism. Why does CNN put him on?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Otto Lekare, Mexico City — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:03:09 GMT

Great column. I think this was made way bigger (by Sharpton) than it really was. But then again, the Rev. is always looking to get publicity.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tim M — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:03:42 GMT

I believe that if it as a white man that said what Kelly Tilghman said, they would have been fired, and not simply suspended.

Remember the reaction when Fuzzy Zoeller made an unfortunate comment regarding Tiger's dinner selection after a Master's win?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chrs, Memphis, TN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:03:58 GMT

You are an idiot! You do not understand. I bet had she accidentally said, "They should burn him in big oven." You'd want her fired for good. How insensitive of you to say you think she should not be suspended. You do not know how those words effect a class of people. This country has to be more understanding. It was not that long ago!!!! I don't wonna hear his foolishness about intent,intention has nothing to do with it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Scott, Salem, VA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:04:07 GMT

I would love if Tiger came out personally, instead of through his agent, and tell Sharpton to just shut up!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JimS ny ny — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:04:53 GMT

Sharptom wants Imus fired for what he said.
Sharpton wants an apology from Isiah Thomas for what he said.
Sharpton wants Tilghman fired for what she said.
Hmmmm ... is it me ... or is there a double standard here ?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Marko1965, Vivtoria BC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:04:57 GMT

Who cares if Al Sharpton is up in arms (what's new?) or that Tiger Woods could care less about what Kelly Tilghman said. It has nothing to do with them; it has to do with the rest of us. Just because Tiger Woods isn't offended doesn't mean that other people can't be. I have no doubt that Kelly Tilghman regrets what she said and meant nothing by it, but then the same could be said about Don Imus. If Kelly Tilghman's can make these comments with impunity, can all of us?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

D. Wilson Elk Grove, Ca — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:06:11 GMT

I couldn't have said it better myself. I understand the potential the use of the word has, but shouldn't each situation be judged on it's own merit, and in this case what her intention was in making the comment, certainly not racial..

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rick Larsen, Nashua NH — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:07:11 GMT

The last thing the reverand would like to see is improvements in race relations. Who would ever pay attention to him any more? It's in his best interest to stir up as much animosity between races as possible. He used to do it by spouting racist nonsense himself, no he calls out so called racist whites for what he perceives as their shortcomings.
Ms. Tighman probably slipped in her use of insensitive language beacuse she most likely doesn't think of Tiger Woods as a black man, but a great golfer. I'm sure Reverand Sharpton doesn't understand that kind of thinking.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Winston — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:08:25 GMT

Celizic doesn't know what the hell he's talking about. Just because this comment was made about an athlete on a sports network doesn't make his credibility to address a social issue worth squat.

Intentional or not, when someone screws up, they are disciplined for it. I don't think she should be fired, but certainly a suspension is in order. People get ejected and/or suspended and/or fined all the time for messing up, especially in such glaringly public fashion. While the person being punished may not like it, they will always respect the action.

And honestly, when do you ever actually hear someone use the term "lynching" in other than a racially charged reference?

Stick to your day job, Celizic, because you sure won't be in line for any humanitarian awards.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

joeblow — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:08:51 GMT

Al Sharpton is one of the main reasons race relations are the way they are now. In the last 40 to 50 years relations have worsened. This is due largely in part to the people such as Sharpton who are constantly stirring the "pot of racial contempt". I am so sick of this behavior. The sad part is that the majority of black America does not have the initiative nor the individualism to rise above this. By the way, I am white and I know that someone will make a point of that. However, being white does not make me racist nor ignorant.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Todd, Studio City, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:09:24 GMT

Couldn't agree more, Mike. We have a culture where certain people - Al Sharpton is one person in particular - seem to jump to a conclusion that every comment is racially motivated. This is how the good Reverend keeps his name in the news, I guess. My response is simply to ignore what I consider to be a stupid comment from Mr. Sharpton.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Klaus, Fountain Hills, AZ — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:09:47 GMT

Wow Mr. Sharpton. So quick with the whip! Really makes one wonder why you didn't treat Mr. Thomas (of Knicks fame) in the same way. After all, what he did to and how he treated a Black woman was far worse.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

doug — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:10:55 GMT

very childish

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jodi ,Sioux Falls, South Dakota — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:12:54 GMT

Sharpton has quite a way with making a mountain out of a molehill, people like him who cry racism over anything a person says, are the people who make racism an issue in the first place. Had the announcer been black, Sharpton would not have made an issue out of it at all. Racism is wrong all around and allowing blacks but not whites to say certain things without punishment should be considered racism too. I seriously doubt the announcer had any thoughts of racism when the comment was made. Al Sharpton has done a lot in regards to equality but he is badly abusing his influence and should be ashamed of himself.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

D. Paterson — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:14:34 GMT

It is people like Al Sharpton that are the problem when it comes to race in America. He sits back and looks for anything he can turn into a slur. It is pretty obvious that Ms. Tilghman's intent was to continue Nick Faldo's thoughts that Tiger is pretty much unbeatable. To turn this into a big deal is an embarasment for the black people that Mr. Sharpton claims to represent and the Golf Channel, who don't have the guts to stand up for their employees.

D.P.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ken Jacobs, Walnut Creek, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:16:40 GMT

Amen, Mike. Enough with the "offense" everyone takes at every unintended remark. People need to lighten up and have tougher skin. What is really ashame is that incidents like this overshadow true racism, who's perpetrators are much more calculating than show their true colors in public

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Donovan, Denver, Colorado — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:18:02 GMT

Once again, the all mighty Al Sharpton takes nothing and turns it into something for his own gain and to promote racism. I would expect this from a member of the Klan. As much as I would like to speak for everyone, I can only speak for myself. Al Sharpton is by far and away the worst thing to ever happen to end racism. As for the Golf channel, I will actually make an effort to never watch your channel again. You should be embarassed.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

disappointed in Bangkok — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:18:04 GMT

One of the best commentaries Mr. Celizic has ever written and he has written many. Double shame on the Golf Channel. And double shame on Al Sharpton for his 'lynching' of the this commentator.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tired of Al, Chicago — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:18:30 GMT

Al Sharpton is exercising his own version of descrimination by assuming Kelly T was referencing African Americans. Al needs to get a life , get thicker skin and quit the narrow focused witch hunt. African Americans don't own the rights to the term lynching. Throught time Christians were lynched, cattle rustlers were lynched, the lynce mob even went after Frankenstein. I don't see any of these groups claining foul. I agree it was a poor choice of words but the reference was not target to any group in particular. Al is an opportunist who needs to find more constructive things to do than waist air time with his self pity.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob Vogel, Benicia, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:18:34 GMT

I agree with you when you say "shame on Al Sharpton." Unfortunately, Mr. Sharpton has no shame and is nothing more than an opportunistic clown working the media for nothing more than showboating opportunities. Shame on the media for pandering to this worthless performer and his completely irrelevant comments.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike Harris, Cocoa Beach, Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:19:18 GMT

Oh no! You called Sharpton a 'cowboy'! You're gonna get it now! But in all honesty, you are absolutely right. He doesn't care about Tiger or Tilghman. It's been at least two weeks or more since he was last on TV and this just gave him the perfect reason to put on a show.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tony Van Zwaren, Ridgefield, NJ — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:19:36 GMT

Whether Tiger Woods took personal offense or not is not really relevant. The fact is, when you talk about lynching and reference it towards a person of African American descent, even if of mixed parentage, that is a racially charged remark even if it was not racially motivated. Her suspension was mild in my opinion and I'm white, and not a huge Al Sharpton supporter. At the very least it demonstrated her complete insensitivity as to how such a comment would be taken.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Carlos Balandran, Akron, Ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:19:57 GMT

I am an international student studying in Ohio. Perhaps my comments won't mean as much being a foreigner, but I, like many I'm sure, am disgusted by Reverend Sharpton meddling in everybody's bussiness. Why should he feel offended by Tilghman's comments? Tiger Woods is okay with it, why isn't Sharpton? I am amazed by the importance placed on this man. He is nothing but a snake that spreads venom and fuels the fire in every "scandalous" situation. He blows issues out of proportion as in this case. I will stop now, but will leave wondering why this man keeps getting so much air time.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

D. Paterson — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:20:01 GMT

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

steve lynch — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:20:43 GMT

I didn't realize that the word lynch was so offensive, I too, thought of the western cowboy lynching the cattle rustler. Shame on Al Sharpton for thinking that everybody else in this world should be sitting on the edge of their seats waiting for the next politically incorect comment to come across the airways so we can pounce on the hapless talking head before he or she knew what hit them. Don't forget where you came from Al. I remember when you were a goofy bit on the Howard Stern Show. Callers would call in and bet if a contestant was smarter then Al Sharpton (the contestant was usually homeless or a stripper) The Reverend was a corner preacher that would rail against the evil white devil from a street corner in Manhattan. The sad part is he didn't even know that he looked like a fool. He just wanted to be famous.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Spice, Butler NJ — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:22:37 GMT

Lynching has gone on for thousands of years. It has been used by and against nearly every racial, religious and ethnic group.

The lady made a mistake, she mis-spoke.

She has no been lynched for her mistake.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

LO3, Houston, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:23:14 GMT

If Tiger Woods didn't have a problemn with Ms. Tilghman's comments then everyone else should just move on.

It's not political its not racial. If she were black would the reaction be equal. I'm black and I don't think so.

We've arrived at a point where no one is perfect, but we are not allowed to make mistakes. As a result, we walk on egg shells, and serious issues get watered down due to over exposure

I understand what Rev Al is trying to do. Don't bring a shotgun to a squirrel hunt. Save the big ammo for the big game. Eventually the media will start taking you for granted. We don't want that.

When are we going to start living like normal human beings?

Everyone just relax.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mark Welch, Chicago, IL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:23:32 GMT

How about another angle. How about the fact that we're talking about a young woman who has no context with lynching. No understanding about what that means to some in the black community.
Remember...it's not racism unless the dime store Reverend Al says so!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

No Al, San Diego, Ca — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:23:35 GMT

Al Sharpton would do or say anything to get on TV...
If Tiger Woods is not upset what gives anyone the right to be upset for him. Tiger knew it was a joke.
Al sharpton needs to worry about true problems, not made up problems...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jeff — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:23:58 GMT

I shudder to think what a sermon by Al Sharpton would focus on? Christ or on Al

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Gary — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:24:17 GMT

Amen!!! Al Sharpton should be suspended from speaking and pretending to be a Christian.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ali Rashada Beachmere, Qld Australia — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:24:20 GMT

While you are correct that Tiger was not offended, and the remark was not meant to be racist, or offensive, because of the history of the United States, and the race of the target of the comment, many other viewers may have been and were offended. Insensitivity is not racism, but a broadcaster, offering her thoughts to potentially millions of viewers has a much greater responsibility to be aware of the reach and power of her words. Perhaps you and many others have forgotten that black athletes have recieved death threats simply for participating in sporting events traditionally played by whites, and if God forbid they were actually better than their white competitors, the abuse and anger they received was tenfold.
No one likes to be reminded of the prejudice and violence that our country produces, but those who actually experience it cannot so easy shrug it off and act as if it has no reality in today's world

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Doe, Seattle Wash — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:25:06 GMT

You're an idiot and a racist.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

D. Wayne Gainesville, Fla. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:26:25 GMT

I agree that the commentator meant no harm, but it was a really stupid slip. If she had been talking about a white golfer she wouldn't have used the word "lynch." I find it hard to believe this columnist doesn't know when you hear the word "lynch," a hanging, tortured black body comes to mind. Not a white one. The comment didn't just offend Al Sharpton, blustery though he may be. It IS offensive, and a temporary suspension is appropriate -- no different than when a non-celebrity employee receives disciplinary action for an inappropriate behavior or remark. Don't make it about Al Sharpton.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Charles, Vernon Hills, Illinois — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:26:39 GMT

I agree with you that her statement had no malicious intent. I also agree that calling for her to be fired is rediculous. However, using the word lynching is enough to warrent a suspension. The hanging of a noose from a tree is or can be considered a hate crime. And the hanging of a noose from a tree is used or intended to intimidate people of color. Why should a noose hanging from a tree be considered a hate crime? Because a noose hanging froma tree is how they lynched African Americans. As a writer you know the importance of words and that the choice of words can make all the difference. You are right she should have used the word mug. And if she had this would not have happened. But she did.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Don D, Illinois — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:29:30 GMT

Reverend Al Sharpton is wrong and needs to be man enough to admit it and apologise. By the way what church is he a Reverend of? Every Reverend I know exercises compassion and forgiveness and teaches peace and harmony. Reverend Al seems to be more interested in inciting racial division not unity. That's not very Christian so I question his credentials as a Reverend.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ali Rashada Beachmere, Qld Australia — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:29:42 GMT

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

J, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:30:55 GMT

Rock on! I'll buy you a beer once Sharpton gets YOU suspended for being racist by criticizing him. . .

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James Sims — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:31:20 GMT

You are so right, the whites of america are so innocent. You are innocent of all the the crimes that have ever been committed towards the blacks of this land. Slavery, Jim Crow, Segregation and all the rapes and lnychings that came with these institutions.You are obsolved. Actually, your article is a sad commentary on the illness that white americans have. it is called, DENIAL!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob Vogel, Benicia, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:31:22 GMT

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Captain James Crim, USMC, Washington, DC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:34:14 GMT

Mike I totally disagree with you. Being an Officer in the Marine Corps, we have court-martialled many of them for use of that phrase. Some Officers and some Enlisted personnel. I have personally sat of the courts-martial board as we have relieved a Navy Chaplin, 3 aviators (2 Marine, 1 Naval), a host of Lance Corporals and PFC's, and a few seamen and petty officers. While I understand that you - as you put it - understand that it carries racial overtones to Blacks (myself being a Black man)...trust me sir, it offends not just Rev. Sharpton, but me and a host of my friends. To say that she does not warrant suspension is totally off base. While I personally disagree with you in thinking that she should have been fired, do not get it wrong. It is Offensive.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Doe, Seattle, Wash — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:35:19 GMT

Seriously. He's a commentator on the GOLF CHANNEL. The golf channel. Settle down. It's the golf channel. This is a channel for and by people who neglect their families for the, "sport." Let it go.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Stephon Kirk, Alexandria, Louisiana — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:36:47 GMT

I totally agree with this commentary. It seems that Al Sharpton was more offended than Tiger. I saw the comments and could not find an ounce of ill intent on the part of Kelly.

As an African American, I would love to see more effort from the Al Sharptons of the world go behind improving education, crime, teen pregnacy, and employment opportunities.

If you want to hear something really hilarious, try listening to Al's radio talk show.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

walter jones — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:36:47 GMT

You have got to be kidding me as to her only offending Sharpton. 2 minutes is too long, huh...Pleeeze! Why must we wait until you say it is ok that we can be angry? I love the Golf Channel and Kelly, too. If GC did nothing it would not have surprised me nor hurt me. I am so used this type of behavior being acceptable that I have moved on. I am glad that at least GC did something. You don't have to be a racist (whatever that means anymore) to make inappropriate remarks. Thanks you GC for having some integrity.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Wes Attaway — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:38:28 GMT

Mike is exactly right.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

AR — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:39:07 GMT

Maybe just a poor choice of words. More likely a subliminal, subtle rascist comment. What she does to rectify her own behavior is, ultimately her choice.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jack Griffith, Pinellas Park, FL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:40:11 GMT

Here here. Maybe it was a bad choice of words, but I took it as meaning that they couldn't beat him on the golf course so they'd have to beat him up in a back alley, but not because of racial issue, just because they couldn't compete with him.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:40:24 GMT

Mr. Celizic-
You can't say it is not worth a suspension then talk about Sharpton's statement. It was an asinine comment. I don't think she meant anything malicious at all but that doesn't excuse her ignorant statement. Tiger accepted her sincere apology and that settles the conflict but she made a big mistake on the air. Another anchor was fired for saying mothersucka on the air. The network brought her back after some consideration.
I am of african-american descent. You might think talking about getting lynched is small. It's not. If she said something offensive about a jewish or a latin golfer I would say the same thing.
I would also like to say Sharpton is a media whore. He doesn't speak for african americans he speaks for hisself. If your network stopped giving him and Jesse Jackson airtime maybe we wouldn't be talking about him right now. This isn't about Al Sharpton. It is about the dumb comment by Kelly Tilghman.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Don Haas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:41:12 GMT

I agree. If anyone is a racist it is Al Sharpton as he continues to stir the pot of racism by his remarks. I forgot all about race in the military back in the 60's-70's why can't he????

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

bill varconie — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:41:17 GMT

This truly trancends reality....that some individual can make this riduclous judgement and the management of the golf channel just rolls over..do we now place this managment team on the same level as the reverend

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Javier, Houston, Texas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:41:29 GMT

I'm tired of Al Sharton and African American turning every little thing into racist issues. They have too much time in their hands. Maybe they should spend more time bettering themselves instead of accusing everybody of been racist. This country would be a better place.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Q. Public — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:41:39 GMT

There was nothing innocent and her ignorant tirade was no verbal slip...

Keep on spinning!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jeff, Norman, OK — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:42:00 GMT

Sharpton says "Lynch him in a back alley" is racist. Looking up the word "lynch" at dictionary.com , it doesn't give me a vulgar definition of the word, nor give me any hint that the phrase is vulgar. Usually that website is pretty good about telling when something is inappropriate. Either the website is wrong, or Sharpton is reading too much into it. Yeah, someone should be put to death in a back alley is definately wrong, but I don't it's a racist comment.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tom Daly — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:42:48 GMT

I probably disagree with 90% of Mr. Celizic's opinions, but this one is dead on. I didn't know Until researching it today, that the word comes from a William Lynch, who hung black slaves without trial in the 1800's - hence a racial connotation. I've used the term myself to describe a dituation where someone is deemed guilty without the facts. Mr. Sharpton should go back to his religious teachings and either judge not or turn the other cheek. Leave discipline to the employer.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tired of it all in L.A. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:44:30 GMT

It's nice to see there is some rational thought in today's world. While I whole-heartedly agree that Tilghman made a poor choice in words, her vilification is incredibly unwarranted.

Racism is a real problem throughout the world, yet every time an attack is perpetrated against a minority, that word is thrust onto the issue, often before all of the facts are known.

What I feel is important to note, is Tiger's response to the issue. The pair are friends and have a long-standing relationship. If the person to which the comment was directed has taken no offense, what business is it of the larger majority.

It is also nice to see someone challenge Sharpton's cingular claim over the use of the word. The definition of lynching is to execute without due process of law, particulary to hang, as done by a group of people.

Words used in the persecution of people does not mean those same people have exclusive rights in deciding how that word should be used. Sanitizing the vocabulary does not change the hearts and minds of those who choose to judge others, and Reverend Sharpton should know that better than most.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James Wineman — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:45:31 GMT

I feel that as a nation we are not giving the benefit of the doubt to people of other ethnic groups and we should be more forgiving until further evidence, behavior indicates otherwise. Likewise, for those that want to chastise, penalize other ethnic people for "off the cuff" remarks should be equally scrutinized for their agenda and chastised for their lack of fairness. Their influence should be minimized and the press should QUIT quoting them.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Phil Moore — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:46:02 GMT

I will have a hard time watching the golf cannel from now on. The problem is that we now can't speak. Al Sharpton nows to get a job and quit jummping on every comment that is made, Tiger is a great athlete and we all know that. Tiger's manager said it was a 'no issue' but we are still hearing about it. WHY?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Alonzo, East Hartford Connecticut — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:46:45 GMT

Is the author of this article serious? His idea of lynching and what it means is something he read in a Western novel? Blacks were being lynched a long time before that book was published. Maybe he should have done his homework on what lynching means in American History, better yet...African American History.
Tiger Woods is a Black man in a sport dominated by Whites. Tilghman is suggesting a group of White males, (a lynch mob) take Tiger out and lynch him? And the author doesn't see this as being a racist comment?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Greg T. Schubert Springfield Massachusetts — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:49:32 GMT

Why is this woman any different than Imus. The remark was stupid--unlikely to have been made in a racist vein, but some form of punishment seems appropriate. I'm not for "political correctness, but people need to be smarter--especially in their publicly aired remarks

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Home Opt, Manhattan, New York — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:50:10 GMT

An old, white fart doesn't like Al Sharpton. Wow, what a surprise. Almost as surprising at attempting to divert the focus of this issue from a supposed professional being stupid enough to use the term 'lynch' in reference to Tiger. It's no different than Fuzzy telling Tiger to have August make fried chicken for tiger. Fuzzy was friendly with Tiger too. It doesn't matter whether the person who made the comment is racist or not. The comments were insensitive and no one in their right mind would let something like that slip out of their mouth. The Golf Channel should fire her because she will be forever known as the broadcaster who made that comment, no matter what else she does in life.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Gretchen W. , Ann Arbor, MI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:50:21 GMT

Kelli's comment was offensive and inappropriate. If you knew anything about our nation's history, you would know that the word "lynching" conjures up images of African American men hanging from trees in the South. The word, whether you like it or not, is directly linked to racism in its worst form. Had Kelli made an anti-Semitic statement would you have been as forgiving? Let's pretend Tiger is Jewish. If Kelli had said: "The only way to stop him is to send him to the showers at Auschwitz! hahaha!" Such language has no place on the Golf Channel. Kelli will think twice before making such a statement in the future. And by the way, shame on you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ray O., Charlotte, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:54:08 GMT

Bravo. I don't always agree with you, but I do here. I don't believe Kelly Tilghman's comment was racist at all; however, I believe Al Sharpton's motivations are. And yes, there were lynchings of people of all races, and it's a vile, despicable legacy all Americans share.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Charles Cohen, Fair Lawn, NJ — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:54:58 GMT

Mike, You are wrong. This was totally insensitive and offensive. Lynching is not a joke..it's an outrageous crime against humanity which sadly was common in our great country in the 19th & the early 20th Century. This is not humor or joking around. This is a serious and sad comment that reflects ignorance and prejudice. I normally don't agree with Al Sharpton on anything but this time he is right on. This woman should be disciplined for her offensive remarks . We are all responsible for what we say..even in jest...especially public figures.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Craig Taylor, San Antonio, Texas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:55:37 GMT

Golf Channel execs, have you no shame?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Nigel Bennett, Edmonton, AB Canada — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:55:48 GMT

This is just insane, Al Sharpton seems to be the voice of indignation in the US and it is a voice that is going to cause more problems than it will fix. I believe what happened to African Americans was deplorable but lynching is definetly not specific to them. I was born and raised in the UK and lynching was totally asociated with rustlers. Sharpton needs to get off his high horse (no chance of that) and Tilghman should be reinstated asap

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Marty — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:56:15 GMT

OK - So if she would have said that we should "gas" a person of Jewish decent - that would be ok? I think not. Stop making excuses for CARELESS actions by someone who fully knew the meaning of that word.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

S Harrell — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:56:16 GMT

I think you have hit the nail on the head. She meant no harm, and no intent to harm Tiger Woods, that is clear by Tiger's own actions and his managers comments. This is a great example of how much power one man has to instill hate in many people. Mr Sharpton would be a person of great insight and wisdom...if he would only ptactice what he preaches. And yes, no job is safe with such a man as Mr. Sharpton having the power he thinks he has, and only because we buckle to him I might add. He can turn any simple sentence you might say into anything he wants it to sound like, and gets away with it. Again, because we buckle to his whims and let him. Shame on the golf Channel for being such a whimp, and not standing by one of the best employee's they have in a time of need, and thank you Tiger Woods, for being the smart man you are.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

George Washington DC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:56:26 GMT

Wow!!! You must be joking, you believe it only offended him. I like tiger am in a multi-ethnic marriage and my wife I both agree you have to stamp out "SLIPS" of the tongue. It has been a hot topic on our sports radio station here in Washington DC. Maybe because in you homogenous group it isn't offensive you can brush it aside. I was "Very Offended". Also let me be clear, I don't think she is a racist, but she should be punished because she has a pulpit which influences opinions. Unfortunately so do you!!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Steve Brown, Anchorage, AK — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:57:08 GMT

You call that a joke...are you kidding me! That was a call for someone to take tiger out by all means possible. With friends like her, who need enemies.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

David Sweet — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:57:11 GMT

Add yourself to the long, long list of clueless white men who just don't get it. Have you ever sat down with a black man and really tried to understand why it is not OK to use the term lynching in this way, EVER?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chris Bobby, New York, NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:57:34 GMT

Celizic, your article is terrific! I applaud and admire your courage to stop this nonsense crap venting by Al. First of all, I strongly feel that Kelly used a poor choice of words and it is simply unacceptable to use any improper words to offend ANY kind of races, period. However, I'm still bothered by Al and his ways of exploiting unfortunate situations in which he looks for publicity. When will Al ever stop accuse someone especially white people of saying something racist?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ernest, Baton Rouge, LA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:57:59 GMT

Celizic, you could not be more wrong!! In fact, you should lose your job for being too ignorant to the fact that in America, lynching is FIRST and FOREMOST associated with racism. I guess the kids who put up the nooses on the tree in Jena, LA meant them for "cattle rustlers and other ne’er-do-wells." Wow, where did you grow up Mars? No wonder it took decades for civil rights in this country. I am a Kelly Tilghman fan and I know that she is not racist, nor does she have any ill feelings towards Tiger. In fact, she practically worships him on the Golf Channel. With that said, she used a very poor choice of words that probably offended many in the audience so therefore, some sort of penalty should have been levied on her, despite the fact that she had no ill intent. It is you sir, not Sharpton who needs a history lesson on lynching and perhaps then you you would understand that her comment didn't just offend Sharpton, but perhap others who don't have the microphone that the media gives Sharpton to speak their minds. You're right, her crime was not being insensitive, it was being careless, and being careless on camera has its consequences...it always has. This is nothing new...for years "non-racist" commentators made many remarks about black athletes which were offensive and they were reprimanded regardless of their intent. You need the history lesson sir. Shame on you. Sharpton may be wrong for calling for her firing, but not for calling on the Golf Channel to be accountable. Shame on you for having nothing else better to do with your time and your tremendous platform than to rail against Al Sharpton.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

B.C., Yorba Linda, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:58:45 GMT

I agree with you 100% and I hope the Golf Channel doesn't succumb to his demand for firing. Al Sharpton is a fraud. I am tired of him getting air/face time every time an incident like this happens. That's all it is about for him I believe - to get his face on TV.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Nat Irvin, II — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:59:26 GMT

Mike,

You've been blinded by your disdain for Sharpton and your remarkable lack of understanding all of American history. I challenge you to go see the new film, " The Great Debaters" directed by Denzel Washington, and then write about the meaning of lynching. On this issue, you are beyond clueless my friend.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Todd, Nashville, TN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 02:59:56 GMT

Great article. Spot on.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Phil Hastings — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:01:17 GMT

Man, you hit the nail on the head! I agree wholeheartedly with you.

Kelly was obviously joking around when she made her comment and she knows Tiger well enough that she probably would have said it to his face and laughed as well and he would have laughed, too.

Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson have seemed to me to make a career of seeking out the "racists". It's tantamount to Joe McCarthy looking under every bush for a "commie"! And they always manage to get their pictures in the paper and suck up all the publicity around it. They should get a real life! Did the whole black population get together and vote these 2 the racist referees and I just missed it?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

ka indpls,in — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:02:01 GMT

celizic is just wrong on this. at first i thought live and get over it but when i saw the video, what was she thinking? and why that choice of words. she should serve her suspension and let this matter drop. hooray for sharpton.
no we will not see a colorblind society im my or your childrens lifetime.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

George Blinkhorn, San Carlos, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:03:49 GMT

Thank you for bringing some sanity to this non-incident. I will be the first to object to racial statements when I perceive them to be such. However this was clearly an innocent remark and Mr Sharptons over the top reaction is what should be condemmed. He is like the man who cried wolf once to often; when a serious incident arises people will ignore him. He is irrelevant. I grew up in Canada and I to associated lynching with cattle rustlers and horse thiefs. Unfortunatley it has an ugly double meaning. Thank God that Tiger is not only a great golfer he is also a great Man.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Willie Schumpert — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:07:05 GMT

Mr. Mike Celizic,
It is very apparent that there is no love lost between you and Mr. Al Sharpton. Let's keep the focus where it belongs, on a news anchor who used poor judgement and is being held accountable. Not on your opinion of Mr. Sharpton. As you pointed out above in your article "I realize the word has racial connotations and is offensive to many black Americans. That’s why I don’t use it in columns or stories. I also object to the suggestion, even in jest, that great players should be taken out by the competition." Make no mistake about it, whenever the suggestion of lynching is made and the subject of this lynching is "Black" it is "racial". Count me amongst the "many Black Americans" who were offended. I applaud the Golf Channel, even if the caved in to pressure from the media, public opinion or Mr. Sharpton. You got this one wrong.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Nikki, Syracuse NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:09:04 GMT

Interesting - are we becoming a LITTLE too easily offended? Al Sharpton pops up whenever there is a racial controversy - this I also find interesting.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kim in Dallas, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:09:19 GMT

Yes. White people have been lynched too. Even some innocent people who were in the wrong place at the wrong time. Thank you for sharing that with your readers. But, what does that have to do with Kelly Tilghman's suspension? She did get what she deserved as she is paid lots of money to speak intelligently to Tiger Woods' fans and golf fans in general. Let me remind you of something...Lynching was the method that killed lots of innocent black men in this country for no reason other than them being black. They didn't have to be a suspected criminal or a cattle rustler to be murdered. The threat of lynching was used to keep african-americans from voting, working, leaving our houses in general. So whether you learned about it early in life, or later in life doesn't stop that fact that we black people in this country have known about it all our lives. Your hate of Al Sharpton is blinding you from seeing that Ms.Tilghman proved she needs the suspensison so that she can spend time thinking about how to have witty banter with co-anchors and not embarass the golf channel.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Nick Panza — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:09:47 GMT

Mike - Disagree with you. The words are very offensive and totally inappropriate. Professional broadcasters need to be more intelligent and aware of American social history, and not just empty minded talking heads. During the suspension she should spend some time reading and reflecting.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

sal esposito, westfield, NJ — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:10:45 GMT

Unfortunately, the press created Sharpton as a racial watchdog by putting his words and face to any issue involving Americans of African decent. Now that he is using the voice the press has given him against you, you don't like it at all. It is fine if he bad mouths cops or companies or politians but, oh God, how dare he attack the sactamonious press and or media. You are getting what you deserve for creating an easy forum for people of no great intellegence to be heard simply because they attract viewers and readership by creating controversy.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Larry O'Shea, Petaluma, Ca — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:11:49 GMT

When you have nuts like Limbaugh and O'Reilly making purposeful insensitive remarks on a daily basis, The Golf Channel's reaction to Ms Tilghman was overkill. Her error was unintentional and deserved a reprimand. As far as Sharpton's involvement in calling for her firing, he should be tossed into the junk file. If there ever was a racist, he is the first on my list. Tilghman is a good commentator. The Golf Channel is a light weight for not doing the right thing and folding to biased pressure.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Phil, Clearwater, FL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:12:48 GMT

Way to go Mike! We have gone over the edge in political correctness. Whether intended or not, someone will be offended by whatever we say or don't say

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Gray Pearson, Monument , CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:13:22 GMT

This is one of the "BEST" comments on the subject of "racism" and how "some" people EXPLOIT only to "incite" the negative of candid - innocent comments!!!!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Average Joe — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:14:04 GMT

I coundn't agree more! I am beyond tired of the "Reverend" opening his trap every time there is a purported incident! Last time I checked, the people of faith were supposed to preach peace not attempt to disrupt it at every opportunity. Get a life AL!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James Dodson, Knoxville, TN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:14:14 GMT

Kelly Tlighman did not deserve to be suspended. She simply should have apologized for a poor choice of words. When Al Sharpton is our moral compass, we will never navigate the seas of racial equality to the promised land that leaders like MLK destined us to arrive at. Al Sharpton should be fired, if he had a job.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

one multi colored human — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:17:27 GMT

What a joke,Tiger should threaten to keep his face off their network,unless she's brought back instantly.If she had been my friend for 12 years,you bet your ass thats what I would do.Its not as if he doesn't have the pull.A game created by a bunch of white preppy dressed faggots.They all should be kissing Tiger's black ass.If it wasn't for him ratings for this crap would be at an alltime low,if they aren't already.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Terrence Wilson, Lakewood, OH — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:17:44 GMT

Really cracking jokes about "events that speaks to one of this country's most heinous, horrific, racist crimes in our entire history"
does not merit a suspension. What does then. The Lynching of people is the unspoken of "holocaust" of American history. You would not let it walk had she cracked this "joke" about the victims of Hitler and certainly should not in this instance. I hate Al Sharpton and this idea that he is the voice of black people but he has it right this time, this is one of those situations where a person's words are more hurtful than they realize and no amount of "well Tiger doesn't mind" will fix it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sree Tangella, Foster City, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:18:18 GMT

Shame on you for defending what she said. If it was really meant she would have been fired. SInce we are giving her the benefit of doubt it is a 2-week suspension. Growing up and going to school she would have heard of the work "Lynch" and its connotations. By defending it you are showing how racist you are.

How do you know that she had not just watched the movie "great debaters" and had that scene in her mind when she said it. Race relations in America are still tenuous. You cannot ignore it and saying stuff like that on a public channel is a disgrace. Hopefully she learned her lesson.

As for you, go work for Fox. This crap works there more than here.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

gary crawford,basking ridge,nj — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:19:04 GMT

Thank you for putting in words what so many of us have been feeling. Wouldn't it be nice if Tiger would come forward and state that the Rev Al does not speak for me,give this young lady back her job at once!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ronald Gaffney, Columbia, SC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:20:59 GMT

No. She was rightfully suspended (but should have been fired) for expressing a thought on national television that clearly resonated what was embedded in her psyche. And that thought was one that is indelibly linked with the bloodstained history of this nation. Acts of incredible malice and hatred against citizens of this land that happened to be rich in melanin.

Let me ask you this. If Tiger happened to be of Jewish heritage and Tilghman said that he should be gassed, would you have shrugged that off and said eh...no big deal?

I frankly don't give a flip about Sharpton. He is an opportunist. But this has nothing to do with him. It has to do with the poison that remains within this society.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jerry, Houston, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:21:52 GMT

It is puzzling to me...where do you come up with a comment like that? Had she seen a movie...read an article, something to have lynching on your mind? It does make you wonder about the person when someone says something like that.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jack White, Boston, MA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:23:26 GMT

I've chatted about this with friends and co-workers today, both in person and on message boards. Out of this group, every one who was African-Americans, man or woman, said he or she was offended and angry at the remark. It didn't seem to matter that there was, in all likelihood, no racist intent, but just a thoughtless choice of phrasing. At least that was my view. They were still p**ed off, and not because the good Rev. Al told them to be. They wanted Tilghman's head on a pike.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Roy Sullivan, San Francisco, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:23:59 GMT

I agree with you Mr. Celizic. Sharpton is stuck in the sixties. Mr. Al 'the Righteous' Sharpton owns 'specific' words in the English dictionary only he could amend with backwards thinking definition. He makes his money scanning every broadcast and newscast waiting for Non-African Americans to make a mistake with unintentional consequences. I am so tried of this joker. He gives all African-Americans a bad reputation. He should get out of the sixties and start moving forward to the new age and GROW UP!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jason, Washington, DC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:28:09 GMT

You're wrong. Stop shifting the focus from Tilghman to Sharpton. I don't agree with everything Sharpton says either, but what she said deserves punishment, which is only fair. Sharpton is growing continually irrelevant, I can't for the life of me understand why you think her punishment is unjust.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

H. Leigh Toney — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:29:38 GMT

I have to know, what is worthy of retribution in America anymore, in your opinion? To use a testing methodology, lynching is to African Americans what the gas chambers are to persons of Jewish descent...and if the the commentator, who is unworthy of mention by name, were to say that a Jewish golfer should have been sent to the gas chambers, what would you think to be a suitable response?

The is no such thing as an "innocent verbal slip" when it comes to the subject of lynching. In your way of thinking, there seems to be no parameters around what is unacceptable to say about African Americans. This latest example is a clear illustration of why racism still persists in this country; because you would seek to minimize and trivialize the horrific experiences that were visited upon African Americans in this country for more than 30 years. You would dare to suggest that people more commonly associate lynching with the Old West. Give me a break. Do you expect African Americans to accept any lame-brained excuse and rationalization you are able to devise. You and all others who share your opinions disgust me!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Bowman, Modesto, California — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:30:16 GMT

I could not agree more. In no way is the term "lynching" specific only to issues of racism. We are creating an evironment where even obvious mistakes in what a person says are being taken out of context, twisted, and used to try destroy the idividual for the sole purpose of promoting anothers misguided agenda. It continues to amaze me that Sharpton is given any credibility at all and further that a supposedly reputable news channel would give him a platform from which to spout his ignorance with no rebuttal. Tiger has correctly assessed the situation and dealt with it. He certainly does not need Sharpton to deal with his publicity issues. What would be nice is to see him correct Sharpton.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tyrone Brown Altus, Oklahoma — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:31:05 GMT

I would like to say that I totally agreee with you with regards to Al Sharpton. I am an African-American male but I would certainly like to know who made Al Sharpton the spokesperson or rosetta stone for blacks.
What exactly does he do besides go around trying to get people fired from their jobs. How is that helping the black community? America's prisons are full of black people, A black person is 95% more likely to be killed by another black person than any other race, and black gang members are growing by day. Al Sharpton is nowhere to be found. But as soon as someone says something on the air that he doesn't like, he shows his offensive face on tv. Why does this man get so much air time? Who really cares what he has to say?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

J. George — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:31:39 GMT

Has it gotten so bad that every word you say will be scrutinized for what it could mean vice what it does mean. Al Sharpton has done more to hurt race relations than Kelly Tilghman ever will with his war mongering attitude. Mr Sharpton needs to worry more about real problems instead of creating one when he's been out of the spotlight for too long.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jon Duluth MN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:33:28 GMT

Kelly Tilghman said something that may not have been appropriate, however there was no intent to slander anyone with her commentary. She apologized to Tiger and everyone else she could think of for saying something that was an attempt at humor during a broadcast. Nothing was meant by it except to say that Tiger Woods is the most formidable golfer of present time and others have a hard time winning when he is around. Shame on Al Sharpton for peeking his head out of his "I want attention" hole. Al, get a life. How can you look at yourself knowing that you are twisting what others say so you get yourself on TV. A little self serving isn't it?

Thanks, enough Al.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Hawke — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:34:57 GMT

Thank you for speaking the truth, Al Sharpton is nothing more than an unemployed opportunist.He and his statements are more racially motivated than anyone I have ever heard. This girl used a poor choice of words and thats it,no one else had a problem with this including Tiger .

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Happy Black — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:35:35 GMT

i have a problem with what she said because it reflects who she is.....I just wish more black people would use offensive language and racial slurs toward white people she's racist white trash.

On the other hand it serves tiger right he forgot that he is black, sometimes black people want to be accepted by white society so bad they end up like O.J. it's bad enough white men are losing their white women to blacks, the white men have resulted to molesting kids and ruining peoples lives. Tiger doesn't do much for the black community except wear their skin, but if you ask him he's white all over.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

M, Canada — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:36:08 GMT

I agree with the author of this article. Mr. Sharpton should really take a look at himself and his actions before he goes off on other people. He is no angel, but a big hypocryte.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

valery, orlando florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:39:45 GMT

i feel like if it was something said about the "holocaust" you would agree to firing her and so would everyone else. This word should not be desensitize because Al Sharpton is demanding them to account for this, but a women in a professional capacity should have more couth and class and not use such a hateful and hurtful word. It should not be part of her vocabulary. It was distatesful , its the golf channel , not comedy central, we should be professional. She should have been fired so that comedy central might hire her, im sure she'll fit in there.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

jessie inglett — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:40:17 GMT

Amen and may the so called reverend be suspended from making headlines. People in charge of news outlets should not be intimidated by such a biget. He is still pushing a 60's agenda. He only needs to look into a mirror to see the true racist.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

steve jones-Boston, MA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:40:50 GMT

Since When is this a referendum on AL SHARPTON.? This is so typical ofthe of the rationalization of racist remarks. Attack soneoen other than the perpetrator so the argument is bout them Shar;ton0 rather than the real offender (Kelly Tilghman). Sharpton is mentined twice as much as Tilghman.
You further capitulate to this msdeed by explaining that Tilghman reportedly gets along well with Woods"
So she's allowed tomake racist statements beciase she KNOWS HIM? What kind of nonsensical logic is that or perhaps you beleivethat since Woods is in the minority the Majority , KT, can make any type of statements they want, no matter how demeaning. It doesnot matter if Ms. Tingham insulted Mr. Woods as a friend, she insulted ME and every other black person, who not only have tobe reminded of this pock mark on our history but have to endure the endless misguided arguments from people like yourself, who believe that it was actuall Kelly who was wrongeed and that I should "get over it" just like the aftertmath of Imus remarks. And to end the story you Excoriate Al Sharpton;obviously you relish the fact thatA) you do not know any other black people who were bothered by this remark and B) are a poor journalist for not doing more research on others who felt wronged by this piece of shoody commetary, no matter what race they are. Shame on you

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Gavin Sargent — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:43:51 GMT

Right on!!!! This I'm sure is not politically correct for a white male to say, but Mr. Sharpton is a media whore and will jump on any cause ( just or not) to get his mug in front of the camera or his name in the paper. This man is making a maukery of a very serious subject and should be ashamed! I'm sure that he would interpret some aspect of this paragraph as rasist....but be damned, I'm stepping out on the limb!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Samara McCullough, Lakewood, OH — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:44:49 GMT

So if my friend insults me and in public and in such a way that an entire race of people are offended he or she should not be held accountable because she is my friend and said she was sorry. Accountability for a reporter means that he or she should be aware of every word they speak and weigh how those words will affect the public. The word "lynch" is so powerful because so many blacks suffered here in this country by being lynched. You cannot divorce it from its historical meaning. You cannot be so insensitive to believe that that word doesn't affect black Americans. It doesn't matter that Tiger Woods isn't offended- I am. My family is. It makes all of us remember a time when it was okay to grab black men from their homes, off the street, from the jails, and without due process hang them, and diembowl them and leave their mutilated bodies swing from trees. And there was no accountability. Rev. Sharpton does not make up racism. Racism exists- and that statement is one of the mose hateful and racist statements I've ever heard a public figure utter. The sad thing is that you and others seem to feel that insulting blacks and using racist epitaths should now be okay and that you are not accountable for at the very least not advocating racist and hurtful statements. Would your opinion be different if a Christian reporter advocated putting a Jewish atlete in a gas chamber? You are wrong and you are helping racist people feel it is okay to make racist statments without any accountability.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jamaal Adam — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:46:46 GMT

I too would forgive her. With an asterisk. Lyching has a totally different meaning in US dictionary than elsewhere in English-speaking world. To lynch is to "kill without legal sanction." That is what African Americans had to endure for hundreds of centuries. The word touches a raw nerve in African American psyche. So, make no light of it Mr. Celzic. I dont have to elaborate more on that. I believe it was a Freudian Slip that got her to utter it. I also believe she is very familiar with the word and its application to describe despicable historical acts of violence committed on African Americans for a long time. She knew it. I don't think she thought about it when she said it. But it came out of her inexplicably. And it touched a raw nerve of those affected by it, including this writer. But it is a forgivable offense for a Freudian Slip. Finally, I think Mike Celzic should stop being an appologist for rogue media and sports personalities. I am happy with the current level of intolerance displayed by media to rid itself of undesirable personalities that make derogatory observations that fan racial, misogynist, sexiststereotypes, or utter offensive language with impunity. There is no place for such hacks. Allowing them a public platform to act irresponsible and offensive only promotes intolerance among their audience.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dale Zink, Denver, CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:47:03 GMT

Well done! I could not agree with you more. The comment that strikes me most is that Al Sharpton guilty of racism. No one in America promotes racism more than Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson. What she said was not the best choice of words. Tiger Woods' agent was quoted as saying it was a non-issue. Tiger seemed to be OK with it as well. Why should she suffer if she apologized honestly? (unlike Imus in my opinion) Why do we take ourselves so seriously? Does every incident have to have someone to blame? Lighten up people. The only real issues are the ones done with intent.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Insulted in Charlotte — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:48:33 GMT

You are wrong and so is she. How about the next time Maria Sharapova or Michele Wie or D. Patrick dominates in their respective sports (good luck on the latter 2) and someone suggests they gang up on her or rather take her outback and rape her! It is offensive and you are silly for downplaying it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Moxon — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:48:33 GMT

Thank you. I saw the show and remark was not meant in any way to offend. Al Sharpton is more hateful and racist than anyone I know and certainly does his race no good. Most blacks I know are not even close to being this sensitive.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ted, U.S. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:49:07 GMT

She absolutely should not be suspended. It's just like if a man...Al Sharpton for example, suggested that players on the LPGA rape Annika Sorenstam or Lorena Ochoa to slow them down. See...just a harmless slip of the tongue and 'those people' just need to get over it.

And come on...since when is 'lynching' strictly a racially-tinged word? I'm sure Jose Maria Olazabal makes similar suggestions about Nick O'Hern all the time.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

ed, orlando, fl — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:49:07 GMT

tiger woods is black? I just think of him as greatest golfer who ever played. there was no malice in remark.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tony A — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:51:53 GMT

In these times of political correctness and considering the job of this anchor with its inherent responsibility, Ms. Tilghman should have known better and if she didn't now she does.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

C Nesbary, Southfield, MI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:52:10 GMT

I disagree that Ms. Tilghman's comments "only offended Al Sharpton." As a broadcaster, she should know better than to make such a racist, provocative statement. I think she should have been fired.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Karibi Fubara, Brooklyn, New York — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:53:28 GMT

I am a black man who doesn't care at all for Al Sharpton in the least bit (he doesn't speak for us all), but I was greatly offended by Miss Tilghman's choice of words! And commend The Golf Channel for not firing her but simply suspending her like any reasonable corporation would do for breaking company policy.
As for you Mr. Celizic, I find all your points on Rev. Sharpton pretty valid, but your rationale on the actually word "lynching" not being an issue is pretty shallow at best! Lynching in itself may not be racially charged (but it still denotes killing someone, and that could be offensive to fans of Tiger of any color), but put that in reference to a black man, i.e. Tiger Woods, and you have a racially irresponsible and offensive statement. Just in the same way that "gassing" may not be racially charged, but put that in reference to a Jew and you have a very offensive statement. Your ultimate defense of Ms.Tilghman may be ignorance, like what you claim to have had for all those years not knowing it's racial roots (i.e. Willie Lynch), well such ignorance maybe okay for you and I, but it has not place on TV when it's your job and the #1 golfer in the world and possibly the greatest golfer ever is black! So bravo to The Golf Channel for giving her a two week period to learn a bit more, I hope she uses it wisely.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Markeis LeShawn Omaha, NE — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:53:32 GMT

I am a 23 year old black man from Omaha, NE. I've seen racism firsthand. I originally thought what Ms. Tilghman was a racist comments, until I found all the facts. After listening to what Ms. Tilghman stated I did not find Ms. Tilghman comments to be offensive. I do believe it was a joke gone bad, but not racist. Let me point this out, Mr. Sharpton is a hypocrite. I do not support Mr. Sharpton because I find that he only bring things up if it will get him on T.V. I put Mr. Sharpton in the same category with State Senator Ernie Chambers. Anything that can get them on T.V. they will make a big deal about it. Mr. Sharpton went on T.V. to boycott hip hop companies after the Don Imus incident, but goes on the BET Hip Hop Awards later that year and says that James Brown would be proud of what our hip hop artist have done. Mr. Sharpton should have realized that BET is a main reason that the offensive hip hop is out there. BET are the one showing the women with no clothes and rapper selling drugs and living the good life. It seems that Mr. Sharpton was sleeping with his supposedly enemy.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

patrick, salt lake city utah — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:54:28 GMT

Well put Mike. We all need to stop being offended so easily. And most of all, we all need to stop listening to people like Al Sharpton like he is the ultimate truth. Lets just all try and love each other even though we all have faults

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Greg Smith — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:54:31 GMT

This comment was not general in nature -- "kill all lawyers". It was specific to an individual and most inappropriate and offensive.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dale Zink, Denver, CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:55:24 GMT

Well Done! I could not agree more with you. This comment was not made with intent. Why do we take ourselves so seriously? Tiger does not, nor his agent. Al Sharpton is the biggest racist in America. Her comment was not made with malice. She should not be a n example if the person she made a comment about is not offended. Lynching, to me, does not have racist overtones. I grew up in the late 70s and 80s and there were no lynchings of African Americans.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike, Canton MI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:57:19 GMT

Well spoken Mike Celizic. Thank you. Al Sharpton says more things to offend than 100 Kelly Tilghmans. I appreciate your bravery to publically take a stance against Sharpton, and to reprimand the Golf Channel for their actions against Tilghman.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Slave Descendant — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:59:05 GMT

why did she use the word then:" lynch him in back alley.".? I wouldn't worry about Al Sharpton because he definitely has some issues.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Corlis, The Woodlands, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:00:02 GMT

I see above that "all comments must be approved..." I'm sure this one will not be, but here it is anyway, and I'll start with a question or two.
Did anyone (Sharpton; Golf Channel; Tiger) ask this person what she meant by her comment? I will answer. NO! Why? Because everyone that heard it knows that there was absolutely nothing ill-conceived or ill-mannered intended. I have reviewed the definition of the word 'lynch' (oh sorry, I typed the word so I guess I'll be suspended from this comment section; please...); nowhere do I see that this word is declared any kind of racial conotation.
However, the following is the definition of 'racist'; "a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race."

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Alan, Vacaville, California — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:02:20 GMT

I'm with you! Al Sharpton continually does and says things that are more devisive than anything that has ever aired on the Golf Channel! MLK urged us all to judge each other by the content of our character, not the color of one's skin. Yet here is Al Sharpton again claiming another word in the english language as his own, reminding everyone of the difference in skin tone. I'm sure he was immediately offended as he watched the second round of the tournament on Friday. What?! Al doesn't watch the Golf Channel? Well I have for years and Kelly Tilghman is about as honorable as they come. The PGA of America has donated over $1 billion dollars to charities, not limiting the benefits based on race. Tiger Woods has built a foundation and a Learmning Center for kids of all colors and abilities. Al Sharpton needs to get a real job and quit trying to divide Americans based on words he has determined are racist. That is about as racist as you can get!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Anonymous, NW Indiana — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:04:17 GMT

I couldn't agree more!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Craig Clark — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:04:24 GMT

I couldn't agree more. Kelly Tilghman was simply using a phrase that's very much in the American vernacular. It was obviously said in jest, and was, in fact, a compliment to Tiger Woods, not a derogatory remark.
There's no doubt that the language of most Americans needed the dose of "Political Correctness" that was administered in the 1980's and 1990's. But when it is over-applied, as it was in this case, the cure becomes worse than the disease. Ms. Tilghman was not politically incorrect in her remarks, but The Golf Channel was certainly incorrect in its reaction to them. It was obviously reacting to the political "threat" posed by Reverend Sharpton, and chose to avoid negative publicity rather than support one of it's employees.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Alpharetta, Georgia — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:04:48 GMT

Shame on YOU for your thought processes to even say that lynching is an "innocent verbal slippage". Diarrhea is slippage, Burping is slippage, lynching is a murderous word. NOTHING innocent about murder. Al Sharpton is NOT the only one offended.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bill Foster — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:05:16 GMT

Al Sharpton would grab any oppurtunity to get his mug on TV he is a disgrace! What a country we now live in where the slightest slip of the tongue can be so blown out of purportion by people that serve no other real purpose than to seek this controversy out because it is most certainly their livelyhood! Hey Al are you kidding me why don't you get a real job and stop chasing or inventing racism for a living!?! I remember Twana Brawly do you!?!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

St Louis, MO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:05:42 GMT

Bravo. Well said.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tony, Virginia Beach — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:06:04 GMT

Mike and to all White folks:

This country or the White folks of this country has a past history to reconcile with Slavery, Jim Crow and present day discrimination practices of all forms of Black folks. For you and other White folks (including Tiger-apology accepting) to assuage Tilghman's foot-in-mouth "slip of tongue" with the backdrop and history of Black men and boys being lynched is White folks denial of the past sins.

Conveniently, you/others want to apply the "just get over it" and plausible deniability tactic. Regardless of Tilghman's feelings of Black people now, she, like you and all other White folks should know the word "Lynch" or "Lynching" will invoke ill-memories of Black people in any context. Tilghman sealed her own professional fate - she will always be seen in a different light, at least publicly. Tilghman deserves an opprobrium, and if, that means being fired, then so be it. She cannot take it back now- it's in the universe of the public sphere, which should serve notice to all White folks (at least, broadcasters/public figures), using historical intense racial language/tone or photo in any context, will invoke Black's ire and rebuke, which we will seek and demand redress. May we all learn!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Doe — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:07:11 GMT

You should be called Closed(minded) Mike! You are a racist in cloak, and a sorry excuse for a human being. Shame on the employer that hires you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Katie Johns — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:08:07 GMT

The point is, the comment would never have been made about any white individuals and this is the fact you seem to ignore. Maybe her suspension will curtail some other racist remarks from the other innocents out there...Here you are on your soap box railing about Sharpton, find something else.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dana DeMoulin — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:08:42 GMT

The problem with your logic is that you don’t know the difference between lynching and hanging. Lynching is the illegal execution of an accused person by a mob. Hanging is the legal execution of a person convicted and condemned by a state or federal court.

Horse and cattle rustlers were hanged for their crimes after being convicted in a court. While there were certainly those who were hanged by a rancher and his hands, this is a far cry from the lynchings committed in the Deep South. Your memory of the Westerns is either false or convenient. With the exception of the Ox-Bow Incident most references in Westerns are to the legal hanging of rustlers.

Between 1882 and 1930 there were 2805 documented victims of lynching in 2,018 separate incidents. Of those lynched 2462 were African American of which 2314 were at the hands of white lynch mobs. The lynchings included men, women and children and averaged one per week. The catalyst for the lynchings ranged from scaring a white woman to murder. None were with the benefit of a legal trial.

Source: Stewart E. Tolnay and E.M. Beck, A Festival of Violence: An Analysis of Southern Lynchings, 1882-1930.

I am a 55 year old white man and I have known that lynching was a form of racism most of my life. I was named after Dana Andrews who played Donald Martin one of the three men lynched in the movie of the Ox-Bow Incident. There is no gray area here lynching is purley a racist term.

Kelly Tilghman’s words were racist and it is certain that she would not have used the term “lynch” had she been speaking about a dominating white golfer. Racism is so deeply rooted in our vernacular that we use it subconsciously in appropriate context. It is only when brought to our attention that we recognize it for what it truly is, racism.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Keith — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:10:09 GMT

We are about to elect a black man as President of the United States. Perhaps if Sharpton can keep stirring the hatred pot that dream can come to an end. Way to go AL.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michelle, Fayetteville, Arkansas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:10:17 GMT

Finally...words of reason in an out of control, overly-sensitive, politically correct world.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tim, South Bend, IN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:10:36 GMT

She deserved to be suspended. Its sad that Mr. Celizic wants to wipe this under the rug. Shame on him.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ward, Hubbardston, MA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:10:49 GMT

Finally someone other than the so-called 'right-wing' radio talk show hosts recognizing Al Shapton for what he is. Sharpton needs to get a real job that brings credit to what he wants to happen. His looking for racism in every statement that comes out of people's mouth is getting ridiculous and pretty everyone will realize that he is just crying 'wolf'! and not really finding any racism, just opinions.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Willie, New Bedford, MA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:11:25 GMT

Lynch him? Who uses that word in their everyday vocabulary? Her use of that word should have resulted in disciplinary action and cause a permanent "bad mark" on her employee record (as if broadcasters should even be held to any sort of standards like regular employees).

And shame on her fellow broadcaster for even promoting negative comments in the first place. He should have gotten the same punishment as the woman.

The word and the image it creates is wrong in any context. The woman may as well have said crucify.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Raba, San Antonio, Texas 78261 — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:12:12 GMT

I agree that Sharpton really over reacted on this thing. It is almost as if his very existence depends on him springing upon potential racism like it was a grass fire. Only malicious intent should be punished. What Tilghman did was nothing more than an honest and innocent mistake.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bernard Cummings, Valley Cottage, N.Y. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:13:37 GMT

Mr. Celzic called it correct. I would also like ask why he is called "Reverend"? There is nothing about him to revere. He is a racial arsonist and huckster. When is the media going to quit legitimizing him? He is an insult to my intelligence. When he calls someone a racist, it is like the pot calling the kettle black. Oops, is that a racist statement?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

p donoho salem il — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:14:35 GMT

i back you 100%

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim Frego, Grants Pass, OR Capt. US Army (ret.) — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:15:37 GMT

If justice for Imus was being FIRED and humiliated then
Kelly Tilghman should be FIRED and NEVER allowed back on air.
Her "Lynch the Black Guy" comment is MUCH WORSE than the Imus "NAPPY HEADED HOES" comment.
Let the crosses burn on her lawn.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

R.M., Denver, Colorado — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:16:32 GMT

This is awesome.
Also...racism involves differentiating one race from another. That's exactly what the media is doing. If we were a society totally devoid of racism, these comments would be overlooked. I know I would never have heard about this if the media hadn't made it into a huge issue - it was on the golf channel after all.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim W., Temecula, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:17:52 GMT

You're absolutely right, Mike ! This hypersensivity by Sharpton, the genuiness of which I question, is totally uncalled for. As everyone with an ounce of sense would say, no offense or racial slur was intended by Kelly. Sharpton and his cronies are opportunists, making hay out of this country's momentary love affair with political correctness. I said as much in an e-mail to the Golf Channel folks last night.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ric Moser — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:19:59 GMT

I couldn't agree more. I am a bleeding heart liberal and have been active in civil rights for decades. Sharpton is over the edge on this one. Lynching, in context, is racially charged. Out of context it is merely descriptive. The good Rev. Sharpton needs to worry about real issues instead of getting face time on the networks.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jack Ahlen Ft Madison, IA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:22:05 GMT

I agree with you 100%, Al Sharpton is nothing but a trouble maker, trying to stir up trouble. In my book, he's the racist, he tries to keep things stirred up, just leave it alone Sharpton, no body wants to listen to your thoughts.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michael — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:22:36 GMT

lynch
–verb (used with object) to put to death, esp. by hanging, by mob action and without legal authority.

Source: Dictionary.com

I do not see anywhere in the definition the words "black person" or anything that indicates as such.

If you could pass the word on to Mr. Sharpton. I hope he is lynched as well, not because he is black, but because he continuously abuses our great country and laws to make a name for himself, regardless that it is a laughable name.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

I love the wire! — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:23:04 GMT

What is this guy talking about? He didn't know what "lynching" stood for in a racial sense? Give me a break! You shouldn't comment on what you don't understand. When do we punish people for making racially insensitive remaks? Probably never if it were up to you. Don't cloud what she said by going on and on about Sharpton. Nobody cares about Sharpton. She shouldn't have been in the chair she was in if she didn't understand the meaning of "lynching" and neither do you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tennessee — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:24:09 GMT

It's about time someone in public stood up to Sharpton. Good for you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Leland Nelson, Clinton, SC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:25:47 GMT

Excellent article. It is nice to read someone who has some common sense.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Paul Jacobs, Jupiter, FL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:29:53 GMT

Kudos to Mike Celizic for getting it absolutely right.
It is a sad commentary on our society when every slip of the tongue is automatically considered vengeful. Kelly and Tiger are friends and know it was a simple joke. Shame on Al Sharpton for once again throwing himself in the limelight as Mr. Righteous. Look in the mirror, Reverend, and you may be shocked at what you see.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

H Stowell — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:30:12 GMT

Hey Sharpton, just go away! You've got some nerve judging others having never apolgized for your Tiwana Brawley sham. No reputable news organization would even give you a pulpit but of course CNN, the Communist News Network did.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Floyd Blackman, Chesapeake VA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:30:24 GMT

The 2 week supension will give Ms. Tilghman time to reflect how she really feels in her heart, for oft times we show outwardly what is inside. Journalist, commentators, etc., are to be held to a high standard. The stage can be a dangerous place, or it can be a learning, growing place. What is said/fed to the audience should be nourishing and healthy.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

jamessudesky tokyo japan — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:30:38 GMT

Hi Mike,
Being out of the country, I didn't see the program. But I have to say, that I reallyl hate the announcers having such a jolly ol time at the expense of the worlds No. 1 athlete, who almost singlehandedly has raised the revenues, what is it 40 times what it was in Jack Nicklaus era? How many of us wouldn't give our all to be able to announce on the golf channel? I watched the year-end programs when I was in US and I couldn't help think the announcers (Faldo and Kelly) somehow too much self-appeal rather than iinsightful analysis. I guess I'm old fashioned ,and loved the understatement of Ken Venturi, and then the straight talk about golf of Johnny Miller. Faldo and Kelly seem just to be just too light hearted and loose. If that's what Golf Channel wants, and it seems they do, then I often just turn the sound off and watch the match. I wonder if there are any others who share this opinion?
Thanks.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chip, Hayward, WI — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:30:41 GMT

Hey Mike,
You, me, and Ron Paul all agree!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Randall Price, Hamilton, MT — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:31:56 GMT

It's about time someone actually said it! The hypersensitivity of this society regarding race is disgusting! People need to quit getting on the bandwagon and wake up to reality.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Greg Murray, Mount Clemens, Michigan — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:32:07 GMT

Typical apoligistic babble!

Shame on you for placing yourself in a position to evaluate the pain of millions of people who less than a century ago actually could have been lynched.

Shame on you for trivializing an experience you can only imagine but which would never befall you.

If this woman had made a comment recommending burning Woods like a hot dog at Auschwitz, you would call for her head and you know it.

You can't feel this because you would never live it.

What you don't know you could never write, but you can show your ignorance of history, and you've done a good job of.

You want to make this about Sharpton, which relieves you of any responsibility to acknowledge the pain she has caused Black America...making it abut Sharpton numbs you to the real pain felt by people you know nothing about, and don't punt to "some of my friends are.....", which I expect you'll have an impulse to respond with.

Shame on you

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sam Miller Hartford CT — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:35:07 GMT

Dear Mike: your comments on lynching and it being part of american history is true, but the people that your referring to were criminals. African Americans if you know your history were lynched for just being black. Hundreds of thousands of African American were tortured and lynched just for looking at a white woman. Racism is still very raw in America fragile, that shouldn't be taken as "just a slip of the tongue". There is a percentage of Americans who believe or would like to believe that slavery in America never existed. The only way for America to move forward is to first acknowledge apolegize and work together on resolution. To say just get over it, slips of the tongue are acceptable only deepens wounds that many African Americans still hold. Addressing and confronting the small stuff does help the overall big picture.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

edward , st.louis.mo. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:36:04 GMT

i couldn't agree more.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

vested, san diego, california — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:40:35 GMT

Hmm,

Open Mike, you win. You get a response from me and obviously, as a person, not of color, you have no clue. Let me remind you of something that is still prevalent in our society today. The Jewish Community, which was subjected to some of the most unspeakable crimes against humanity our country has known, still makes it a point to "hunt" down those individuals who murdered (or sanctioned) the killing of Jews during Hitler's regime. The message is clear--they will not rest until, all of those who hated them simply because of their way of thinking, their way of living, and their faith, are brought to justice. In fact, this legal right of historical "correction" has been endorsed by the international courts. Certainly, restitution for crimes against humanity is not unheard of. I applaud my Jewish brother and sister for this continued fight. With that said, Mr. Sharpton (whom I don't always agree with) is right on point. The Black community still has an obligation to fight and send the message to all Americans (especially those of the new generation) that racial insensitivity cannot be tolerated. It's simple, I think, teach our children about the past so that they may not make the obvious mistakes that you (and possibly Ms. Tilghman) seem to forget, but hopefully not endorse. Shame on you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rod Poissant, Irvine, Ca. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:43:56 GMT

For every inch of progress that has been made over the years along comes "Big Al", and others like him, and sets us back tenfold.
MSgt Rod Poissant[ret]
United States Marine Corps

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sylvester Brooks, Cleveland, Ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:49:25 GMT

You sir, are an idiot. And if Tiger Woods thinks it is a non-issue, he needs to think again, long and hard. I don't think Buick or GM, who pays Woods millions, think it is a non issue. Mike "last name unknown"..Ms.Tilghman, Mr. Woods, I would urge you to read a book by James Allen, "Without Sancuary:Lynching Photography In America." Then tell me it is a non-issue. It is an ISSUE that is a curse on our house, and should never be MARGINALIZED. .... Finally, Mike.. "last name unknown" .... I must tell you, since you do indeed sound clueless; Mr. Sharpton has has nothing to do with my opinions, ideas or points of view. And, certainly, neither do you. We are not clones. Understand!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Albert Martinez, Pueblo, CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:53:14 GMT

While I dont feel that everyone has the same view on the situation or the same beliefs, this article does beg the question....why arent the people directly involved the ones saying what was offensive?? If Tiger Woods is not that upset by it and it was directed at him, who has the right to make it thier fight? I have seen racism and I have felt it, but I dont know that I have ever been a party to making certain words in the english language the embodiment of ignorance. Does this mean that only certain people can use certain words now?? I feel there are better things to expend Rev. Sharpton's efforts on.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John Doe — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 04:56:43 GMT

Well said, Mike.
The only thing you are missing here is you are NOT black, so you really cannot feel the sensitivities on this issue.

Lynching - an execution without trial, is "specifically" used towards BLACK people. The woman is not a racist, but sure enough she is a subconscious supremacist, or "stereotypist".

Assume you are a jew, and you perform well at work; may I jokingly say the only way I can surpass you is to make you work in a gas chamber?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 05:00:01 GMT

Hopefully this teachs us something-STOP mentioning his name every other word that comes out of your mouths-talk about some of the other good players out there-there are quite a few that would like a bit more media attention I'm sure. You people give him the lead when he really does'nt have it-you talk about him when he's not even in contention-and now this. Al has nothing else todo but look for flaws in others

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Charles R Schafer, Colorado Springs, CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 05:03:27 GMT

This so is ridicilous. If Sharpton had a job he wouldn't have time to monitor all the jokes that are told by white folks in the country. I guess Kelly should have said "Take Tiger out to the alley and kick his ass". What the hell is this Country coming to when it can't take a joke? Hey SHARPTON, IT WAS A JOKE!!!!!!!! It had nothing to do with race. If you don't know, "TIGER IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE WORLD" and he knew it was a joke. Take a break.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

April, Queens Village, N.Y. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 05:22:33 GMT

You obviously don't get it, maybe because you are of the same mindset as the anchorwoman who uttered the phrase in the first place. Perhaps you do not understand because it was not your ancestors who were lynched. Both of you need ethnic sensitivity training.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Greg, Minneapolis, MN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 05:39:11 GMT

When I saw the comment from Tilghman I asked myself if I had to make a similar comment (jokingly) in her position in a golf telecast instead of responding to Faldo by saying “Lynch him in a back alley" I would've said "beat him up in a back alley". Again, this is said in jest. Just riffing off what Faldo was saying. And I think most rational people understood that Kelly meant this. But as usual Sharpton doesn't want to evaluate the situation or the people involved at all to determine their actual intent. But just uses these situations to launch his own personal platform. The man sets race relations back everytime he does this sort of thing. What he needs to know is that some States in this Country have the word Lynch in their laws!

From the South Carolina Code of Laws:
ARTICLE 3
SECTION 16-3-220. Lynching in the second degree.

Any act of violence inflicted by a mob upon the body of another person and from which death does not result shall constitute the crime of lynching in the second degree and shall be a felony.

Huh, sounds a lot like people beating someone up in a back alley. Oh, and by the way Al, guess where Kelly Tilghman is from. That's correct, South Carolina.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ronald E. Cage Fontana Ca. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 06:00:53 GMT

Al Sharpton has once again proved that the english language is bad for america. We cannot simply remove words that offend or have offended to pacify over sensitive media-seekers. Anyone who heard Kelly and Nick offering a clever and funny way to beat Tiger Woods, know it was not meant as a "Southern Lynching" or a hateful comment, it was just plain ole fun. Yes, it was a poorly choosen word, and that all it was. Kelly has shown nothing but respect for the entire golfing, world
especially Tiger Woods. A supension of any kind is insane. It's ludicrous. It's egregious. It's preposterous. Reinstate Kelly now! with dispatch and f you can, quicker than that.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Francis A. O'Brien — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 07:01:54 GMT

Celizic, you've reached a new low... I doubt you'd be as forgiving about a comment like, "the only way to deal with Romanowski is to throw him in a gas chamber." After having read your previous work, I can only come to the conclusion that you are the writer version of an ambulance chaser.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Name Withheld — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 07:55:03 GMT

It's not about Tilghman's level of hate or your level of ignorance. It is about the harm Tilghman caused to most of the black people who heard her inane comment. You may not understand it but it is real. Any broadcaster who is prone to this type of honest "mistake" shouldn't be on the air in the first place. There are plenty of people (women included) ready and qualified to replace her. Finally, the Golf Channel is capable of making it's own personnel decisions, independent of Al Sharpton's opinions. If they felt that Tilghman deserved to be suspended, it was because of the harm she perpetrated on the African-Americans who watch their network. Tiger Woods isn't the only one of us who plays golf and/or watches it on TV.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Qadim — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 08:03:25 GMT

Shame on you for not realizing her statement was racist and offensive to many African-Americans! She should have been suspended!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

George, California — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 08:48:43 GMT

Kelly Tilghman’s words were inappropriate. However if Kelly Tilghman is fired, then there should be a boycott on all minority-owned businesses for a period of ten days from the date she is fired. Also included in the boycott: any movies having minorities as leading actors and any TV shows hosted by minorities or having minorities as the leading characters. Excluded from the boycott: Tiger Woods, since he’s apparently put this behind him, and any other minority movie actor, TV host or actor, or business owner who specifically states that Kelly Tilghman should not be fired. This boycott should be done across the country by individuals, without any organization overseeing it. After the ten days, it should be business as usual, as much as that is possible.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Robert V., Montreal, Canada — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 10:13:38 GMT

It's about time somebody, black or white, exposes Sharpton for what he really is... a bigotted, egotistical, self agrrandizing bag of wind who likes nothing more than to hear himself speak at the expense of others.
Kudos to you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ali Rashada Detroit, Mich — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 10:23:04 GMT

I wonder, if someone had asked, what could we do to show Michelle Wie that she doesn't belong playing with men? Would it have been just as insignificant if a someone said "take her out behind the clubhouse and gangrape her. That would show her who's the man."
Both acts are illegal, immoral, and cowardly. Is it okay to joke about painful events that are still occuring in this day and time? Maybe, but it will most likely hurt and offend those still enduring the pain, while those who have never felt it, will probably, ignorantly minimize it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Joseph C — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 10:35:50 GMT

It is a shame when we have become so overly politically correct that even innocent comments will get you fired/suspended. One cannot not make even the slighest joke, remark etc that "might" offend someone without fear of reprocussion. So much for free speech. We might as well all stay home, turn off the TV, burn the books and just sleep all day.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kenny Wright, HotSprings,Ark. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 11:16:52 GMT

I couldnt have said it better.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

mick — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 11:58:03 GMT

The word lynching has connections SPECIFICALLY with a history of premeditated violence against african americans. In lynching ,randomly selected african americans were murdered slowly , painfully and horrifically, let me say that agin in case you don't understand,MURDERED SLOWLY, PAINFULLY and HORRIFICALLY by huge mobs of whites specifically in order to oppress the black community. Anyone who would use that word whether inadvertently or not , in connection with a golfer of african-american heritage is a racist full stop. Tilghman just was'nt bright enough to suppress her racist impulses effectively. Tiger would never say if he was offended or not. As a multimillionaire sportsman he' s clever enough to play by the rules. Remain bland , never say anything controversial or to court controversy ,even when someone makes disguisting comments about you, and keep those huge sporting endorsements flooding in. And even if Tiger does'nt complain thats not the point. All people disgusted by this remark have the right to complain, and demand action against Tilghman ,otherwise its like saying only holoocaust victims have the right to be offended if someone makes remarks making fun of the holocaust. Maybe defenders of Tilghman could speak to people descended from people lynched or read some history books describing lynching incidents before giving their opinions ?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rick Barr, Columbus OH — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 13:16:27 GMT

I totally agree with what you said in this article. It is an outrage that Tilghman was suspended over this. As you mentioned, the term "lynching" does not always have to do with race. It was clearly a light-hearted comment made during some down-time.

I watched a little bit of the Sony Open last night, and early in the broadcast, someone was interviewing Tadd Fujikawa an said, "Knowing you, there'll be a big rice bowl waiting for you when you get home." Wow. Tadd laughed about it, but it occured to me that he had just been stereotyped. Was this not offensive to anyone (for the record, I certainly do not believe it should have been)? Aren't we going to hear cries from activists calling for more firings? How careful do we have to be these days?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

RBW, Atlanta, GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 13:50:04 GMT

I was discussing this issue with some friends and the question arose "What would have happened if a male commentator made the lynching comment? What kind of suspension would he receive? I didn't have an answer for it, but others felt he would have been fired. Personally, I don't think two weeks is all that harsh nor do I think it was deserved.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Gerald Cardoza, Mattapoisett, MA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:07:29 GMT

I am rather surprised that a writer of your stature would be totally insensitive to the lynching remark. Comparing wild west hangings to lynching is apples and oranges.Try using the words gas him when discussing a Jewish person and see the response.The airways are no place to make jokes that may hurt groups regardless of the intent. I for one am offended..

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Marsha Simms, Indianapolis, Indiana — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:09:04 GMT

You really can't understand how offensive her statement was unless you are black and grew up knowing that not that long ago your relatives had witnessed such things as lynching etc..etc... Don't act like Al Sharpton was the only one offened! Yes she mad a mistake simple to some but hurtful to others.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Garry Trollinger - Graham, N.C, — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:11:53 GMT

Would Al Sharpton of said anything about racism if that had been said about any other player on tour?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jay — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:14:36 GMT

You're dumb. Her comments were WAY worse then Imus. Bottom line, she wasn't fired because she's a woman and Imus is a man. If he makes that comment, man... talk about firestorm.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Brian, Erie, PA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:24:58 GMT

Mike,
In your quote of Sharpton, he doesn't specifically call her a racist, just that she said something racist. Sharpton may be guilty of racism, but I doubt if he accounts for more capacity to hate than most of us have. I think most of us are too proud to admit how low we can actually go. To wit I've never had to teach my child to lie, but have had to teach him to tell the truth even when there may be hard consequences - take from this that people are not basically good, but need to be trained to do good.

But I'm with you on the general disappointment of the whole scenario. Sharpton is crying "foul" when no harm was meant and no harm was taken by the individuals involved. But my biggest complaint with Sharpton and his like is that all they ever seem to do is complain that life isn't fair. Life isn't fair (a sword that cuts both ways). But that's what helps to separate the great people from the rest: great people don't complain about their situation, they overcome it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rev. Sharpton Supporter, Atlanta, GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:35:45 GMT

Rev. Al Sharpton is right and you are wrong. The word 'lynch' is totally inappropriate to use especially when describing what to do to a black man jokingly or not. Surely this word does not invoke the same feeling to you as it does African-Americans because your family members were not the ones hanging from trees on a regular basis just a few years back in this great nation of ours.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

The Noodler — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:35:50 GMT

Why does Al Sharpton continue to show up on my TV? If Kelly Tilghman and her use of the word "lynching" are the height of racism today, racism is dead.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Nat Irvin, II — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:43:26 GMT

Mike,

You have got to be kidding. Your disdain for Sharpton has distorted the real issue here. You cited a novel as a source for lynching!! You apparently have no appreciable understanding of your own country. Lynching is not something to look for in a novel, and it is not a term to be used lightly. Lynching is central to the black experience in America. I dare you to go see the film, " The Great Debaters" directed by Denzel Washington. On the matter of lynching, you are clueless.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tim Majoras, Bowling Green, Ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:04:55 GMT

Unfortunately it seems the reverend has nothing else to do with his time. This just seems like another opportunity for Sharpton to get his name in the news. Kelly Tilghman apologized, I did not hear Sharpton apologize to the Duke lacrosse students when he got a whole town up in arms and the students were later judged to be innocent.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mark Oberle, New Ulm, MN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:06:52 GMT

Thanks, Mike. One of your better pieces. It's people like Sharpton that DON'T allow racism to disappear. If he did, he'd have nothing to stand on his soap box and scream about. Thanks, again.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Michelle Largo Florida — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:12:02 GMT

I agree. Al Sharpton is the biggest racist of all! When are these networks going to stop letting him dictate how they run their business. He's to racism what Don King is to boxing! An oppotunist who cares about no one but himself and his own agenda! Stop giving him air time and let him consontrate on paying his taxes!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob, Denver, CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:14:13 GMT

Thanks Mike for saying exactly what I've been thinking since yesterday afternoon.

I've been a fan of the golf channel for some time now and Kelly Tilghman in particular. She is a great anchor and it's a credit to the golf channel for finding her. Shame on them for letting Sharpton "lynch" Kelly for "obviously" innocent remarks.

As for Sharpton, I'm disgusted by the way media/network executives bend to his (and Jesse Jacksons) histrionics. They have no purpose in life except to incite anger and stir up controversy so that their small constiutencies have something to grouse about.

BTW, your analogy about western movies is exactly
what came to mind when I heard about lynching statement.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tom delavergne, springfield, PA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:25:16 GMT

OUTSTANDING!!!!!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John S, MO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:28:44 GMT

Wow! I pretty much thought the exact same thing. Way to go!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike K, Toronto, Canada — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:45:39 GMT

Finally, someone who has the guts to call out Sharpton for the hate-mongerer that he is.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John L. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:49:15 GMT

Right on, Mike. I couldn't agree with you more. No one race owns the English language. It belongs to all of us. Sharpton just needs to get his name in the paper and that's why he can't keep his nose out of things. His recent actions in talking to an escaped criminal from NJ in Mexico City should put him up for obstruction of justice or aiding and abetting a fugitive because he decided that he should talk with him before law enforcement. His quote was hilarious (paraphrasing here - Why do people want to politicize this. All that was going on here was someone trying to help his community. Blah!!! Give me a break Al.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

steve austin texas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:49:16 GMT

that's the way to say it .al sharpton needs to keep he's BIG MOUTH SHUT. always in someone else's business. never his own. stick to what he know's best nothing.
'

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave, Garfield Heights, Ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:53:14 GMT

Right on Mike, right on. Leave it to Al Sharpton to take a comment that had nothing to with race, and make it all about race. That pretty much sums him up. Doesn't he realize that by continuing to rant about these "causes", he is only forcing the racial gap in this country wider. If Tiger - the subject of this supposed racial comment - is a rational enough person to see that there was no ill intent in the statement, what business does Sharpton have poking his nose around in it?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jomo Walker Denver Colorado — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 16:10:04 GMT

Dear Mike Ms kelly Tilghman should be fired.Why?Between 1882-1968 3468 black people were lynched in the USA. This is not about Al Sharpton sir my mom
was raised in Alabama,she has told stories of encounters with white males who were going to harm her
in the 1950's. Mr Woods does not like black women
therefore it is easy for,Mr Woods to forgive Ms Tilghman so quickly.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

john doe, seattle, washington — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 16:14:03 GMT

Ask Sharpton if he ever apologized to Steven Pagones, or for that matter, paid him the money ($65,000) awarded him by the courts for defamation of character. Ask Al Sharpton if he ever apologized for the comment about the politicians he ran against, calling them "recycled white trash." Ask him if he ever apologized for saying that Jessie Jackson should not have apologized for his "Hymietown" remark. Why is he demanding everyone to apologize for what they say when he himself said that apologizing would be "all about submission." Who is really setting 'double standards'? Isn't his theatrics more about publicity for himself than actually being concerned for people's welfare?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

(Beverly Smith, Philadelphia, Penna.): — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 16:26:36 GMT

Thank you, Thank you!!!

I am a 60 year old African American woman, and I can even tell that it was just a poor choice of words. We ALL have said something and than later wish we had put it differently. I also agree that she should not have been suspended

I'm quite sure as soon as she said it she realized that it didn't sound so good.

I don't have too much respect for Al Sharpton when he does things like this, and he really need to some real soul searching or get a life.

And last but not least, kudos to Tiger for seeing it for what it really is, a poor choice of words.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

VS, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 16:28:55 GMT

Thank you Mike for teaching that "Reverend" a few things.....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ticked at TV, Denver, CO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 16:41:11 GMT

Our national and world news reporters have become shills for the National Enquirer and can make blatantly accusatory statements, but let someone kid about a minority and we get Shapton'd and Jackson'd to death. The fact this story got so much press just makes me want to puke.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

George, Tampa Bay FL — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 16:43:03 GMT

Thank you Mike! Well stated.
I think Kelly should SUE the goos reverand, maybe that might shut him up and make him think before he opens his mouth and incites such rediculous thoughts in everyday people next time.

Come on America, let's take back our country from all of the hate mongers that have nohing better to do with their lives than exploit a truly harmless word - Maybe we should "Lynch" the reverand, there I said it. And to be perfectly clear, I mean it as it was intended...Take him out back and teach him a lesson.
Not because he is Black - but because he is inciting racist attitudes where none existed.

Simple thoughts from a simple black man.
G.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jack Paramore, Wilmington, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 16:47:26 GMT

You have nailed the issue correctly. Add to it the apparent; that Sharpston is merely looking for another source of income for his hateful cause. He is a racist. Kelly is not, Tiger is not. They have class. He has none.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

J. Turley — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 17:00:06 GMT

I agree Al Sharpton is the main reason for her suspension. Mr. Sharpton needs to realize that those that place themselves on pedestal need to be careful. That wood may have termites.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mark , Springfield, Mo. — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 17:57:17 GMT

The only racist in this whole story is Al Sharpton. I wish the news channels and papers would just ignore him and let him go back to ranting on the street corner.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob D. Lewiston, ME — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:04:34 GMT

Wow! This was the first I here about this situation. Like you, when the word "lynching" was first used, I thought of the old western movies. I never gave racialism a thought and I'm 56 years old. Tilghman was wrongly treated, no question in my mind. Is Sharpton trying to make a name for himself? What is happening in America today?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

orlando — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:15:23 GMT

Sharpton offends everytime he is plastered on TV or newspapers

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Darrell, Lees Summit, MO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:22:04 GMT

While I agree that the Tilghman suspension was grossly excessive, perhaps you could a little history lesson regarding the origins of lynching. Please consider the following information.

“The term "lynch" is derived from the name of Charles Lynch, a Virginia planter and patriot during the American Revolution, who directed violence toward White British loyalists. After the Civil War and emancipation, lynching became almost synonymous with hanging and torturing African American males. Between 1882 and 1930 more than 3300 Black male victims were hanged, burned alive, castrated, and mutilated by mostly southern White mobs who have never faced any charges for these criminal acts.”

Let’s consider educating others with respect sensitive subjects instead of attacking them. I think both you and Rev. Sharpton are wrong. Hopefully cooler heads will prevail and people will gain some knowledge as a result of this incident, despite the vitriol from those of you who choose sides.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bobby Hill, Little Rock, Arkansas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:26:48 GMT

U are so right on with this article and especially with the things u said about sharpton. Pious, self-righteous and a holier than thou attitude.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Henry D, Lake Elsinore Ca — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:31:50 GMT

I am a black man, a black professional in the US, I served my country in the USMC for 4 years during time of war and I was not amused by the comment. It was racist, inappropriate whether offense was meant or not. Whether harm or disrespect is meant is never an excuse, people should be held accountable. I dont beleive she should be fired, but she should certainly have some consequence.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

LD McClain — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:33:36 GMT

Mike, I was raised in Texas at a time when blacks had to sit at the back of the bus etc. I used to go to my uncles and pick peas and cotton with blacks and rode to market in the back of the pickup with them. Never was there a time that we treated each other racially. Times sure have changed.

Enjoyed your point of view.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Carlisa Barnes, Castro Valley, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:47:03 GMT

Just because I am a Black American expressing my feelings about this subject, do not assume I am in total agreement with Al Sharpton. He was not the only one offended and for you to down play it because of his position upsets me a lot. This is an issue and problem this country countiues to have. Hopefully, if you read this you will understand where I am coming from. This incident with Kelly Tilghman has once again showed me the America I live in. Being an educated, young Black woman, I am amazed all the time at how people in this country, especially Caucasian people feel that it is okay to make vile comments about my people that reference slavery. She could have said, “They need to take him to the back ally and give him a beat down.” Anything besides using the vernacular that references on of this country’s most heinous past. And it is not just Tilghman. For people in this country to not know and understand our history as a nation and feel it is okay to use words like, lynch, and nappy, reminds me of the Jim Crow days of the US. Are people that ignorant and insensitive to human beings to not see that it is not okay? If I look back 3 to 4 generations at my existence and history in this country do you know where it leads me to? Slavery. If I look at my mother and my grandmother, do you know where that leads me to? Jim Crow laws, the KKK and the Civil Rights movement. AND if I wanted to go any further and find my ancestors in Africa, do you know where that leads me? To a dead end. However, in this new day and age, I may be able to find my ancestors via DNA and long intensive searches that may or may not be completely accurate. On one hand, I can understand where Tiger Woods is coming from in not completely acknowledging this incident, I am not saying she is racist but on the other hand, I can not. I would not and do not have friends that would be so disrespectful, inconsiderate and ignorant to even say such words referencing me or anyone like me in such a manner. You expressed what you think of when you hear the word, lynch. But do you know what I think of when I hear the word, lynch? I think of a big group of white men taking a black man away from his home and family in the middle of the night to have a picnic and the next morning his wife and kids waking up to him hanging by the neck from a tree with his genital in his mouth. And you think this two week, I am sure with pay, reprimand is an apology? Tilghman should have been taken off the air when she made the comment, not given a slap on the wrist when this channel felt the wrath of her decision to say what she said. Which I am still wonder why the hell (excuse me) she would use such a word.

I would feel the same way about comments made about Jewish Americans, Mexican American, Chinese American, and Native American people. Let’s learn our history as a country and learn to be more sensitive to each other. Because it is our history and it does matter. The fact that people don't see it and deal with it makes it worse and instances like this will continue to happen.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:51:55 GMT

Lynch To inflict punishment upon, especially death, without the forms of law, as when a mob captures and hangs a suspected person. Person(any color) Get a grip AL. Get an education, stop feeling like everyones against you. Move on etc...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ahmed, Atlanta, GA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:55:31 GMT

She should have been fired yesterday! What she said was racist, whether she had a "history" of racism or not. If she didn't realize the severity of her statement, she should be fired for stupidity. I am with Rev. Sharpton on having this woman removed, or staging an ongoing protest until she is.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

RH Elkin Chesterfield, MO — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 18:59:35 GMT

Kelly's comment was meant to be funny, and it was to most people. Anyone who was watching at the time knew so. Al Sharpton is clearly racist and like Jesse Jackson will seize any moment in order to launch a protest. His next move will probably be to picket her return to broadcasting. Her comment in know way was condenscending and doesn't even merit discussion. I am very disappointed in The Golf Channel and if any more is made of this I will stop watching it. We have too many "frightened" people at the helm of businesses
willing to sacrifice anyone. That is poor leadership. The Golf Channel needs a change at the top. Why would anyone, especially of Tilghman's caliber want to work for someone without any backbone?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ty — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:05:50 GMT

Well said! The Reverend Sharpton is "out of bounds" on this one. With stroke and distance that's playing three now from his original position.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave Strobel, Prior Lake, MN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:13:39 GMT

When I first heard about this, the Golf Channel said they planned no disciplinary action. I'll admit, that didn't feel quite right to me. Having Al Sharpton weigh in doesn't either! My first reaction was to email the Golf Channel suggest they pull her off the air for one tournament as a way of recognizing what you said in this column - it's was an extremely poor choice of words and there is a racial component to the term "lynch." I was suprised that they went with two weeks. She absolutely should not be fired as requested by the Rev. However, I wouldn't be comfortable if nothing was done. So, I guess two weeks is better than nothing.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bryan Dalzell, Pasadena, Maryland — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:19:28 GMT

You're absolutely correct in this article. Anybody likening Ms. Tilghman's statements to those of Imus is clueless. She made a comment which came out incorrectly and promptly apologized for it. Imus made a hateful comment purposefully to be outrageous, then only apologized when called out on it.

I wish somebody would tell Sharpton to look up "lynch" in the dictionary and realize that it isn't simply a racially motivated term. Clearly one doesn't have to be of a certain race or ethnicity to be lynched.

Benedict Arnold was "lynched." I don't hear anybody yelling at the descendants of the American Revolution for an apology. The connotation that people have with the word "lynching" derives from the despicable acts that have occurred in American history involving African-Americans being viciously killed for no reason. Nobody is, nor should they be, trying to downplay what has happened in our history as a nation. I, personally, don't interpret Ms. Tilghman's statement as believing that the PGA golfers should form a lynch mob and kill Tiger Woods.

Ms. Tilghman utilized a poor choice of words. I would wager everybody has said something that came out the wrong way and would have liked to have had it taken back. Maybe if we stopped giving Sharpton the platform to release his ignorance then we'd be able to save our outrage for an instance that truly warrants it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike Taipale Bath — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:27:53 GMT

Another example of 'tyranny by a few' at the expense of all. When the language police deal with such inconsequential issues such as this, individuals providing 'entertainment' will be so guarded and mute that simple yes and nos will be the only safe content. Boring. Yes. SHAME on management to caving into Al.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Donald L. Bert Annapolis, MD — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:53:21 GMT

I heard a news report recently that cited statistics saying that from the early 1900's to the late 1930's, on average, two African Americans were lynched in America, EVERY DAY! The idea that anyone in this country could make a joke out of this issue is completely abhorrent.

Those who do not know history are condemned to repeat it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ed Godsey, Whichia Falls, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:55:10 GMT

Mike, like you, I also think Ms. Tilghman made a bad slip of the tounge with no malicious intent. However, your remarks about lynching not being a total racial remark are off base. You take a minute and just "Goggle" the word "Lynching" and see what responses you get. While it was called a"lynch mob" in the movies, the term associated with cowboys was "we're going to string'em up". I believe this was done to make a clear distinction between the hanging of a cattle rustler and the lynching of a Black person. The suspension is debateable on both sides. To me, this wasn't like Jimmy the Greek, Al Campanis or Fuzzy Zeller, this was just a bad choice of words. Bottom line, there are certain words that strike at the very souls of people that remind them of a very brutal and vicious past. You see Mike, I could be a white law abiding cowboy and never have to worry about being "strung up" in the middle of the night, but if I was a law abiding Black man at that same time in history, I still had to worry about being "lynched". With the reason being.... "Just becasue...."

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rudy Milosevich, Columbus, Oh — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:55:40 GMT

Mr. Celizic is correct that the definition of 'lynch' is not racial in nature. However, as an avid golfer and historian of the game I think it is important to remember that golf (more specifically the country club culture) was a late adopter of equal rights clauses. Mr. Sharpton creates controversy so that issues will see the light of day. Lets step back from such kneejerk reactions (Sharptons and Celizics) and continue the discussion. A lot has been accomplished toward racial equality in this country. A lot remains to be done.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ron Campbell Winnipeg Manitoba Canada — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 19:59:46 GMT

I totally agree, (lynching) hanging someone without benefit of a trial, happened to whites, blacks, chinese etc, etc. Sharpton and Golf Channel should apologize to Kelly and right now. Ron Campbell

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim Short, Franklin, Tn — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:24:10 GMT

I am glad someone of intelligence and a platform has awakened and spoken for those of us who do not have a platform from which to be heard. The Reverand is like some others of his ilk who only want to keep their names in the press. Ms Tilghman was probably speaking in fun terms as all golfers do with no intent of harm. Lightenup people!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jenifer, Columbus OH — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:26:36 GMT

As a young, black, college-educated female I come across racism and stereotypes everyday. Was I offended by Ms. Tilghman's choice of words? Yes. But I am more appalled at the way "Reverend" Sharpton continues on his witch hunt! If one was to investigate the relationship between Ms. Tilghman and Mr. Woods, they would find that they have a personal friendship that is greater than their professional relationship. I believe that it is this level of comfort that caused Ms. Tilghman to use a phrase not meant for public consumption. My closest friends and I do the same when talking about my "nappy" hair versus their "greasy" locks. It is a shame that she didn't choose her words more carefully and thus, is suffering the consequences of her actions. However, it is a greater shame that every misdeed performed in this country earns one ridicule and a label as a bigot. I have only one thing to say to Mr. Sharpton in regard to his histrionics and that is to mind those things that truly matter. While racism is still existent - albeit cloaked - I find that it is in greater supply from those with darker complexions. They defend their intolerance with the excuse of open wounds from the past of their ancestors. I am verbally attacked every day by young, black men who want to know why I'm so "uppity" or why I'm not "keepin' it real". Each time I let them know that I am not their "Ma", "Girl", or "Wifey", I am looked at as though I have four heads. I would recommend that Mr. Sharpton redirect his focus from facilitating division between the races to teaching respect and tolerance for all.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jay Corso, Jamesport, NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:29:24 GMT

Mike, you say "with all due respect to the Reverend." He doesn't deserve respect. He's the biggest racist of anyone out there. He's a media hound looking for headlines. He should keep his focus on his calling, stay in the pulpit where he belongs (does he even have one?)

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Corey Williams, Detroit, Michigan — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:32:31 GMT

I consider myself a reasonably intelligent African American man. She didn't mean it the way the "Rev" took it. Sharpton in a boob.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Daniel, Tulsa OK — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:53:28 GMT

Thank you for this article. The only segregation done was by Al Sharpton himself. Why can't Tiger be treated like the rest of the gentlemen on the tour? If she would have applied the term to Phil Mickelson or Ernie Els would anyone be up in arms? I watched the program and all she was stating was Tiger is the best and that is the only way to stop him. It was a kudos to Tiger more than anything. It is time for Mr Sharpton to leave the rest of us alone.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jabril Muhammad newport News Va — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:55:50 GMT

As usual, whites just don't get it. But how can you expect a race of people that have never been persecuted, abused, or treated unfairly wholesale to get it. I guess we should just continue to allow people to use language that---whether white America chooses to admit it or not---is hurtful and offensive to those who experienced horrors at their hands. I guess we should act like 1950-1965 was centuries ago...the horrors of lynchings not fresh in the memories of many Blacks....like my parents who grew up under this type of thing in the South. No, America....we won't speak out anymore, just treat us as you always have. Tiger...maybe one day you'll understand, too.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

J Green — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:56:54 GMT

I agree with you SHAME on Al Sharpton. He should ask himself if he is helping or hurting people. I think he hurts more people then help them

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike, Omaha NE — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 20:58:20 GMT

I agree 100% with your conclusions. I was also surprised the Rev Jesse Jackson did not take great offense with Ms Tilghman's comments too! He too is another person that is quick to be judge and jury on people.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim Hudson, Ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:04:48 GMT

Mike,
This is a little to do about nothing except when you get Al Sharpton involved. He's nothing but a trouble maker and hypocrite. Regretably, the politically correct media is gutless to stand up for common sense and they let Sharpton intimidate them. This is a case where the tail is wagging the dog.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jasmine Cleveland Ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:11:36 GMT

Please please know that Al Sharpton does NOT speak for all black people (not even most). We understand the slip of the tongue, we understand speaking before thinking, and we certainly get that what she said is not worth her job

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Derric, Charlotte, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:14:23 GMT

You say that because you are white and can't begin to understand the impact of a statement like that. If she made a seemingly "anti-Semitic" slip of word use against a Jewish player, you don't think the JDL would call for the same punishment? It's always ok to stand up for religious virtues, but racial virtues are often summarily dismissed as you are attempting to do . She shouldn't be fired but giving her time off to think about her actions is quite suitable. Shame on you for attempting to justify her statement. Al wasn't the only one who was offended !!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

larry portland ore — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:14:45 GMT

Well I guess long as you don't mean it you can say whatever you want on TV. She needs to be at least suspended until she can get some classes or training under her belt. I heard the comment, and as a Black Man in his fifties I said Oh No here we go again. Because even in 2008 I think that what a few people would like to do to Tiger Woods. As a golfer in Oregon I know that's what some golfers would like to do. So Mike I think your employer might consider sending you to some sensitivity class. I don’t want that word used even in Joking on the Golf Channel.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

jo_nasty, highlands ranch colorado — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:16:22 GMT

who is the racist here? Sharpton needs to get over all these racial inuendos. I'm sure someone told him that this was said on TV and in order to get his name in the news, Sharpton jumped on it and said that Kelly is racist. Why don't we ask Tiger who is a racist? Al or Kelly!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Will — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:24:03 GMT

This is a test comment

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Holly, Santa Monica, CA — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:25:55 GMT

Thank God someone else things Al Sharpton is a self righteous CLOWN. Furthermore, he only stands up for things said against African Americans. Where is Mr. Sharpton when someone uses a racial slur against a white person? Oh, wait, white people dont matter to Sharpton. Neither do women. He sees what he wants to see, and hears what he wants to hear. He's a very sad, sad individual. Poor thing.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jorge Suarez, Tucson, AZ — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:35:18 GMT

Very well written column. How can we get the message to Al Sharpton that he is creating more ill will in our society with his irrational and unjust influence. I truly hope the black community turns away from the Al Sharpton and looks to a true leader who will bring blacks and whites together based on common human decency. Al Sharpton is constantly on the hunt for the soundbite that can be used to divide us.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rey — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:36:26 GMT

Right On, brother.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Phil, Southfield, Michigan — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 21:48:39 GMT

Mike Celizic, You are an idiot. If you think that lynching is not offensive to African Americans then you need to adjust your education level and sensitivity. African Americans have been lynched in America for the last 300 years. Your point of view just illustrates how far Americans have strayed away from intelligent thought. Thanks for the reminder.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

ed white — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:00:57 GMT

Sir you are ignorant of slavery and american history, lynching was a regular pasttime in the south for many years in our nations past and this lady's words were offensive to every black person. Tiger was not affected because he doesn't believe he is black.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Robby, Winston-Salem, NC — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:05:17 GMT

I think we all agree Sharpton is an idiot. That aside, the comments were ridiculous and yes, in the end racist or at the very least, horribly insensitive given the historical significance of the comment and it being directed toward a person of color, no matter a slip of the tongue or not. She needed some time off, maybe not fired, but at least suspended. Eventhough the comment was made in jest, there are some things you just don't joke about.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

steve las vegas — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:09:34 GMT

I think the real problem with the Al Sharpton issue is that the news even acknowledges him. His opinion is of no value.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James N. Canady, Houston, TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:11:18 GMT

One day, Mr. Sharpton's reckless, unsubstantiated charges of racism are going to be met with a slander suit. The elements of slander seem to be genuine: causing damages via false claims. If a jury could not deem Colin Ferguson to be a racist for his murderous rampage of Caucasians and Asians, how can Kelly Tilghman be considered a racist for a clumsy, impromtu attempt at humor?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Les Zan — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:36:45 GMT

Merriam-Webster defines LYNCH as - to put to death as by hanging without legal sanction. There is no link to racial or cultural contexts. I cannot believe that the Golf Channel submitted to Al Sharpton who is himself a racist by the very way he goes on witch hunts. Oh no. The Witches Coven of Salem will be after me now.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Donald Green — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:37:15 GMT

I think the Golf Channel did not have the guts to stand up for their employee. If Tiger did not get upset about what was said , why should anyone else?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

sports fan — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:38:40 GMT

Normally I wouldn't say Al Sharpton is public figure I find particularly appealing. But I think he is totally right about this. In any other sport, she would have already lost her job. Remember Jimmy the Greek anyone? It's not about her, it's about what's acceptable to say on television, what is acceptable language for public discourse. To get along in a complex, diverse, large society, it makes sense to have certain baseline rules that everyone abides by. I'm not sure I've every seen anything quite as offensive as this. She should lose her job, no question.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dave Strobel, Prior Lake MN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:44:26 GMT

I understand that she was trying to pay Tiger a compliment and it was a spur of the moment comment, not a pre-written statement. But my goodness, there were 100s of ways to make her point. She said something stupid and insensitive - what's wrong with pulling her off the air for awhile. A sportscaster in MN accidentally dropped the f-bomb on live television and he was also suspended. I acknowledge that Sharpton is over the top. He wanted her fired, they originally said they would take no action. Nothing wrong with a good old compromise.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Brian, Houston TX — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:59:24 GMT

True, she should not have been suspended. She should have been fired. If I were her boss I'd be thinking "how can someone be so stupid?", then "what's she going to say next?" If the golfer was Jewish he should be "gassed"? There must be thousands of good looking people with some knowledge of golf who'd be willing to stand in front of a camera for hundreds of thousands of dollars per year. Next!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

ARMAND PARIAN — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 23:06:08 GMT

FIRST OF ALL AL SHARTON IS ONE OF BIGGEST IDIOT/STUPID POWER HUNGER MAN I EVER SEEN OR HEARD. HE ALWAYS THINK THAT HE IS ABOVE EVERYTHING. AS FOR ME I DON'T THINK WE NEED HIS STUPID COMMENTS.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

PJ Flanagan, Bay Village, Ohio — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 23:10:46 GMT

Rev. Sharpton,

I read today that you are calling for the Golf Channel to terminate the employment of one of their commentators who made a remark that you found offensive. I assume that the reason that you found this comment offensive is because it included the word “lynch” in the same sentence with Tiger Woods, who is partially African-American. Reverend, would the same comment have offended you if it were made in reference to Phil Mickelson? White people have been lynched. Do you really believe that the commentator use the word lynch only because she was referring to an African-American? If you truly do, you are deluded.

I understand that your agenda principally centers on furthering your own career at the expense of true racial unity, but at some point it must become difficult to look at yourself in the mirror. How much further are you willing to devalue actual racist actions/words in America by championing these ridiculous causes?

The general public is led to believe that your life’s work is to advance the cause of racial equality and racial unity. I would like to work towards racial harmony in America but truly believe that your inane grandstanding for worthless causes like this only add to the discord. How is pursuing this frivolous issue honestly going to advance the cause of racial unity? Potentially, unity is not your goal.

In closing, Reverend Sharpton, please provide a list of the words in the English language that all Americans can use without fear of your judgment or wrath. As the moral compass for our country, I feel it appropriate that you and you alone should let us know what is right and wrong to say

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tim, Birmingham, Alabama — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 00:08:47 GMT

Whatever happened to the meaning of a sincere apology? Kelly personally called Tiger to apologize, and he "publically" said that everything's okay and to move on. I think that all that Kelly has accomplished (outstanding commentator, first woman as main commentator for PGA Tour telecats, excellent role model) should not be diminished or thrown away because of one mistake.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

russell l. mccullough — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 00:09:30 GMT

Al sharpton should get a life and spend more time preaching to his people and let the news media do there thing. the young lady was only trying to be funny. no harm intended.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bobbie C. Allen, Atlanta, Ga. — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 00:15:11 GMT

I think the suspension was warranted to send a message
to everyone in the news business that you have a responsibility for how you speak as well as conduct yourself to the viewing audience. The comment was out of line,tasteless and above all unprofessional. What if some one listening who hated Tiger for what he has done in the golfing world and made an attempt to carry out the suggestion. I hope that we all learn a lesson from this poor display of judgement and remember to think before you speak. Kelly, the proper way for any golfer to challange Tiger is to become better at the game than he is.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim Byrne — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 00:19:57 GMT

How can the Golf Channel dive under the table with this issue. How is it possible for one person to make you guys shiver in your Foot Joys?
You claimed that Kelly's choice of words were inappropriate. You and I both know that your comment was for Sharpton's benefit.
I guess it's ok for foul-mouthed Dottie to call our girl's golf team "choking freaking dogs" on national TV and nothing happens to her.
What you're doing here is putting Kelly down on the same level as Imus. (even Imus shouldn't have been fired) You must defend her on this and not run and hide.
DO WHAT'S RIGHT!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John, San Diego, CA — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 00:24:56 GMT

I believe Al said that whether she's a racist is immaterial. He's right. Whether she's friends with Tiger is similarly immaterial. She is an employee that works for a broadcaster. I am a professional union representative and I can tell you from experience that 2 weeks for that comment is reasonable. Her fundamental obligation to her employer is to give a significant quantity and quality of broadcasting to Golf Channel. The term is racial. There is no other form of lynching. Its a terror tactic pretty much exclusive to racists in our vernacular. She effed up. Bet she won't do that again. That's the point of corrective action. If she was fired, I'd mostly agree with you, but to say she didn't deserve any corrective action is silly.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mel, Oakland, CA — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 01:02:45 GMT

Well, Your article is lacking correct substance on this important issue. This is not about Al Sharpton. You need some classes on sensitivity yourself apparently. Your holier than thou arrogance is showing. For you to say that "not everyone automatically associates lynching with racism." Well sir in this country we do. Do you know the history of that word in America? It is all bad news. Shame on you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Anthony, New Orleans, LA — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 01:10:44 GMT

This was an awful column. Completely insensitive. Indeed, Reverend Al Sharpton was not the only one insulted. He is right in that the fact that she might not be a racist is immaterial. Harm was done and it needs to be addressed and corrected. Those words are offensive. I like Kelly a lot but words have power and meaning. Her words hurt. Am I overly sensitive? Maybe, maybe not but again that is not the issue.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tripp, GA — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 02:35:34 GMT

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Lady B, Saint Louis, MO — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 04:09:30 GMT

WHAT? Even if TIGER does believe Tilghman's lynching comment was "a nonissue" Historically, HE HAS TO KNOW (and so should she) it is AN ISSUE!! Out of the mouth flows what's in your heart.....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Stephen Llewellyn Portland,Oregon — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 07:28:43 GMT

Let me just add my word of support to your view Mr Celzic. I am not going to deal piecemeal with why your comments make sense and an unfortunate number of others do not. Zoeller's comments were racist and mean-spirited. Tilghman's was an unfortunate slip which all (except perhaps Sharpton) accept had no malice in it. Suspension? It would be laughable were it not this lady's livelihood.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

MaryBarbara Sanchez, Arvada CO — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 10:32:59 GMT

If a male commentator had "jokingly" called for Kelly to be taken to a "back alley and gang rape," would we still regard the incident as notworthy of a two week suspension at best? I very much doubt it, and rightly so because these remarks are VERY IMPRUDENT and UNPROFESSIONAL and should be accountable for it!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

ken — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 12:08:46 GMT

We all greatly admire Tiger's father for the way he raised a real champion. From all appearances, his father is black. Where is his mother? When we state that 'he is black', do we impune his mother, or just write her off. My daughter-in-law, who also appears to be black, has given me two beautiful grandaughters, and had raised three of my grandsons. If my grandaughters are regarded by you as black, well that is your prejudice. If they are regarded as white, well that is your prejudice also. Tiger is one of us, and that is all that needs to be said.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

A.J., Cape Coral, FL — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 12:22:17 GMT

The question to ask is: Would she have used the word "lynch" if she was talking about Phil Mickelson or Ernie Els? If she used it specifically because it is Tiger then that makes it racist regardless of whether it is malicious. Racism is not necessarily malicious. It is a prejudgment based on someone perceived as different. Many "acts of kindness" are based on racism because many see blacks and other minorities as in need of help because they cannot fend for themselves. The view may be racist even though the intent is not malicious.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

A.J., Cape Coral, FL — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 12:35:02 GMT

It is amazing how many people was unaware of the racial connotations to "lynching" considering the Congress apologized in 2005 for it's historical non-action to prevent lynchings of African Americans.

Are we really that uninformed?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

uche, Atlanta, GA — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 13:12:50 GMT

I am a black guy and I watch the Golf channel all the time and I love Kelly's work on the channel. I feel horrible for her, but has anyone thought about the fact the Golf channel could have done this to protect itsef from a future legal nightmare should some shenanigan try to use this word in a hateful manner in future and file a lawsuit, if they get suspended, "when Kelly was not". I believe this to be the reason behind the suspension, and I believe Kelly probably understands this has to happen for her employer, the Golf channel, to stay on firm legal fround. The Golf channel cannot allow a precedent to be set that can legally work against her; the judicial system thrives on precedents.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ed, Charlotte, NC — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 13:42:35 GMT

Unfortunately we live in the United States of the Offended. Put a helmet on, people. Glad someone wrote this article. Get over it!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Les Zan — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 15:36:30 GMT

Those who compare Ms. Tilghman's comments to comments made to a Jewish player regarding Gas Chambers - Not even close - the Gas Chammber was tied to a specific event in history, specifically the Holocaust. Lynching can happen anywhere that a mob decides to take the law into their own hands. That can be Kenya, Hungary, India, Burma or Antartica for that matter and yes, the USA. Although the word lynch may be tied to Black History, it can be referenced in many other events in history. The word Gas Chamber is tied to Jewish History and there are very few if any references that can be tied to the Gas Chamber other than Capital Punishment. Unfortunatley, I feel Mr. Sharpton does more harm to "his" cause by trivializing a horrible period in American History. Racism still exists but it also exists at many levels all over the world in all cultures. When I first came to settle in the USA, I was told to go back to Vietnam. Although I am Asian, I am not Vietnamese, but I considered the source and realized the angst some Americans felt at the time. We must take things in the context in which it was referenced. It is a shame that we can no longer speak innocently and freely with no intended malice without undeserved scrutiny to our every word and reference.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Lamont Selby, Port Chester, NY — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 21:14:34 GMT

Celizic, you have really lost it this time if you don't think Kelly deserves a suspension. For goodness sake she made a joke about lynching a black man!!! To compare this to the movie/book Oxbow Incident is so off base is ridiculous! No she should not have been fired (neither should Imus either) but a suspension was necessary. I do believe that because she is a woman it soften the impact of the incident and also showed why it took several days for it to become public. Tiger should not have let her off the hook and used this opportunity to make a statement about this kind of journalism/commentary that is happening too much nowadays. I regret he did not take a stronger stance.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sharon Richards, Canton OH — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 21:38:06 GMT

This has been so blown out of proportion. I seem to remember many a lynch mob on the old westerns-and it had nothing to do with race.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Hoping For Change, Los Angeles CA — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 23:21:53 GMT

To all who agree that Black people are too sensitive and that Al Sharpton is an opportunistic interloper (I agree with that one): Please share your honest reactions to these two scenarios please:

1. Michelle Wie or Anika Sorenstam actually whips up on a male golf field. The analysts take turns saying, "Hey, maybe the guys should gang up on her...laugh, laugh", "...yeah drag her in an alley and rape her..laugh, laugh, laugh!".

2. Great Jewish golfer is killing the field so much it's unfair..."Hey maybe the guys should gang up on him...laugh, laugh", "...yeah throw him in an oven and gas him...laugh, laugh, laugh."

This country is amazing....I am a professional Black man who has never felt that Al Sharpton spoke for me much at all...but here he is speaking not only for me, but he should be speaking for the entirety of America. Clearly he is not. This is SO NOT ISOLATED in that even Sharpton doesn't hear 90% of the crap that is going on out there being picked up by kids like in LA putting up nooses at schools and reinforcing the ignorance of many young people and older professionals like Mr. Celzic here about their own American history.

I wish Celzic could or would actually respond to my scenarios; maybe someone who knows him might ask if his reaction would be the same. Would the Anti-Defamation League or NOW be overreacting? Should they be silent just because Wie said the man was her friend and she knows he's not a rapist? You know the answer, and you know what it means, as painful as it is for most people in America to accept.

It means that race is still a very different animal here in America. We have a pervasive group denial unique to the treatment of black people by white people who decided when they ended Affirmative Action that they didn't want to feel guilty anymore and they don't owe black peole anything. Other forms of discrimination are alive and well, but racism has been eradicated forever, and anything that walks like this duck is a mirage or some sort of joke that Black people need to just get over. And if we don't, we are young ingrates like Muhammad Ali was framed, failing the legacy of Jackie Robinson who took it all and was grateful for the opportunity to turn the other cheek to any non-Black. They don't tell much the end of the story that this tremendous athlete who debuted for the Dodgers in 1947 in his 20s died in 1972 in his 40s from cancer caused by what it takes for a Black man to keep smiling and being disarming so as to not scare back then, or even offend now, any colleagues in the workplace by playing the race card or implying any type of racial inequity. No one of you wants to have that on you, so you have just declared it non-existent by voice-vote.

The unpleasant truth: Race still matters in America; and nothing else compares. Wanna try another one: Openly gay golfer, let's gang up on him, yeah take him in the alley and beat the crap out of him. See what I mean? There would be OUTRAGE!!!! But alas, "Let's lynch Tiger Woods" and what is all the commotion about. She's cute. Tiger likes her. And those black people should just get over it and be like Mike....and Tiger.

Un-bleeping-believable America. I'm fuming now, gotta go channel it by working here in LA for that drug-dealing, Muslim, kid-Senator who won't wait his turn and doesn't know his place. My bet is he will stay true to his character and our American ideals and win-or-lose help bring out the best in the American people.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ronald Simmons — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 02:34:53 GMT

Jokingly tell me your going to take be in a back alley and lynch me and see what happens next. Make sure you have your dictionary with you!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Calvin, Acworth, Ga — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 02:54:12 GMT

Everybody, both white and black go watch roots, and then write your comments about lynching again. I wished that every white man that has racism in his heart could be black for just one year. Then tell me how it feels to be black and live in America.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mark, Cumberland, RI — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 05:29:56 GMT

There was a cartoon w/ Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson praying to God to get rid of racism. In the next panel there was a lightning strike and then both Al and Jesse were gone. The problem is not that racism exists, it's that those two can never do anything else than paint everyone with the same brush at every minor utterance or slip of the tongue. When you point a finger at someone, remember that you have three pointing back at you.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

K. Klevenoski — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 05:52:21 GMT

What an idiot!

In the old west, white people "hung" murderers, horse thieves and criminals by due process...

Whites beat, horse whipped, stabbed, shot, spat on, castrated, disfigured "lynched" and finally burned negroes to death without so much as a hearing. So, unless you know the origin of the word Lynch which refers “specifically” to blacks, the only thing we should be hearing from the Golf Channel, Ms. Tilghman or anyone, including Mr. Celzic is a shameful apology for the very utterance of the word in the same sentence with Tiger Woods or any black person. You too should be silenced for your ignorance & insensitivity.....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Paul M., Playa Vista, CA — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 10:30:57 GMT

Tilghman's comments may be lighter than those of Imus on the Rutgers women's b-ball team, but Sharpton's words cut into the hearts of even innocent, slightly envious people speaking with tiny acid tongues of bias against well-known stars. No wonder Americans found him unfit to run the country in the last campaign; he could spray off the bugs excessively in a (almost) perfect political restaurant.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Drew, Cleveland, Ohio — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 13:00:25 GMT

Funny, but I do not look at Tiger as a 'black man'. He, to me, is just a very poised, talented super athlete and all-around class individual. When I read Kelly's comments, I giggled and cringed, not because the word 'lynch' brought visions of old south racially motivated violence, but rather that some unhinged person might consider an attack a way to resolve their frustration over Tigers dominance of golf. Am I wrong thinking? Conversely, when I hear Sharpton speak, the first thing I think of is racism. The Duke rape case is all you need to know about what a racist Sharpton truely is. (BTW, I thought Al was going to pay the strippers tuition no matter what the outcome of the case; those were his words, not mine). Stop giving the hate-mongers a megaphone. Common sense should rule the day, not intimidation.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

N. Duplessis, Mount Vernon, New York — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 15:13:58 GMT

Don't make this issue about Al Sharpton. It is not. The issue is that the word LYNCH appeared in a joke on national TV. Guess what? It's not funny. There is nothing lighthearted about such a thing. It offended me, and I'm not Al Sharpton. Kelly Tilghman should be removed from air permanently, certainly longer than two weeks, and without pay. No one has the right to determine the hurtfulness of her comment more so than the very people who lived in fear of being lynched. Some of us can still provide firsthand accounts of seeing a burnt, castrated Black man swinging from a tree somewhere in the South. Considering that this JOKE has been turning up everywhere recently, it's safe to assume that Ms. Tilghman had very recent exposure to the significance of the noose, and the subsequent dismay of her fellow Americans with Black skin. So, America, don't you dare say this is not offensive. And Mr. Woods, shame on you for your accepting response of such foolishness. It's one thing if she were in your living room with her shoes kicked off, and you both laughed together. National TV does not quite equate a living room, now does it?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

kate — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 19:38:51 GMT

Are you kidding! She should definitely be fired!@ NOW! I am a golfer, white etc etc and this completely disgusts me. Why. Because it was a racist remark and not about Tiger really. she showed her true colors and I have lost respect for here and not GC. I believe they are being cowards and she most certainly deserves more than a two week vacation! shame on you and shame on the GC for believing this is nothing! It goes against what golf stands for Fire Kelly now!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Nile Johnson, New York, NY — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 19:48:26 GMT

Is it ok to say "Let's 9/11 Hillary Clinton to keep her from further campaigning?" Is it ok to say "let's take Pete Sampras and put him in an oven to prevent him from participating in his next tennis match?" How about "let's feed an Irish athlete a rotten potato to keep him from competing in the future." Let's all make quadriplegic jokes around veterans who have lost limbs fighting for this "country." Lets make "Cop Shot" jokes at a gathering of families of police officers who have been struck down in the line of duty. Lets do arsonist jokes at a gathering of families of fire fighters who have died in the line of duty. Lets tell "Man on the cross" jokes on Good Friday. The persons telling these jokes meant no harm. Just trying to insert a little humor into an otherwise depressing atmosphere.
Lynchings, Gassings, The Potato Famine, The Crucifixion, Police officers and Firefighters dying in the line of duty, etc. are events which have brought woe to many people. It seems to me that many people think it's ok to make these vicious comments until they hit home. Then the commonts are not so funny anymore. Would you tell the mother of a prominent young athlete that, we are going to kidnap your son to keep him from playing in the next game, if you knew one of her other children had been kidnapped and murdered? Would you?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James, Houston, Texas — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 20:48:00 GMT

Mike, your logic is illogical to put it mildly. If the golfer was of Jewish decent and someone said, "just take him out back and gas him, HA, HA, HA" the person would have been fired on the spot (and rightfully so), no questions asked. Moreover, even if Tiger was not offended, it was a very offense remark and subconsciously says something about how this woman thinks...that a thought like that would even enter her mind. Mr. Celizic, you are not the authority on what is and what is not a "suspension" worthy offense to African-Americans. Al Sharpton is not the issue (as much as you would like it to be), the issue is that what she said reflects a total lack of culture understanding and appropriateness given the history of African-american's and the fact that for many years if white people got tired of a black person, the solution all to often was to simply lynch and be done with them. Kelly was dead wrong and you Mike are DEAD WRONG TOO!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Floored, Pittsburgh, Pa — Sun, 13 Jan 2008 22:39:57 GMT

Celzic in my opinion you are wrong in the worst way period.

To me your article aims to desensitize a repulsive phrase. I think you accomplished your purpose because there are a lot of insensitive replies listed above.

Claim Sharpton's an ambulance chaser all you want, but don't white wash the repulsiveness of the word lynch.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

EJJ, Minneapolis, MN — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 00:28:04 GMT

All Al Sharpton is doing by claiming that lynching is a racist term is perpetuating the idea that black people are different that white people. As horrible as the atrocities commited against black people are, the first people lynched were white folk in England.

If we as a society ever want to achieve a place in which ethnicity is not an issue then we need to stop creating differences between the ethnic groups. Until we give up the idea of "black" or "white" or "asian" we will continue to live in a world where men and women are judged on ethnicity rather than, as MLK put is so beautifully, the content of our character.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim, Valpo, IN — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 03:59:11 GMT

Tilghman should be fired! That's right, fired right after the Mayor of New Orleans is fired for his "chocolate city" comment!!! Where was "Al" when that happened? Can't have it both ways "Al".

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sean Crosby, West Reading, PA — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 13:07:51 GMT

Personally, being "p.c." is utter garbage... think about it, we've all had thoughts that were racist/sexist/whatever else towards someone and its bullshit that people get in a fuss about it. Even Tiger was fine with it, just let it die *sigh*

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John, Raleigh, NC — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 13:38:05 GMT

Lynching - "To execute without due process of law, especially to hang, as by a mob". Would someone ask Sharpton where the word BLACK is in this definition? Reverend or not, he needs to understand what he's talking about because this isn't racist at all. he just wants everyone to think it is. Do us a favor big Al, print out a list of the things people can and can not say that way we won't have to worry about offending you all the time...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Canada — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 14:51:10 GMT

I am a black male. My daughter plays golf and wants to be a professional one-day. She is learning about America’s past and what happened to innocent black people and children’s that cross the path of angry ordinary white American people. Sometimes black kids headed off to school would see a black person lynched and burned hanging from a tree. Would you as a white person want your kids seeing this? I am sorry they did let their kids see the hanging from start to finish as if it was a picnic. Their excuse to their kids was “they are not human so it is ok to do this”.

I understand that you as white people cannot grasp on what happened and the shock wave it produce and could have produced it my daughter watched and heard her comment on national TV. Would she think that they are still doing that to black people today or would a white child think that it is ok to say that because they are not human anyway?

I’ve watched the golf channel all my life even before Kelly Tilghman started. Was it bad choice of words? Yes it was. Should she be suspended? Yes. Fired? No. You cannot let comments such as that go passed you un-answered.

Now excuse me while I have to take care of damage control with my daughter. I have not told her yet and do not want her to hear about it when we watch the golf channel next time and be surprised and un-prepared for it.

That comment should not have reached the green in the first place never the less in the whole.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

GAP — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 16:13:17 GMT

I read all of the negative and negative comments regarding this issue. Al Sharpton is not the issue. My problem is that this country continues to be separated by racial lines. Political correctness is merely a way for people to hide the way that they really feel in order to keep their jobs. If this country had dealt with the racial issues years ago this problem would not continue to surface. White America is desensitized to the racial inequalities we face daily. When I say daily, I mean daily. There is nothing positive in the word “lynching.” That word can never be used in America and draw positive, warm fuzzies. If you believe that it does, you lie to yourself. That word has nothing to do with old western movies; every white American knows this one way or another. Lynching is taught in history and it continues in families of the KKK and white supremacist groups. Let us not patronize or insult the intelligence of others. The lack of racial intent does not negate the negative connotations of the comment. She made a mistake that I obvious, but what was the mistake. We can hide our feelings but eventually if one speaks long enough the truth eventually surfaces. Suspending or firing Kelly does not change anything but it does put people on notice that this type of comment will not be tolerated!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Robert, New Orleans — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 17:07:42 GMT

Well this really iritates me. Some of my ancestors were lynched in the west and now I'm very mad.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sean, New York — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 17:26:19 GMT

I have no ill will toward black, asian, white or hispanic populations. Each has its share of bad apples and each has its share of great men and women. Yes, there are still white people today that hate other races. However, there are African-American people who hate other races as well. Yes, back in the day a horrible injustice was done to African-Americans. All of us civil minded people know that. When does the point come where we can live without bringing up the injustice from 40 years ago? I'm not trying to be insensitive, but its a question I would really like the answer to. If this woman used the remark specifically because Tiger is African-American then I would certainly say that she needs to be fired. How many of you actually believe that she deliberately associated Tiger being black with lynching him? I, among others do not associate lynching with African-Americans. (And I have seen Roots) So does that makes us ignorant or just blind when it comes to the color of ones skin?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Doug C, Chicago, Illinois — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 17:49:15 GMT

I would not like to be directed as a "white" man. It is a direct reflection of my skin color. I do not use the term "black" I say/write African American for every direction. Please refer to me as Caucasion. So if you refer to me as a "white" person I take offense to that. This is so ridiculous.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

anonymous, ohio — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 18:16:12 GMT

I can see if Tiger thought he was being attacked racially, but according to him, it was no big deal. So let it go, Al Sharpton. Is it this man's job to publicly speak everytime someone says something that is racial? Why can't they let it go? He makes a big deal about the smallest things then blows them out of proportion.Remember the saying "sticks and stones will break my bones,but words will never hurt me" . This is not nearly as bad as Don Imus's remarks. If i listened to everything that people said about me i would go off the deep end. Al if you let it fall on deaf ears like everyone else and then maybe we won't get tired of hearing this thing called racism.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jennifer, Seattle WA — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 18:27:12 GMT

Have Al sit in a booth hour after hour, day after day and let's see what idiotic things he says. PC has gone over the top.
Give Kelly a break and get her back on the air, she is the best part of the coverage!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Peter Pedersen — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 18:33:26 GMT

You know Mike, I am amazed at the illustriouns do no wrong Al, who makes every statement made that could possibly be turned into a racial remard into one. He obviously doesn't know the definition of lynch! He has caused Kelly's punishment, not her own act. Sure a better choice of words, but only becuase Big Al is out there. We are all equal in this world. If Tiger wasn't affected, no one should be.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

mags Greenville, NC — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 18:50:09 GMT

I am not certain who died and annointed Al Sharpton king of appropriate speech. Mr Sharpton is a mean spirited, nasty piece of work and why the news media continue to give this loud mouthed idiot a forum for his ideas beats me.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

FamousTony C, Louisville, Kentucky — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 18:52:41 GMT

A Golf Channel anchor jokingly, albeit inappropriately, makes reference to lynching Tiger Woods to stop his dominance of the sport and suddenly it becomes a referendum on American race relations? It's this type of hyperbole that makes fringe-dwellers like Sharpton and David Dukes socially and politically relevant, folx. How about trying this on for size:

Kelly was laughing when she replied to Faldo's comment. Woods, who has been friendly with Kelly for more than a decade, immediately backed her up and stated the comment was not intended maliciously. This only became and issue once other new stations picked up on it and ran to Sharpton for a predictable response in order to fill airtime. And we've all taken the bait.

I guess 9 more soldiers dying in Iraq isn't "if it bleeds it leads" enough for them.

I'm one of those AA's for whom Sharpton has apparently annointed himself "leader." No offense, but I could care less what Sharpton thinks of this, as he does not speak for me on this (and many other issues.) She is not a racist, the comment was made jokingly, and we really, REALLY do need to get off of this kick of looking for monsters behind every door and beneath every bed. Enough already, folx.

If you want something genuine to debate about, how about predicting how long it will take Woods to break Nicholas' record?

Just food for thought---anyone else hungry for something more than popcorn fluff "news?"

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

steve joiner 950 twin brook court nw lawrenceville ga — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 19:00:10 GMT

This is the most ridiclous racially motivated converstaion I have seen in a while. White people please stop telling black people how to feel and react to offensive things said or done to them. just because you feel a certain way doesn't mean another white person is still not bigoted. Only speak for yourself and yourself only. Stop trying to justify something said with defense that the intent was meant to be mean or insensitive. You don't know the intent. She doesn't deserve to get fired but she doesn't deserve a pass either. She is a professional on the airways, she should have known better. Tiger is Tiget and I am who I am and I was offended. It was all in all in bas taste.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tom Maher, Las Vegas — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 19:01:30 GMT

Nice job Mike. It really bothers me that the media allows things like this to become sensationalized by letting people like Al Sharpton blow things out of proportion.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Don Kramer, Richmond, VA — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 19:02:05 GMT

Kelly Tilghman's choice of words may not have been the best possible choice at the moment. However, they in no way warrant the suspension. It's obvious she is not a racist, sexist or any other "ist" Al Sharpton wants to throw out there. In my opinion, Al Sharpton is helping to keep racism alive in America. If he did not come out of his house to the microphone everytime someone said something questionable, we would all be much further ahead socially.

Everyone has said something inappropriate in their life, even if it was not intended to be mailicious. We are humans, not robots and this will not be the last time something is said publicly that may be ethnically correct.

If Tiger can ignore it, there is no reason for Al Sharpton to drag it out. After all, the comment was not even directed to him so why doesn't he mind his own business. If Tiger was offended, he certainly has the clout to fight his own battles. Between family, golf and business, Tiger certainly has better and more important things to be concerned about.

As for Kelly Tilghman, she is talented and a good broadcast partner for Nick Faldo. The Golf Channel should not have suspended her. Whether it was to satisfy Al Sharpton or for their own reasons, if it were not for him, this story would not even be in the headline sports stories today.

I have friends from many different ethnicities that frequent my golf course and that I socialize with. The consensus is across the board that if Tiger doesn't care, why should we?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mel — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 19:34:38 GMT

"shame on Al Sharpton for so trivializing one of the most important social issues in America by demanding that Tilghman be fired for an utterly innocent verbal slip."

Didnt TIlghman do that all on her own? I dont understand the general hatred of Al Shaprton by many people for being a troublemaker, when all he does is provide a voice for some of us who are not represented in media or government. Im sorry it upset so many tender sensibilities, but it IS true. If it wasnt for Sharpton, many of these issues would be swept under the rug, but they would STILL be issues for many of us & it really wouldnt be guaranteeing everyone a fair say.

Tilghman's punishment can certainly be debatable, but to say the Golf Channel should act as if this was an innocent slip of the tongue is strange. The debate with me isnt that she is racist, because it is not all that uncommon or shocking & shes entitled to her own opinions, but that she was wholly UN professional in her role as a tv anchor. Can You IMAGINE Peter JEnnings tossing that out, no matter how benign? It was dumb, and just on a professional level, it was a gaffe because she didnt use the brainpower to realize that it would be insensitive to use those words. And if she doesnt know that & Im TGC, that makes me wonder how qualified she is to represent me.
Also, have you realized that since the Gena 6 coverage racist action has spiked in this country? There is a lot of fermenting going on under the surface. It cant be swept aside, people must learn to look at the other side (ALL PEOPLE ALL SIDES).

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ria — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 19:44:16 GMT

I CANNOT believe how many people will always put the blame on SHarpton when someone in the public eye is outed for insensitive behavior. It's as if they think Sharpton is the real problem, but Sharpton has a mouth just like everyone else. He doesnt REPRESENT all Black people, just like Celizic doenst represent all White people.

However, if Tilghman was speaking on a Japanese-American golfer & she said (in jest) 'why dont they just put him in an internment or something'. haha
She might not be racist, but it would be a really WRONG choice of words. Everyone makes a mistake, but her job is to be witty, & knowledgable under pressure. I dont know if she should be fired, suspended or just reprimanded. But I do know that it was NOT 'no big deal'. There is a gross injustice still going on in Gena, La. the DAs are levying harsher sentences against Michael Bell just because this case gained nat'l prominence. Nooses have been popping up ALL over the place since that case. Im not saying shes racist or an evil person, but I am saying that we still havnt dealt with the underlying sores in our society. Sharpton reminds us of them & that aggravates us, but it should.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Monique, Houston, TX — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 19:53:14 GMT

Tiger Woods doenst have to be offended by Tilghmans remarks for it to have weight. He represents a certain segment of the population, just like Sharpton does & they BOTH deserve the right to speak their minds.

As for Tilghman, who USES that word casually? I dont know people who casually say lynched, so yes, it did mean somehting to a lot of people.
Im also not surprised Tiger wasnt offended, Tiger considers himself more a citizen of numerous cultures rather than an African-American. Yet its interesting, that no one ever has disparaging remarks attributed to his Thai, Caucasian, or native American heritage. i.e. Fuzzy Zoeller's famous watermelon & fried chicken comments.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

hey doc, Woodbury, CT — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 20:04:14 GMT

There are few articles I feel equipped to respond to. There are a few articles I feel I must respond to. I didn't particularly feel obliged to respond to Mike's article when I first read it, but you people leave me no choice. How in God's name can some of you put your fingers on the keyboard to write such trash?

This is not about Al Sharpton or even about Tiger Woods. It is not about another stupid overpaid reporter nor her employer. THESE STATEMENTS CAN NOT, SHOULD NOT AND CLEARLY WILL NOT BE TOLERATED IN THESE UNITED STATES!! Why?....because of the simple fact that it is about time the majority (you know who you are) gave a crap about the sometimes piercing rhetoric that flows just a little too freely from your lips especially when it pertains to the mionrity (guess who I am). IT HURTS A WHOLE BUNCH OF PEOPLE!! My wife and I teach our 10 y/o to watch what he says in public so as not to offend anyone because "you never know who is listening". We just finished a presentation on the constitution and the amendments. I recently heard him challenge a kid in soccer practice for using the word "ghetto" to describe how someone was dressed. Hooray! C'mon folks, let's give a hoot about the next guy. Watch what the hell you say, regardless of who you are or where you are. Don't get your britches in a bundle just because now "the next guy" lets you know you just pissed him off and offended an entire race of people!!! This world would be a better place.

p.s. I happen to be a physician and surgeon and my son happens to be mixed. He looks very white!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tomas, Miami — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 20:18:13 GMT

Your article, unfortunately, only demonstrates the problem with her comment - the inability or arrogance in your case, for whites to show humility and compassion, even if they don't agree. It doesn't matter what Tiger thinks nor if she meant it in that manner, which I believe she did not. To even THINK that using that term in America about a group of white men assaulting a man of color is outrageous. For a supposedly educated American journalist who is supposed to have a grip on words' importance in an educated society to justify and condone it is sad. You should be ashamed of yourself. You are really a bigger part of the problem than she is...she just slipped up.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

c. moore, nashville, tn — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 21:15:30 GMT

Please people. We are becoming so sensitive about every little word that comes out of an announcer's mouth. Don't we have bigger problems to solve?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Waltina Harris. Atlanta, Ga. — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 22:57:31 GMT

I am always amazed at how white people can tell Black People how we should feel. You always want us to get over whatever insult is leveled at us. When any white person make a racist statement like she did, she knew what she was saying and now Tiger Woods knows also whether he admits it or not. Al Sharpton is not the only black person that was offended I can assure you of that. This is not just about Tiger the word "lynch"
isn't just past history to black people, these things are still going on in small towns in the south. You are seeing more nooses hanging on trees being displayed on some white people's cars and trucks. Why do you think that is? Maybe as a white man you can tell me "WHY". Every time some one make an insulting statement about a black person who comes to their aid but someone in the media who is white. Remember black people have feeling to, and that is one thing that some white people fail to understand that words hurt as much as the strap across our back and hanging from a tree. My people didn't put the noose around their own neck. When you start talking about how Kelly didn't mean what she said as an insult, tell her to pick up a Black History Book, O I forgot everything that happen to my people is not a part of History. Don't tell me how to feel.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Pedro Nieves New York, New York — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 00:20:04 GMT

I have follow Tiger Woods for over 13 yrs, and Kelly Tillman for over three. She is not a racist and her words were said to add to the conversation. I grew up the thw Williamsberg section of Brooklyn and the word always came up when we play another team who had a good player. It was a sign of repect to that player. But leave it to Al to try to restore cival rights for everybody. He does not represents me. Her words like Tiger camp said it a done issue.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

David Duncan Lake Lure NC — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 04:50:15 GMT

Oh John L Wolfe, You missed it. It was the Indians who did the scalping. lol Doesn't that show how stupid this is.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Brett Petsuch — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 06:38:26 GMT

Tilghman was trying to make a joke regarding how remarkable Tiger Woods has become,we all know and we all have said thing that didn't come out the right way and may have offened someone.Tilghman and Faldo always seem to be trying to cut it up.It was a mistake.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Matthew Crosby, New York, NY — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 08:28:16 GMT

Al Sharpton has reduced the discourse on race in this country to the level that people like John L Wolfe talk about "sensititvity training". What has happened to us? When Evers and King marched and died it wasn't over the misinterpreted remarks of cable sports commentators or anyone's lack of "sensitivity". They'd have laughed at that. It was against a culture of repression and physical violence. Those men changed the world and the way we look at ourselves, and while there is further to go down the road they cleared, it seems to me that we have missed a turn.

That you are offended by someone's words or actions does not make that person, their words, or actions, racist. If we allow Al Sharpton to throw the powerful word "racism" around at his pleasure and convenience (or if we do it ourselves), what meaning does it have?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Raymond Lombard — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 11:53:33 GMT

FIRE HER!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jock Jackard, Warren, MI — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 12:54:00 GMT

Why couldn't the show allow Kelly to make a short statemnet that she made a mistake in chosing her words. That she talked to Tiger, that he accepted her appology, and that she was sorry for causing any hurt feelings for waht she said. Can we not allow anyone to explain themselves and say their sorry, and they understand the way people feel about what was said?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Holly, Orlando, FL — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 15:08:57 GMT

BRAVO! It is about time someone someone said what many of us are thinking! Al Sharpton has apparently skipped over the parts of the Bible that preach tolerance and forgiveness. Judge not...dear Al. All of us have said things that we regret or that were inappropriate but I can assure all of you, as someone who knows Kelly personally, that she is not a racist and infact far from it. I am certain her first concern after the comment was for her friendship with Tiger and NOT for the judgment of a self-serving, arrogant, loud mouth Al Sharpton! Al is the reason that racism persists in this country. He incites hatred and anger on the part of ALL races including his own.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jack Thomson, Lake Jackson, Texas — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 16:33:03 GMT

A tempest in a teapot! Have we become so paranoid as to take everything personally? I'm afraid the answer is "YES"

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

L7, Baltimore, MD — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 17:20:32 GMT

What I find offensive is that the reverend does not acknowledge that Tiger Woods is half Thai. He is not an oppressed 'black man', he is a person. One who is not receptive to the preachings of the reverend apparently. If there is someone who should be offended - like in the Rutgers situation, wouldn't he have spoken up? Or at least released a statement through his publicist or attorney? He does not need the reverend speaking on his behalf. Face it folks - if Tiger Woods wanted to make a statement and let people know he was offended - wouldn't he have let it be known? If you have doubts about that - go ask that Irish newspaper.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

James Perry — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 18:13:09 GMT

First let me say, I am black, a proud black that will not tolerate racism in my presence.

However, we are an intelligent people. This situation did not warrant a suspension. At most, maybe an internal talking to, and a reminding that the 'lynch' word is not the best choice or words to use.

That said, I saw the video. The context in which it was used does not warrant any punishment. Al - I backed you during the Jenna 6; I agreed with you regarding Imus;, your involvement in this one make you appear like a joke.

Enough is enough.

Tiger - invite the suspended anchor to spend her 2 weeks suspension with your family.

Amen

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike Hunt — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 18:28:17 GMT

..can anyone take a joke anymore?

It was joke.... get over it ..and yourselves.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Debbie, Old Saybrook, CT — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 18:35:51 GMT

I just wonder, would it have been less offensive if the word "hang" had been used instead of "lynch?" And on the other hand, would there be any uproar if the same sentence had been used about, say, Phil Mickelson? Offensive, yes. Unfortunate, yes. Racially motivated, doubtful. Kudos to Tiger for taking the high road. And a side note to Rev. Sharpton; there will NEVER be an end to racism as long as people continue to use it as a catalyst for self-promotion under the guise of righteousness. Sharpton is the least color-blind of us all.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JOHN DOE, MISSISSIPPI — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 19:44:31 GMT

DO WE USE THE WORD LYNCHING WHEN IT COMES TO ANY OTHER RACE, OR IS IT JUST USED WHEN IN COMES TO AFRICAN-AMERICANS???

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rob, Alberta, Canada — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 23:32:57 GMT

This is crazy. Everyone needs to calm down and look at the entire picture. Her words can be thought of as insensative and mean, but what if she were talking about Phil Mickelson. Would everyone still consider her words racially charged? Would Al Sharpton still get on t.v. and claim her a racist? Everyone is so p.c. that they forget that not everyone is so gung ho to cry racism every time something, someone, some where might find offensive is uttered. People need to grow up

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Gates Collins — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 00:18:54 GMT

No racism, no Sharpton and no Jackson. They gotta keep the flame of hate burning or they cease to be relevant.

This whole situation is beyond ridiculous. Give Ms T a raise for having to listen to it!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Billy — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 06:08:53 GMT

Rediculous! If Tiger can accept the apology and understands, to hell with Sharpton!
The comment was a bit over the top. But, it was a quick, uncalculated comment to another. We all are human and have made mistakes or had things come out the wrong way.
This suspension is a shame. Would there have been a suspension had she talked about Phil Micholson being lynched?
Tiger was bigger than the rest in forgiving this accidental comment. It merely meant the only way to beat the guy would be to do him in. It was not meant to be racist.
White, black, yellow, red, or whatever, if you were going to do a person in, it might be done in a back alley.
This race card thing is getting absolutely rediculous and sickening.
Tiger knows Kelly. He knows what she meant.
It was meant to be light-hearted and actually recognizes Tiger's supreme talent.
Shame on Sharpton! Shame on The Golf Channel!!!!!!
Shame on people for their lack of forgiveness! I bet all the stone throwers have sinned, too, at some point in their lives.
This really makes me angry at the Golf Channel!!!!!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Cabong, Charlotte, NC — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 15:05:44 GMT

Sir, your column is normally one I enjoy tremendously but I feel you are off base this time. It isn't your fault, but you don't realize how harmful and hurtful the word "lynch" is to Blacks. I'm not Al Sharpton's biggest fans and I think there are times the man cites racism where perhaps none exists. But unless you grew up listening to the awful stories of lynching and other barbaric acts visited upon black men, you can't understand. I'm a black man of 42 years old, born in 1965. My parents and grandparents, out of love and fear, expalined the dangers of being a black man in America and the punishments often carried out by lynch mobs as they were growing up. I've seen the pictures and read the stories of lynching. I'm sorry, but using that word in a joke is akin to finding humor in the holocaust: it simply doesn't fly. Your column is your opinion but in fact, the word "lynch" has no place in broadcasting. Who knows why Tiger reacted as he did? Perhaps the money machine that is Tiger Woods didn't want to jeopardize his tremendous cash flow. I've always liked his golf, his character, his ability to handle pressure on the golf course. But as a black man, my feelings for him are now diminished because a simple condemnation of the word in an eloquent and tolerant statement would have been adequate to help quell this type of language going forward and to establish that he understands the racial issues in this country. Tiger missed the ball on this one.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kenneth Scoby, Florence, SC. — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 16:40:37 GMT

I am a 37 year old b/m who is a new player to the game of golf. The problem I see in this Kelly Tighlmann issue is that the main people who are propelling the issue do not understand or probably play the game of golf, so they do not understand the analogy of her statement... Not saying that it wasn't a poor choice of words, which they were. But it is way too overblown. I appreciate her wit and candor as an anchor.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Forrest, New York — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 17:08:23 GMT

Mike you're 100% right. Should the network have yanked her aside and said 'Next time lets think things through'? Of course. But instead they let one loud mouthed man claim racism and bend to his will. Personally, Al Sharpton is a walking joke to me. And one more thing: John Wolfe, would you say 'He should be gassed in a back alley'? No you wouldn't. In context, her term makes much more sense-- without racism, than yours.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Marc, wish i was in Myrtle still — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 20:20:23 GMT

Shocking that in 2008 there is ANYONE in this great land of ours who somehow thinks 'lynch him' is NOT offensive and dripping with racism. That Tiger is black and the other 'less offensive alternatives' (ie, 'mug') wasn't used only proves the point. What folks say in private is thier own business, among friends/family/etc. But on television it's downright inexcusable. The person herself should have demanded that she be allowed to recant and apologize, and should have known that in this day and age the comment would be picked up and then blown up. I agree that Sharpton is annoying (and have probably been following him for longer than anyone on this page as I was born 'n raised in NYC), but still... when you say something THAT stupid it's your responsibility to apologize and take responsibility for your actions. That's what television and those involved in it should be teaching and preaching. Shame on the producers at Golf Channel for not catching it early and nipping it in the bud like they should have.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim, Fredricksburg, VA — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 20:34:50 GMT

I was mugged and everytime I hear the word it brings shivers to my spine. Who will step forward and protect me from this injustice?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

KM, Moutain View CA — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 23:05:26 GMT

Mr. Woods is not ONLY a black man, he is Asian, he is white, he is a mixed breed as most of us now are.. one way or the other.

Deeds hurt people, not words. I learned this on the playground in elementary school. You don't like what someone says, turn and walk away. Until they physically hurt you, you have the ability to decide what words will hurt you and what will not. Your decision.

I do not believe Ms. Tilghman's comments were intent on hurting Tiger. Nor do I think that anything she or anyone else could say could hurt him. He has total control of his feelings. He'll decide what hurts him and what doesn't.

If Kelly's comments didn't offend him, then we as extreme outsiders should have NO right to tell him or anyone else what is hurtful.

To the point: Take some responsibility for your own emotions and decide.. Are you going to let something someone else says hurt you? If yes, then you have given the person that said the comments the power to control your emotions and subsquently have great impact and control of your life.

Not me! No one can say anything to me that I do not take FULL responsibility for reacting to. MY CHOICE!

Also, I too learned later in my teens about the horrible way in which African-Americans were treated by their white captors in America. I was raised on Westerns and thought lynching was a "cowboy" thing.

I'm offended as a white person, that I am blamed for slavery. Something of which I had nothing to do with, would never have condoned but yet am still accused and tried for. I don't understand the concept of "condem the children for the father's sins". My father didn't own slaves either.

I can do my part and speak up when I see racism and bigotry happen.. and I DO!!!! But I don't care if the person is blue, purple or sprinkled with polka dots! I will stand up for anyone being treated unfairly and unjustly for the sake of their religion, race, creed....etc. I believe in what many great leaders have said. We are all people... that is the bottom line. We treat people the way we want to be treated then we have no problem.

So the question is: if you made a remark, that you had no intention of being taken in a wrong way...would you want forgiveness? Would you deserve forgiveness? Isn't forgiveness something a Reverend be touting???

It's up to us, people! Learn from the past, don't wallow and fester in it. Teach the lessons..don't use the past to insight fear and pain. I doubt anyone on the board would ever allow lynching of any kind to happen to any race ever again! We have learned that much I hope!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Bob Duron — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 01:32:21 GMT

I responded to this incident in regards to another article, and I will state again, as I did on the my previous email, that I find it very offensive that al sharpton has the word "reverend" in front of his name. This incident, at worst, is a bad choice of words, and should have been put to rest. What we have here is a man who saw an opportunity to get another fifteen minutes of fame. If his title of "Reverend" is really applicable, where is his compassion and forgiveness? This is another example of shameful behavior on the part of this individual.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John doe — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 02:12:55 GMT

I was offended, I'm a descendant of a cattle thief and that word brings up horrific memories of a past I can't remember because I wasn't there. People should stop waving the banner of history without looking at it as a whole. White people were slaves once too. And white folks were also lynched. Her choice of words were incredibly out of place, but the person her words are directed towards said he accepted her apology. Since when are you required to apologize to all black people when you direct a comment towards one? I thought we were all individuals, or did Al Sharpton change that from his mountain top?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Marty Miller, Los Angeles CA — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 02:15:36 GMT

I wonder if humans will ever evolve to the point where they can let words just be words and stop acting like the the world ended because somebody said them.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Doug Zecher, Liberty Township OH — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 02:44:06 GMT

Mr. Celizic, thank you for standing up to the true racist in this issue. The definition of the word lynch has no racial connotations. I, like you was first exposed to the word in Western movies.

KT is the one getting lynched and reverend AL is holding the rope.

Shame on the Golf Channel for not standing by thier own.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Brian Mahoney, Seattle, WA — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 03:26:36 GMT

Mike, as usual you obtusely missed the point. Lynching was a violent technique used in the United States up into the early 1960s to marginalize black men. Kelly's comment was equal or worse than Imus' comments on nappy hair.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Chad Dixon — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 08:31:33 GMT

In all actuality I think we should look at this situation in a different light. By Tiger saying essentially that "it's no big deal" we see where Mr. Woods’ head is really at. If someone uses a racial slur around me that is not directed towards me it makes me uncomfortable but it doesn't pain me. In this context the suggestion that the competition should lynch Tiger is not hurtful to Mr. Woods because he doesn't see himself as being Black/American American/any other euphemism people choose to describe people of West African decent in the US. Why should Tiger feel anything about such a comment? He's not Black/African American/any other euphemism used to describe people of West African decent in his own mind. If there was any question before, I think this clears up where Eldridge Woods resides in his own mind. He is a “citizen on the world” who is not trivialized by constructs of color-lines that Americans are so concerned with.

In the end, it was an offensive remark to make. Nothing will ever change that. And to all the people who are defending Mike and/or this commentator try telling your one and only friend of color that they should be lynched to their face and see their reaction. If you are still standing it’s because they are like TW or you are their boss and they can’t afford to lose their job in this economy. :)

BTW Mike, please update your picture to includ your hood and buring cross.

God Bless America!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Herstory07 — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 18:11:06 GMT

The only reason the Golf Channel suspended her is because Al Sharpton threatened to protest their offices in Orlando, Fl. I think that although her comment was blurted out and not something she probably planned on saying, I agree that it does not merit suspending (or firing) her. No one seems to be in an uproar about Hillary Clinton's "plantation" comment. In fact, Al Sharpton SUPPORTED Hillary after he heard her say that. So, there is an apparent double-standard. Either referring to lynching and/or running a slave house is WRONG, or it's not. Besides, isn't there room in the 1st Amendments for "Ooops, I never should've said that?" If she said it to be malicious or malign Woods, then that's ONE thing, but it was an accidental "shouldn't have said it" moment. If Tiger isn't offended, then let it go. Besides, it was between Tilghman and Woods, not Tilghman, Woods, Sharpton, and everyone else who wants to get their name in lights for a full fifteen minutes of fame. (By the way, I do not condone racial harassment, however, making a stupid AND accidental comment as compared to... hanging a NOOSE from a tree or on a doorknob are two different things.)

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Omar - Seattle WA — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 18:28:37 GMT

The article may not be the most thought out piece of Journalism I have ever seen, but he does make a point. I do not beleive that Kelly Tilghman(however you spell her name) had any malice or intent of racism in her comments. It is well known that she and Tiger have a very long history and personal friendship, so by that alone I am willing to give her a pass on the whole she is a racist thought. She did use poor judgement in wording, and for that she should pay her penence (poor speller here). two weeks is appropriate, for her comments. As for one sided racism, and some of the other issues, those are far bigger than some message board on MSNBC. Poor choice of words, she is serving her time, and she'll be back in a week. Next time hopefully she'll be smart enough to use MUG, or just simply express that they should work as hard as he does and try to out play him, which we all know aint going to happen, but that as well is another story.....

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

RT Joplin Mo — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 18:31:53 GMT

we would be better off if Al Sharpton were not around. This "guy" if you can call him that, causes more trouble than anyone. Maybe her comment should have been directed at al "racist" sharpton. This coward of a man is a pig. Maybe he should move to another country if he isn't happy here. oh wait, he wouldn't be able to make the money there that he does here. how old is he? i only ask because i wonder how much longer we have to put up with him.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jim Ellis...Rocky Mount NC — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 18:35:33 GMT

You folks that condem what Kelly said should get a life. Anyone that knows her or even watches the G> Channel knows that she meant nothing by it. And you folks can call Al Sharpton a Reverand all you want to. With his hatered toward whites, he's about as much a Reverand as you and I are. He affends me a hell of a lot more than anything I've heard anyone say on TV. An apology is never enough for Sharpton and his cronnies, they want the white person fired, hoping that a black will take their place. Come on
America, can't you catch on to his a Jesse"James" Jackson's game. The only difference in them adn an outlaw is an outlaw used a gun and these two have special interest groups. To hell with both of them

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Les Rose, Reno, NV. — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 20:04:47 GMT

I totally agree with your article. In my opinion Mr. Sharpton and Rev. Jesse Jackson do as much to promote racism as do skin heads and the neo-nazi's. I think that the Golf Channel is more in the wrong than Kelly Tilghman. I still don't understand why lynching is associated with only blacks when many whites were lynched for stealing cattle, horses, sheep, etc.

Les Rose

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kathy, Coral Springs FL — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 20:30:26 GMT

I was indeed offended by the comment ... and I am not Rev. Sharpton. However, I agree a 2 weeks suspension was extemely harsh. An on-air apology to the viewing public, and a personal letter to Tiger Woods would have more than covered it. We all have slips of the tongue now and again, pity the perfect person who does not. We acknowlege it, apologize and move on.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kim Perkins — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 03:59:16 GMT

I agree with the guy who said lynching was a wild west kind of thing. On TV, a bunch of white cowboys jump to conclusions and lynch another white guy for rustling cows or something. But since blacks were lynched in the 60s and earlier, they now think they own the word "lynch." And what about "Lynchburg" Virginia? What about that. Or Merrill Lynch? Or Jessica Lynch? Stop already.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Herb, Charlotte NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 04:04:45 GMT

It pains me to read all of these comments. It seems like more people are upset with Al Sharpton then the actual words that were said. So what if he got in front of a camera and said those words were racist? They were! Have you seen pictures of a lynching? Do you understand just how violent and horrible that word represents? I am sure she didn’t mean to say it, but to have that word floating in the head of a professional commentator is disappointing. It makes you wonder why she was even thinking that. I don’t expect Tiger to come to a microphone and say he wasn’t offended. He should be, but I am sure he will digest it on his own. The fact that more people are upset that Al Sharpton said something than what she said is troubling. I didn’t see this much outrage in the 3 days before the Golf Channel suspended her…that is a very big problem. And the fact that Golf Week put that picture on their cover is horrible. I will never purchase another magazine from them. That image shook me to the core.

Could someone explain to me why they are more upset with Al than Kelly?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jerry Wilmington NC — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 16:55:32 GMT

I love watching Golf on TV (oops) used to watch Golf on TV. Sorry but not anymore if this statement was a reason for Golf chanel to dismiss one of its family for the useless Sharpton racism.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ann, Jasper, FL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 17:14:05 GMT

I say get over it. Pretty soon there won't be any words left in our vocabulary to use because it will "offend" someone. History is history but that doesn't mean the words are meant bad. Wonder when we won't be able to say "black man" anymore?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

reuben. Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 17:42:30 GMT

Mike,
You see it never stops. How do you think people would react if Tiger were Jewish and they said burn him?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Willam J. Steed, III, Mobile, AL — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 18:07:32 GMT

I think that Sharpton, as a black man, can feel offended. I felt is was extremely offensive as well. However, Tiger Woods accepted her apology and that should be the end of it. A two week suspension is not uncommon for a radio/tv personality that says something stupid. Howard Cosell was fired for saying, "Look at that monkey run..." If it was a white guy that she suggested be lynched, it would be different. Lynching has a horrible and I'll say evil history when it comes to blacks. I think the suspension is justified. After that, forget about it.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Dan — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 18:30:06 GMT

I disagree with Celzic that she didn't deserve the suspension, but I agree with him that Sharpton is a blow-hard moron.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Kevin — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 19:18:13 GMT

It is so hard to not make mistakes in life. In today's "climate" I wish there were room for forgiveness. I am sure Kelly is as hard on herself about her mistake as Sharpton. Kelly was the first woman broadcaster for the PGA. She knows what is at stake for her career as well as opening the door for other women into broadcasting.

I am pretty sure Kelly has the utmost respect for Tiger and his accomplishments.

No matter what anyone says there is a large segment of our population that views the term "lynching" as being derogatory in nature.

Anyone can think of 20 different statements Kelly could have said that would had been appropriate in that situation. Of course hind sight is 20/20.

Kelly's comment was a mistake or she would not be appolgizing for her words.

I am not offended at all with her joke. I do think this will effect her performance for the worse in the future. She will be over cautious, boring, and mundane. I think she is an excellent fit for Faldo. I hope that she uses the current attention wisely.

She has chosen to be in the public eye as a career. The criticism comes with the job. Good luck Kelly.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

cg — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 19:26:43 GMT

Al Sharpton is right. We must realize Tiger Woods is from a younger generation that has not been taught about the evil lynchings that were once common place in this Nation aimed to terrorize
black people to control them. That is why Tiger Woods could accept the racist derogatory
remarks of Kelly Tilghman without blinking an eye.

There many black folk from older generations that know the history of the lynching black people, especially in
the South. And there are a high percentage of black people overall that think it is very disrespectful and hurtful to use the term lynching, not just Al Sharpton.

It is easy for a white person to say it,s not a big deal to use the term "lynch a black man" because the white race was never systematically terrorized in America with lynching violence.

Whether intentional or not, Ms. Tilghman should not have used the term lynching in the context that she placed it in, over the public airways, making a joke against Tiger Woods. She is suppose to be a media professional and know better.

It was very insensitive and irresponsible and Ms. Tilghman deserves to be punished based on her own doing.

If left unchecked, certain media outlet personalities would routinely spew venom and vile over the public airways, aimed to hurt certain groups of people and the consequences would be very tragic for this nation.

P.S. Whats in the heart and mind will eventually come out of the mouth.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Anthony, Chicago, Illinois — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 19:47:02 GMT

This is crazy to me. I suppose I COULD understand why people feel lynching is associated with the old west. But how can those of you who are making this argument vehemently DENY that when "lynch" is used in conjunction with "African-American" and "in a back alley", that the term and more importantly, the imagery is not soaked in bitterness and pain for a specific group of people in this country??? If you don't get it, perhaps, Black History Month needs to be extended past February and into March!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Conan The Destroyer — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 20:15:20 GMT

Everybody is entirely too sensitive. She obviously meant nothing personal, Tiger said as much. If doesn't care, why would anyone else. America has changed indeed, into a bunch of candy ass whiners.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Rebecca Alfaro, Lansing, MI — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 20:43:00 GMT

Heck no Kelly should NOT have been supspended. She should have been FIRED-IMMEDIATELY! As long as she is the golf channel anchor me and at least ten others are not watching. Why don't someone take her in a back alley and do something to her? Doesn't sound too good does it Kelly?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ms Martin — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 21:34:35 GMT

I think that America needs to take a real LOOK at race relations and quit trying to deny that there is not a difference made. The comment was racist and anyone living in this country with the slightest bit of awareness of America's historical connotation to lynchings should be offended black or white! The Jenna event has taught us nothing I guess. If black people continue to ignore these tail-tale word slips we may find ourselves slipping back to a time that was as hostile toward us in word and in deed. Zero tolerance should be the standard especially when you are in the public eye.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

MIssy — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 22:45:34 GMT

I think America has become to sensitive to things that are said. You can't open your mouth anymore without someone acusing you of being racist. I am not racist, but I believe I have the right to say what I want without having to apoligize for it. If someone were to make a comment about "white" people or any other race, hey its your opinion. I don't let someone's opinion of me or my race get me all worked up.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Adelle — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 23:02:23 GMT

Ms. Tilghman's remarks didn't just offend Rev. Sharpton, but many other people as well. She did deserve the suspension even if Tiger accepted her apology. The noose has a specific connotation for Black people just as the Holocast and/or anti-semitic remarks have for Jewish people. So just think how you would feel, Mike, if that connection had been made.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ray — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 23:25:17 GMT

It's nice to see that all these comments are pretty much the same. And that is trying to direct the attention to AL instead of the fact that the word lynch should not even be in anyone's vocabulary. She is an adult with plenty of word's to pick from to humor the crowd, let her take her punishment like a woman.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Grace, Garland, TX — Sat, 19 Jan 2008 16:58:21 GMT

As a woman I am disgusted by her comments and it shows her lack of intelligence. Have we not grown as a society that comments like those would not even be thought of or communicated. She shows a real lack of judgement and should not be able to speak her mind if she is continually allowed to make comments like that. The editor of Golf Week was fired, why wasn't she?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Andrew Price, Ludlow, NB — Sat, 19 Jan 2008 17:24:19 GMT

The real travesty here is how easily Al Sharpton gets face time on a supposedly serious news channel like CNN. Al Sharpton and others like him perpetrate racism as much as anyone. Without they wouldn't have a job. In my opinion people are way over sensitive and get offended way to easy today. What was done to Kelly Tilghman is just pandering and a show of weakness by the Golf Channel. While lynchings were carried out on blacks during a dark time in US history, they are far from being the only ones who were lynched. People just need to get over themselves. Thanks for your time.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Jonathan, Sioux City Iowa — Sat, 19 Jan 2008 21:09:21 GMT

Color has nothing to do with race, period. We are all part of the human race, created by the same Creator. We MUST stop glamorizing those that seek to bring attention to themselves by causing controversy and division by taking sides with the public remark du jour. Let's start bringing attention to those who seek to bring unity and peace to this world.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Steve, Los Angeles, CA — Sat, 19 Jan 2008 22:00:01 GMT

“Lynch him in a back alley,” laughed Tilghman.

The ignorance about the term "lynching" and its place in US history displayed by Tilghman, MSNBC.com contributor Mike Celizic, and many posters here is staggering.

"Lynching" doesn't just have "racial connotations", as Mike Celizic euphemistically puts it. "Lynching" was deadly WHITE RACIST TERROR carried out against people of color in the US from the end of the Civil War until well into the 1950s and beyond in order to keep them "in their places" after SLAVERY had been legally abolished.

"Lynching" was the practice of the public murder WITHOUT TRIAL WITHOUT JUSTICE of a black man or woman or child by a LAWLESS WHITE MOB, often with the cooperation of white law officers and government officials. Certainly no white person was arraigned or convicted by any US or state government during the period.

What does US white terrorism look like? Check out this movie:

http://www.withoutsanctuary.org/main.html

The US Senate actually BLOCKED anti-lynching laws for 80 years! The Senate finally got around in 2005 to APOLOGIZING for obstructing justice and equal protection of the law as guaranteed under the US Constitution. Here is Louisiana Senator Mary Landrieu speaking on the Senate floor:

http://www.democracynow.org/2005/6/14/senate_apologizes_for_not_enacting_anti

Go and educate yourselves.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Gerry Jon Arlington, VA — Sun, 20 Jan 2008 00:22:57 GMT

I am not black but the the comment that Tilghman made is very offensive and she should be fired not suspended. I will never watch the golf channel as long as she is employed there. Golf week magazine - goodbye.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JC — Sun, 20 Jan 2008 15:59:46 GMT

I'm no Al Ahrpton fan, but who are you to say she was suspended for just offending Al Sharpton? Unless you're an African American, you have no clue as to who she offended. Give me a break.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Matt, Appe Valley, MN — Sun, 20 Jan 2008 18:54:01 GMT

Wow! Couldn't agree with you more, Mike! This is the FIRST article I have read with this tone, and it's something I was hoping to see!!! One of the high-tech CEO's said it best... Al Sharpton, Like Jesse Jackson is a sea gull, they pride themselves on flying in, crapping on everything, and flying out.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

norm, newark, ohio — Mon, 21 Jan 2008 11:47:06 GMT

i dont think sharpten was watching the golf channel. it didnt become a problem until the rev. said so. if this little incident bothers all of you polictly correct snobs i dont know how you leave your homes every day. sharpten and jackson make their living stirring up the pot and for the most part a lot of you fine folks buy into their venom.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Joe Senkiewicz — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 00:05:34 GMT

This is a joke. You can't say anything or the press will turn it into a bias crime. Tiger said she was his friend and friends can say just about anything about another friend when joking and the press should not turn the comment into a crime. Are we that hungry to sell TV adds and newspapers that we willfully hurt people? Freedom of the press does not mean they have the right to sensor or attack people unless they mean harm. Shame on all of you. No harm was meant by that comment.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Celeste J, Albuquerque, NM — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 00:28:51 GMT

I grew up in Arizona and 'lynching' was something someone did to a horse thief in the Old West, not a hanging of a black person in the South. It really does have to do with where you are raised. Even when I heard about this, the Old West came to mind, not the Deep South.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Sam Edge, Danville, CA — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 00:36:40 GMT

What has happened to free speech? You may find it offensive, some do, but we need to get back to the basic freedoms in this country. Just because you don't like the words, or how it was referenced doesn't mean you have the right, or even moral authority, to call for her firing.

Most importantly, the individual it was used against has said it is an event which is over. Truly it should end there.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Brian Duncan — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 01:25:17 GMT

I think that Mike is a Notre Dame graduate. I wonder would he care to engage Father Theodore Hesburgh in a dialogue about lynching and black people. During my time, Class of '71 Father Hesburgh was the Chairman of the US Civil Rights Commission. I assure you that the word lynching would not be benignly used by Father Ted. Perhaps Mike may have forgotten where America has come from. After all Dr. King was murdered in 1968 while Mike was in ND. What Al Sharpton says or doesn't say has nothing to do with the hisotry of the comments or the magazine cover.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ben Pleasnt — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 01:49:29 GMT

Racism is going only one way these days. Imus gets fired for saying "ho" but ESPN invites that rapper
(Ludicris) to perform at their pre-SuperBowl party. His lyrics are X-rated, at best, against women, especially black women. Where's big Al when this party was announced?

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Baffled — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 02:40:39 GMT

Good lord, if it wasn't meant to be racest, why the big fuss!!! Grow up folks, this isn't news, people are really dying in the world!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

LOUIE MORFE, NORTHVILLE, MICHIGAN 48167 — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 02:45:34 GMT

when i came to america 40 years ago, our tv,radio, telephone and other ways to amuse the family is very primitive. we all survive and happy to be with our friends and neighbors. how?, the great american sense of humor!!!, got us thru vietnam, and several conflict among nation.our secret weapon is no other than mr. bob hope,if bob hope used anybody for his material, you just made it bigtime. if mr hope were alive to hear kelly about lynching tiger because of how good tiger is , he migth call kelly to offer his help to lynch tiger out of jealousy, because he raised the level of excellence beyond bob reach.
so, cut out all your sensitivities, joke is A joke, a bad good joke is still a joke. everybody shut up, AL SHARPTON, START PREACHING AGAIN, KELLY GO BACK TO WORK, TIGER TEE IT UP.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

JD, San Antonio, TX — Tue, 22 Jan 2008 03:16:46 GMT

http://www.withoutsanctuary.org/main.html

Please review this website to understand why their is such a ruckus over the word "lynching".

After you reviewed the site, let's see if you still feel the same way over the usage of such a word.

Thank You

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Patrick Silva, Albuquerque, NM — Wed, 23 Jan 2008 03:40:12 GMT

I can't believe this is being discussed in a serious light. Then again, media mongers discuss Britney Spears every move. At what point do we take Al Sharpton and sew his mouth shut. This is ridiculous. We spend so much time apoligizing and righting the wrongs of yesterday, that we forget about today. Please, if Kelly were angry or trying to put Tiger down, fine, she's out of line. She's Tiger's friend for God's sake. If anyone should be concerned it would be Tiger. Obviously, he's not concerned. So why do we let Al Sharpton say whatever he wants. Al Sharpton is asking us to affect someone's life, and we let him get away with it. He's capitalizing on his ancestors misfortunes, not his concern for his people. He's the one who should be disgusted with himself and we should be disgusted with him. I can't believe we spend so much time with similar issues. We change team mascots to apease native americans. Come on people, it's a frickin mascot. Wow, I can't believe how angry this subject makes me. What a bunch of whiners!!!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Ken Johnson — Wed, 23 Jan 2008 20:45:17 GMT

Sharpton needs to review some of the old westerns (99.9% white actors); there were a lot of "let's lynch 'em", "we lynch rustlers around here", etc. To say that the word lynch has a racial connotation is completed ridiculous. People with attitudes like Sharpton are what keeps racism alive, taking a completely innocent remark and charging it as racial.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

tim — Thu, 24 Jan 2008 00:34:51 GMT

Mike,

You moved me to laugh at your thinking of the word lynch,I read all of your takes on issues and will contiune.But on this one, get pass Al and just look back on a little place call Jena,then get in front of a mirrow and please try to understand there are familes like mine who had love ones who did die at the hands of a .... rope. By the way I wrote the golf channel to ask that they not suspend Kelly but instead let her and Tiger go out in front of the media to show that they have move on. I disagree with you also by saying shame on the network, they are the only judge in case.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

RWOR Foxboro — Thu, 24 Jan 2008 11:51:54 GMT

Shame on CNN for giving Al Sharpton the air time, people need to lighten up. Although offensive it was a joke nothing more, the double standards have to end. She laughed as she said it, that was an attempt at comedy. IT WAS A JOKE, take it as it is and get over it. The self proclaimed reverend Al Sharpton, he is the racist. If Tiger and his agent understood, then everyone else should too. Watch an old cowboy movie, they lynched cowboys in those movies, could that be racism against cowboys? Take it as a joke and nothing more, and make Al Sharpton accountable. What's next a delay sililar to talk shoew to make sure no one gets offended. Or maybe better Al Sharpton and JEsse Jackson could become anchors, that would solve everything, they could do morning radio and then all broadcasting on TV then we would live in a perfect world...

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Juanita, Kansas — Thu, 24 Jan 2008 20:27:16 GMT

I agree with using Oprah as an example. We see this on football programs all the time. I remember Deion Sanders saying things no white man would have gotten away with.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tom S, Franklin, PA — Mon, 28 Jan 2008 16:59:06 GMT

Who cares if other people were offended? Nearly everything written or broadcast causes someone to be offended. I'm tired of people adding thier meaning to something they didn't say. If Tiger wasn't offended, then drop it.
Another recent article said that for performance enhancing drug testing, we should only test Tiger; if he's clean, we din't need to test anyone else. Did this imply that no one else was physically capable of beating him? Or did it mean Tiger could be doing drugs??
To me, the most racist people in this country are some of the more vocal african-americans (ie Reverends Jackson and Sharpton). If the white community is the problem, then why do we have the Miss Black America, the United Negro College Fund, the NAACP? Would a miss White America pagent, or the caucasion college fund, or the NAAWP be allowed to operate? This doesn't sound like a group who wants equal rights.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

John O'Connor, Dedham, MA — Mon, 28 Jan 2008 21:38:29 GMT

There never will be peace until black people get over their feeling of being constantly insulted or put down. The remark was not meant to hurt or insult anyone and every one knows it. If tiger had a little less skin pigment nobody would have noticed the remark at all. People say things like this all the time and everyone knows they are joking. Do we have to have different jokes for each race ? That doesn't sound equal to me. I'd like to feel that what ever I can say to a white person I can say to anyone.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Cliff, Toronto, ON — Fri, 01 Feb 2008 07:39:49 GMT

Inappropriate for her to say it
Inappropriate for this article to defend her
Inappropriate for msnbc to post this article

Like colored pioneer athletes before him, Tiger has to hold his tongue lest it gets cut out (metaphorically speaking).

Tiger played his role and Al Sharpton played his. You guys may not like him, heck, I don't like him, but he plays an important role.

All you people who think that comment was no big deal... It was no big deal to those who use to do the lynching. That's why Al HAS to make himself heard. Give you an inch and you'll take a mile.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

M. Posey, Chicago, IL — Tue, 12 Feb 2008 22:36:13 GMT

For each of you who insist that the word lynch is "no big deal" and that Black Americans are being hypersensitive and thin skinned, I invite you to gaze upon the photos and read the essay in this link. http://www.liu.edu/cwis/cwp/library/african/2000/lynching.htm
Many of you were living when these photos were taken. If you can honestly say that speaking of being lynched is "no big deal" then America is worse off than we think. Forget Messers. Sharpton and Jackson for a moment and consider that Ms. Tilghman did not speak those words where only Mr. Woods could hear them. She insulted every Black American who was ever affected by this atrocity, which is every single one of us. And to anyone who insists that we should "just get over it" clearly has no clue. Shame on her. Mike Celizic and anyone of any ethnic background that thinks this is "no big deal".

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

David Tate — Tue, 12 Feb 2008 22:40:49 GMT

I'm white, 60, and have seen many shows depicting the lynching of white men over my life. I thought about this incident and for the life of me I couldn't come up with a racist tone to her statement. But I don't have a large of like Sharpton whose job is to examine every piece of American life to find something racist in it. Besides, if you would examine her statement in the conotation it was made, you might see that she was complimenting Tiger. I'm glad Tiger is a bigger man than Sharpton.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

dave ant, new york,ny — Tue, 12 Feb 2008 23:15:46 GMT

i think until white americans realize the hurt that comes with the insensitive remarks they make the next generation is in alot of trouble...2007 was a year for white folks 2 show their true racist colors.....and the idiots replyn sayn it was not that serious,should take a look in the mirror

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Mike, Denver — Tue, 12 Feb 2008 23:46:19 GMT

I normally spend more time reading comments and I never respond, however in this case I think I will. I am a Black Male and have no use for Sharpton, Jackson, Clinton or Bush, they all play on people's ignorance and fear.

I do not know much about the lady commentator, and I do not beleive she should have been suspended. But I do know that she went to the University of South Carolina and I'd be hard press to beleive that she had no idea of the connotation of the word lynching. That being said'I think she was just trying to be cute and witty (which is another term for look at me) and meant no harm.

In regards to Al Sharpton he has his own personal agenda, which frankly is no different than Jackson, Clinton or Bush. They assume that people are gullible, naieve and ignorant. As long as people buy into it, they are right

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Tue, 12 Feb 2008 23:59:46 GMT

I see the word innocent used often in regards to Tilgham's comment. Only babies in a mother’s womb are innocent. But immediately after birth we become corrupted. We don’t always learn right from wrong because that’s all a matter of ones opinion. What we do learn for our selves is that we can all be held accountable in some way shape or form for our actions. Though it is not for us to judge, we do so never the less. This article illustrates to me the deeply imbedded seeds of hate, racism, and negativity we all carry in our individual subconscious. We are all guilty and if we would stop trying to justify our short comings and instead, be relentless in our striving for perfection, these issues wouldn’t re-occur perpetually. Human beings have great potential. But our decision making limits us from realizing true harmony. The sooner we stop lying to ourselves the sooner we can make our world a better place for all…

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Just Forgive you may need it back someday. — Wed, 13 Feb 2008 00:10:06 GMT

The reality of lynching is horrible in its diverse history. But I don't think the golf reporters comment was meant to harm Tiger or the listeners or become a battlecry to literally approve of this horrible act. Quite clutching your pearls in shock. and look at real racism in jobs, drugs, poverty. Someone being held back because of race probably was to busy to be watching the Golf Channel and its pointless little drama, they were looking for a way to get ahead to achieve their own successes.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Alice Morris — Wed, 13 Feb 2008 00:28:18 GMT

I agree with his comments. I'm part Indian and I take no offense to 'scalping' comments or "indian giver". Sharpton needs to sit down and shut up. He is a racist himself but why is he allowed to tell people what they can say. I always associated lynching with westerns and the old west. Sharpton should have no say it in even if Tiger was offended or not. She should not even have been suspended but just talked to. That editor should not have been fired either due to the 1st amendment. I don't like a lot of things that are said in America or done, but whether offensive or not, we have the right of the 1st amendment of free speech. This is still America,is it not!

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Neville Schouburgh, Sanford,Florida — Wed, 13 Feb 2008 01:49:39 GMT

Lynching comment is no Joke. People died and are still dying as a result fo the racial devide in the U.S.

'Lynch Tiger' wasn't worth suspension

Richard Harvey, Las Vegas, NV — Mon, 18 Feb 2008 01:50:21 GMT

While it's true that Al Sharpton is an anti-white racist, that's no excuse for a golf announcer who makes stupid cracks that smell like racism. And the comment itself was offensive, whether it was honest to God racism or just idiot talk. Suggesting that someone should commit violence against the world's top golfer (who's the consummate gentleman and ambassador for the game of golf) is not funny. A broadcaster in this day and age should know that there are those in the audience who take "jokes" like this seriously and therefore today's broadcaster should exercise a little discretion.